The Relationship between Urban Green Space and Urban Expansion Based on Gravity Methods

Qizhen Li, Saroj Thapa, Xijun Hu, Ziwei Luo, David J. GibsonSustainability 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the complex relationship between urban green space and urban expansion in ten rapidly growing cities in China and the U.S. using a gravity center model. The findings reveal that while urban expansion and green space growth are synchronous, the proportion of green space is decreasing, suggesting a potential depletion of ecosystem services due to rapid, often unplanned, urban sprawl.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Urban green spaces are vital components of urban ecosystems, offering numerous environmental and social benefits. However, rapid urbanization, particularly in developing economies like China, often leads to urban sprawl, where city boundaries expand outwards, potentially at the expense of green areas. Understanding how urban green space dynamics interact with urban expansion is crucial for sustainable urban planning and ensuring the continued provision of essential ecosystem services. This paper aims to quantify and analyze the spatial relationship between the movement of population centers, economic centers, and urban green space centers over time in fast-growing cities, seeking to uncover patterns and potential imbalances.

Methods

The researchers employed a gravity center model to track the spatial movement of population, economic activity (GDP), and urban green space over an 18-year period (2000-2017). This model calculates a "center of gravity" for each attribute within a city, representing its spatial distribution. By analyzing the migration path and direction of these centers over time, the study quantifies how these elements shift in relation to each other.

Key methodological steps included:

  • Data Preparation: Spatially aligning population and economic data with urban green space data. For U.S. cities, this involved merging census block groups into a grid system for comparability.
  • Green Space Classification: Utilizing Landsat satellite imagery and the Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI) to classify vegetation (grasses, shrubs, trees, and agriculture) as green space. A Support Vector Machine (SVM) algorithm was used for classification.
  • Center of Gravity Calculation: Applying the gravity center formula (Equations 1 and 2 in the paper) to determine the coordinates of the population, economic, and green space centers for each city annually.
  • Circular Statistics: Converting the latitude and longitude coordinates of the gravity centers into radians to treat them as circular data. This allowed for the application of circular correlation and Watson-Williams tests to analyze the directional relationships and consistency of movement among the centers.

Datasets

The study utilized the following datasets:

  • Landsat satellite imagery: Acquired for ten cities (five in China, five in the U.S.) from 2000 to 2017. Gap-filled Landsat 7 ETM+ and Landsat 8 OLI scenes were used, focusing on summer seasons for spectral reflectance and selecting images with less than 20% cloud cover.
  • Population and economic data:
    • U.S. cities: Obtained from the U.S. Census Bureau, including population and economic data at the census block group level.
  • Chinese cities: Acquired from annual statistical yearbooks, including year-end population and local GDP at the district level.

The ten selected cities were:

  • China: Chengdu, Guangzhou, Nanjing, Wuhan, Xian
  • U.S.: Atlanta (GA), Columbus (OH), Denver (CO), Harrisburg (PA), Phoenix (AZ)

These cities were chosen for their representative rapid growth, significant land-use changes, and to cover diverse geographical regions within each country.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Divergent Movements: A significant finding is that in eight out of ten cities, the population and economic centers moved in a different direction than the urban green space center. This suggests that urban development and green space management are not always synchronized or aligned.
  • Centrifugal vs. Centripetal Forces: The study highlights that "centrifugal forces" (forces pushing development outwards, like market congestion and land rent increases) seem to play a larger role in urban change than "centripetal forces" (forces pulling development inwards, like market proximity and the appeal of green spaces).
  • Green Space Proportion Decline: Despite overall urban expansion and synchronous growth trends between green space and urban development, the proportion of urban green space within the total urban area decreased over the 18-year period. This is a critical indicator of potential environmental strain.
  • China vs. U.S. Dynamics: While both countries show urban expansion, the movement of population centers in China was generally faster and covered greater distances than in the U.S. This is attributed to China's ongoing rapid development and urbanization compared to the more established, slower-paced development in U.S. cities.
  • Physical Barriers Matter: Cities with natural barriers (like Phoenix with its desert and mountains, or Wuhan with the Yangtze River) showed a tendency for their population, economic, and green space centers to move in more similar directions, suggesting that physical constraints can influence urban spatial patterns.

