The Relationship between Multiple Health Behaviours and Brachial Artery Reactivity

Jennifer L. Gordon, Kim Lavoie, André Arsenault, Bernard Meloche, Blaine Ditto, Tavis S. Campbell, Simon BaconInternational Journal of Hypertension 2012 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigated how multiple health behaviors (smoking, alcohol, obesity, physical activity) independently and collectively impact endothelial function (EF), a key indicator of cardiovascular health. The findings reveal that central adiposity (waist circumference) and past smoking are significant predictors of poor EF, while physical activity does not show a significant association in this at-risk population.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Endothelial function (EF) is crucial for cardiovascular health, and its impairment is an early predictor of cardiovascular events. While individual health behaviors like smoking, alcohol consumption, obesity, and sedentary lifestyles have been linked to poor EF, their relative contributions and independent effects within the same population, especially in individuals at high risk for cardiovascular disease (CVD), have not been well-established. This paper aims to fill this gap by comparing these four behaviors simultaneously to understand which ones are the most significant drivers of poor EF.

Methods

The researchers utilized a nuclear-medicine-based forearm hyperaemic reactivity (FHR) test to measure brachial artery reactivity, serving as a proxy for EF. This technique involves inflating a blood pressure cuff to induce hyperemia and then measuring the blood flow ratio between the hyperemic arm and a control arm using a radioactive tracer. This method is described as having high reproducibility. Health behaviors were assessed through self-report questionnaires for exercise, smoking habits, and alcohol consumption, while waist circumference was measured to assess central adiposity. Statistical analysis involved generalized linear models (GLMs) and logistic regression, controlling for covariates such as age, sex, CVD status, and medication use.

Datasets

The study utilized data from 328 patients referred for single-photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) exercise stress tests. This cohort was a substudy of the Mechanisms and Outcomes of Silent Myocardial Ischemia (MOSMI) study. The data collected included demographic information, medical history, self-reported health behaviors, and waist circumference measurements. No new datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Central Adiposity is King (for EF): Waist circumference emerged as the strongest and most consistent predictor of both continuous EF and the presence of endothelial dysfunction. This highlights the critical role of where fat is stored, not just how much.
  • Smoking's Lingering Damage: While current smoking didn't significantly predict poor EF in the logistic regression, past smoking was associated with a significantly increased risk of endothelial dysfunction. This suggests that the damage from smoking can have long-lasting effects, even after cessation.
  • Alcohol's Nuanced Role: Abstinence from alcohol was surprisingly linked to a higher risk of endothelial dysfunction, while heavy drinking did not show a significant association. Moderate drinking was the reference group. This contrasts with some expectations and suggests a complex, potentially J-shaped relationship.
  • Physical Activity's Elusive EF Link (in this context): In this population already at risk for CVD and likely engaging in other poor health behaviors, physical activity did not show a significant independent association with EF. This suggests that its impact might be overshadowed by other factors or that higher levels of activity are needed to see a measurable effect.
  • The Power of Multiple Behaviors: The study's strength lies in examining these behaviors together, allowing for the estimation of their independent effects and highlighting that interventions targeting multiple behaviors might be more effective.

Key Results

  • Continuous EF: Waist circumference was a significant independent predictor of EF (β = -0.03, P < .0001), indicating that higher waist circumference is associated with poorer EF. Physical activity, lifetime smoking (pack-years), and alcohol consumption were not significant predictors of continuous EF when all covariates and behaviors were included.
  • Endothelial Dysfunction (RUR < 3.55):
    • Increased waist circumference significantly increased the risk of endothelial dysfunction. The odds ratio for the third tertile (>108 cm) compared to the lowest tertile (<92 cm) was 2.39 (95% CI = 1.15–4.98).
  • Abstinence from alcohol was associated with a nearly double risk of endothelial dysfunction compared to moderate drinkers (OR = 1.99, 95% CI = 1.08–3.70).
  • Past smokers had double the risk of endothelial dysfunction compared to never smokers (OR = 2.00, 95% CI = 1.26–3.75).
  • Physical activity tertiles did not show significant associations with endothelial dysfunction.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Cross-sectional design: This prevents drawing definitive conclusions about cause and effect.
  • Retrospective self-report: Measures for physical activity, alcohol, and smoking are susceptible to recall bias.
  • Lack of detail on alcohol type: The study did not differentiate between types of alcoholic beverages, which might have different effects on EF.
  • Nicotine replacement therapy not recorded: This could be a confounding factor for smoking's impact.

Future work suggested includes:

  • Longitudinal studies: To understand how EF changes over time in relation to health behaviors.
  • Confirmation of mechanisms: Further research is needed to elucidate the precise biological pathways through which central adiposity, smoking, and alcohol influence EF.
  • Intervention studies: To confirm the impact of prioritizing weight reduction, smoking cessation, and moderate alcohol consumption over increasing physical activity in at-risk populations.
  • Exploring the role of physical activity: Investigating whether higher thresholds of physical activity are needed to observe an effect on EF in this population.

Summary updated

Abstract

Background. The effects of smoking, alcohol consumption, obesity, and a sedentary lifestyle on endothelial function (EF) have only been examined separately. The relative contributions of these behaviours on EF have therefore not been compared. Purpose. To compare the relative associations between these four risk factors and brachial artery reactivity in the same sample. Methods. 328 patients referred for single-photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) exercise stress tests completed a nuclear-medicine-based forearm hyperaemic reactivity test. Self-reported exercise behaviour, smoking habits, and alcohol consumption were collected and waist circumference was measured. Results. Adjusting for relevant covariates, logistic regression analyses revealed that waist circumference, abstinence from alcohol, and past smoking significantly predicted poor brachial artery reactivity while physical activity did not. Only waist circumference predicted continuous variations in EF. Conclusions. Central adiposity, alcohol consumption, and smoking habits but not physical activity are each independent predictors of poor brachial artery reactivity in patients with or at high risk for cardiovascular disease.
BibTeX
@article{gordon2012relationship,
  author = {Jennifer L. Gordon and Kim Lavoie and André Arsenault and Bernard Meloche and Blaine Ditto and Tavis S. Campbell and Simon Bacon},
  title = {{The Relationship between Multiple Health Behaviours and Brachial Artery Reactivity}},
  journal = {International Journal of Hypertension},
  year = {2012},
  doi = {10.1155/2012/846819},
}
Figure