The relationship between key natural and social factors and the transmission of novel coronavirus disease 2019 in China

Shengnan Lin, Yaman Li, Jia Rui, Yao Wang, Wang RuiXin, Zeyu Zhao, Yuanzhao Zhu, Meng Yang, Jingwen Xu, Xingchun Liu, Li Luo, Jingwei Chen, Dongbei Guo, Benhua Zhao, Yanhua Su, Feng Li, Yi‐Chen Chiang, Tianmu ChenResearch Square 2020 · DOI

Abstract

During the initial wave of the COVID-19 pandemic, researchers investigated how environmental and social variables influenced the spread of the virus across 21 regions in China. This study shifts the focus from total case counts to the Proportion of Local Infection (PLI) to distinguish between imported cases and community transmission. Findings indicate that higher temperatures and lower latitudes significantly reduced PLI, while higher population density was associated with lower local transmission rates—a "density paradox" likely driven by aggressive containment measures.

Introduction

In early 2020, as COVID-19 transitioned into a global pandemic, identifying the factors controlling its spread became a priority. While many studies focused on the Prevalence Rate (PR), this research emphasizes the PLI. By understanding which natural factors (e.g., temperature) and social factors (e.g., GDP, healthcare infrastructure) affect the PLI, policymakers can better predict regional vulnerability to sustained community spread.

Methods

The study analyzed epidemiological data from 21 provinces and cities in China, including Shanghai, Tianjin, and Shenzhen, with a cutoff of February 28, 2020. The researchers evaluated the relationship between PLI and several independent variables:

  • Natural Factors: Monthly average temperatures (minimum, median, and maximum) for January and February, and geographic coordinates (longitude and latitude).
  • Social Factors: Population density, Gross Domestic Product (GDP), and healthcare capacity (medical institutions and practitioners per capita).

Statistical relationships were simulated using 11 models in SPSS 21.0. The exponential model ($y = b_0 \cdot e^{b_1x}$) was selected as the most accurate based on $R^2$ values and data trends.

Key Results: Natural and Social Drivers

The analysis revealed that environmental conditions and population dynamics played distinct roles in the early transmission of SARS-CoV-2.

Temperature and Geography

The study reinforces the hypothesis that the virus is sensitive to heat. For every 1°C increase in temperature, the average PLI decreased by approximately 0.01. Latitude was also a significant predictor ($R^2 = 0.344$), with northern, colder regions facing a higher risk of local outbreaks compared to warmer southern regions.

The Density Paradox

Contrary to standard infectious disease models where higher density facilitates spread, this study found a significant inverse relationship between population density and PLI ($R^2 = 0.301, P = 0.012$). This "Density Paradox" suggests that high-density urban centers implemented stricter lockdowns and more comprehensive public health interventions, effectively breaking the transmission chain.

Exponential model simulations showing the relationship between PLI and temperature (a-f), latitude (g), and population density (h).

Economic and Healthcare Neutrality

Surprisingly, factors like GDP and the number of doctors per capita did not significantly impact PLI. This indicates that early, strict non-pharmaceutical interventions (NPIs) were more decisive than a region's wealth or existing medical capacity during the initial outbreak.

Prevalence and Distance

The Prevalence Rate (PR) generally decreased as distance from Hubei province increased. Shenzhen was a notable exception, maintaining a high PR due to its status as a major economic hub with high population turnover.

Conclusion

The transmission of COVID-19 in China was significantly influenced by temperature and latitude, with higher temperatures acting as a deterrent to local spread. Furthermore, the efficacy of containment measures in dense urban areas reversed the expected correlation between population density and infection rates. These findings highlight the importance of environmental monitoring and the decisive role of early public health interventions over economic status in managing novel pathogens.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> Background Novel coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) has become a global pandemic. This study aims to explore the relationship between key natural and social factors and the transmission of COVID-19 in China. Methods This study collected the number of confirmed cases of COVID-19 in 21 provinces and cities in China as of February 28, 2020. Three provinces were included in the sample: Hainan, Guizhou, and Qinghai. The 18 cities included Shanghai, Tianjin and so on. Key natural factors comprised monthly average temperatures in the January and February 2020 and spatial location as determined by longitude and latitude. Social factors were population density, Gross Domestic Product (GDP), number of medical institutions and health practitioners; as well as the per capita values for GDP, medical institutions, and health practitioners. Excel was used to collate the data and draw the temporal and spatial distribution map of the prevalence rate (PR) and the proportion of local infection (PLI). The influencing factors were analyzed by SPSS 21.0 statistical software, and the relationship between the dependent and independent variables was simulated by 11 models. Finally, we choose the exponential model according to the value of <italic>R</italic><sup>2</sup> and the applicability of the model. Results The temporal and spatial distribution of the PR varies across the 21 provinces and cities identified. The PR generally decreases with distance from Hubei, except in the case of Shenzhen City, where the converse is observed. The results of the exponential model simulation show that the monthly minimum, median, and maximum average temperatures in January and February, and the latitude and population density are significant and thus will affect the PLI. The corresponding values of <italic>R</italic><sup>2</sup> are 0.297, 0.322, 0.349, 0.290, 0.314, 0.339, 0.344, and 0.301. The effects of other factors were not statistically significant. Conclusions Among the selected key natural and social factors, higher temperatures may decrease the transmission of COVID-19. From this analysis, it is evident that if the temperature decreases by 1℃, the average PLI increases by 0.01. Further, it was established that locations at more northern latitudes had a higher PLI, and population density showed an inverse relationship with PLI.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lin2020relationship,
  author = {Shengnan Lin and Yaman Li and Jia Rui and Yao Wang and Wang RuiXin and Zeyu Zhao and Yuanzhao Zhu and Meng Yang and Jingwen Xu and Xingchun Liu and Li Luo and Jingwei Chen and Dongbei Guo and Benhua Zhao and Yanhua Su and Feng Li and Yi‐Chen Chiang and Tianmu Chen},
  title = {{The relationship between key natural and social factors and the transmission of novel coronavirus disease 2019 in China}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-31046/v1},
}
Figure