Abstract
We carefully examine common measures of dynamical heterogeneity for a model polymer melt and test how these scales compare with those hypothesized by the Adam and Gibbs (AG) and random first-order transition (RFOT) theories of relaxation in glass-forming liquids. To this end, we first analyze clusters of highly mobile particles, the string-like collective motion of these mobile particles, and clusters of relative low mobility. We show that the time scale of the high-mobility clusters and strings is associated with a diffusive time scale, while the low-mobility particles' time scale relates to a structural relaxation time. We find a high degree of similarity in the geometrical structure of these particle clusters. In particular, we show that the fractal dimensions of these clusters are consistent with those of swollen branched polymers or branched polymers with screened excluded-volume interactions. In contrast, the fractal dimension of the strings crosses over from that of self-avoiding walks for small strings, to simple random walks for longer, strings, corresponding to flexible polymers with screened excluded-volume interactions. We examine the appropriateness of identifying the size scales of either mobile particle clusters or strings with the size of cooperatively rearranging regions (CRR) in the AG and RFOT theories. We find that the string size appears to be the most consistent measure of CRR for both the AG and RFOT models. Identifying strings or clusters with the "mosaic" length of the RFOT model relaxes the conventional assumption that the "entropic droplets" are compact. We also confirm the validity of the entropy formulation of the AG theory, constraining the exponent values of the RFOT theory. This constraint, together with the analysis of size scales, enables us to estimate the characteristic exponents of RFOT.
Introduction
When a liquid cools toward its glass transition temperature ($T_g$), its viscosity and relaxation time increase by many orders of magnitude. Why this happens remains one of the deepest mysteries in condensed matter physics.
Two major theories attempt to explain this:
- Adam-Gibbs (AG) Theory: Suggests that as a liquid cools, particles must move in "Cooperatively Rearranging Regions" (CRR). As the liquid gets colder, these regions must get larger, making movement harder.
- Random First-Order Transition (RFOT) Theory: A more modern framework that describes the liquid as a "mosaic" of metastable states with a characteristic length scale $\xi$.
Neither theory provides a concrete, microscopic definition of what these regions actually look like. Meanwhile, simulations have long shown "dynamical heterogeneity"—the fact that some particles move much faster than others, often in clusters or strings. This paper asks: Can we identify these observed clusters with the theoretical CRRs of AG and RFOT?
Methodology
The authors performed extensive Molecular Dynamics (MD) simulations of a "bead-spring" polymer melt (400 chains of 20 monomers each).
- Identifying Mobility: They isolated the top 6.5% most mobile particles and the most "immobile" (caged) particles.
- Cluster Analysis: They grouped these particles into clusters based on proximity and further decomposed mobile clusters into "strings"—subsets of particles that follow each other in a co-linear, "follow-the-leader" fashion.
- Geometry: They calculated the fractal dimension ($d_f$) of these structures using the radius of gyration to see if they were compact blobs ($d_f = 3$) or sprawling structures ($d_f < 3$).
- Thermodynamics: They used thermodynamic integration to calculate the "configurational entropy" ($S_{conf}$), a key variable in both AG and RFOT theories.
Key Insights and Ideas
- The "Strings" Win: While both large mobile clusters and smaller strings grow as the liquid cools, the string size is the most consistent measure of the CRR size predicted by AG and RFOT theories.
- Fractal, Not Compact: A major assumption in many RFOT applications is that the "entropic droplets" (the mosaic pieces) are compact spheres. This paper finds they are actually fractal, resembling "lattice animals" or branched polymers. This suggests the theories need to be adjusted to account for non-compact geometry.
- Decoupling Explained: The authors found that mobile clusters track the timescale of diffusion ($t_M$), while immobile clusters track the timescale of structural relaxation ($t_I$). This naturally explains the "Stokes-Einstein breakdown"—a famous phenomenon where diffusion and viscosity stop tracking each other as a liquid nears $T_g$.
- Symmetry in Extremes: Surprisingly, despite moving at totally different speeds, the spatial structures of the most mobile and most immobile clusters are geometrically very similar (both look like branched polymers).
Key Results
- Validation of AG: The paper confirms the Adam-Gibbs relationship ($\tau \sim \exp[A/(T S_{conf})]$) holds remarkably well for this model.
- Fractal Dimensions: Mobile and immobile clusters have a fractal dimension $d_f \approx 2$ at high temperatures (like "lattice animals"), increasing to $\approx 2.5$ (like percolation clusters) as they cool.
- RFOT Exponents: By mapping the string length to the RFOT length scale, the authors estimated the RFOT scaling exponent $\psi \approx 1.3$. This is a significant finding, as previous estimates for $\psi$ have been highly inconsistent.
Limitations and Future Work
- Finite Size Effects: At the lowest temperatures, mobile clusters become so large they begin to "percolate" (span the entire simulation box), which may lead to an underestimation of their true size.
- Dimensionality: The degree of the Stokes-Einstein breakdown changes with spatial dimensionality. Future work could explore if these string-like CRRs exist and behave similarly in 2D or 4D systems.
- The "Mosaic" Definition: If the regions are fractal rather than compact, the concept of "surface tension" in RFOT theory becomes more complex. The authors suggest this fractal nature implies a need to revisit the fundamental surface-to-volume energy balance in the RFOT model.
Summary updated