Key Results

  • Synchronous Growth, Decreasing Proportion: Over 18 years, urban expansion and urban green space expansion showed a synchronous growth trend in the studied cities. However, the proportion of urban green space within the total urban area decreased.
  • Divergent Directions: In 80% of the cities, the population and economic centers moved in directions different from the green space center.
  • U.S. vs. China Movement:
    • The U.S. cities showed more consistent movement patterns for their green space centers compared to Chinese cities.
  • Chinese cities generally exhibited larger distances covered by their population and economic centers of gravity. For instance, Chengdu saw the largest movement for the green space center of gravity (58.41 km over 18 years).
  • Urban Expansion Outpacing Population Growth: The study indicates that the urban expansion rate exceeded the population growth rate, contributing to "unreasonable urban sprawl."
  • Statistical Significance: Watson-Williams tests confirmed a significant difference among the mean directions of movement for population, economic, and green space centers across all cities.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Inclusion of Agricultural Areas: The study acknowledges a limitation in including agricultural areas as green spaces, as this might have skewed the directional properties of core green spaces (parks, wooded areas). Future work could isolate these categories for a more nuanced analysis.
  • Population Data Estimation: For U.S. cities, population data for certain years (2005, 2015, 2017) were estimates based on 2000 and 2010 census data, which is noted as being as good as the estimating algorithm used by the U.S. Census Bureau.
  • Future Research Directions:
    • Deeper Classification: Isolating core urban green spaces from agricultural areas to better understand their distinct impacts.
  • Socio-Demographic Analysis: Classifying population centers by race, age, and income to explore their relationship with green space and economic center movements.
  • Comparative Policy Analysis: Conducting comparative studies of urban management plans and policies between the U.S. and China to understand how governance structures influence these spatial dynamics.
  • Global Context: Extending similar analyses to other regions, such as Europe, to gain a broader understanding of urban green space and expansion patterns.

Summary updated

Abstract

Urban green space, comprising parks, fields, woodlands, and other semi-natural areas, is a fundamental component of urban ecosystems. The determination of the relationship between urban green space and urban sprawl is necessary to understand urbanization and the provision of urban ecosystem services. It has been hypothesized that the center of urban (i.e., population and economic) areas in fast-growing cities would migrate toward urban green space over time. To test this hypothesis, urban expansion and urban green space expansion were examined in five cities in China and five cities in the U.S. that were experiencing high rates of growth. Landsat images of those cities from 2000 to 2017 were combined with annual population and economic data and used to quantify the extent and migration of the urban green space. These data were analyzed using the center of gravity method by Grether and Mathys and circular statistics were used to determine the relationship between urban green space and urban expansion. Eight out of the ten cities showed a divergent pattern, i.e., the population and economic centers moved in a different direction to that of the urban green space. The movement of the mean centers of the urban green spaces in the U.S. cities was more consistent than that of the Chinese cities. Over 18 years, the movement of urban green space and urban expansion in the 10 cities showed a synchronous growth trend; however, the proportion of urban green space in the cities decreased. The urban expansion rate exceeded the population growth rate, which led to problems with an unreasonable urban sprawl that is likely to deplete the provision of ecosystem services in the future. In conclusion, the centrifugal forces of urban green space that lead to the movement of population and economic centers away from green spaces play a larger role in urban change than the centripetal forces that pull these centers toward urban green space.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2022relationship,
  author = {Qizhen Li and Saroj Thapa and Xijun Hu and Ziwei Luo and David J. Gibson},
  title = {{The Relationship between Urban Green Space and Urban Expansion Based on Gravity Methods}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/su14095396},
}
Figure