The Relationship between Corporate Culture and Value at Different Life Cycle Stages

Sung Ook Park, Seung Uk Choi, Seong Tae Kim, Hyung Jong NaSustainability 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how different corporate cultures impact firm value and whether this relationship changes across a company's life cycle. It finds that flexible, externally-focused "adhocracy" cultures boost firm value, while rigid, internally-focused "hierarchy" cultures diminish it. Crucially, the positive effects of adhocracy and "clan" cultures are amplified during a firm's growth stage, highlighting the dynamic interplay between culture and environment.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

While it's widely accepted that a company's culture influences its success, there's a surprising lack of empirical research quantifying this link to firm value. Existing studies often assume a static corporate culture, overlooking how it might evolve over a firm's lifespan. This paper aims to fill this gap by exploring two key questions: 1) Does corporate culture directly affect firm value? and 2) Does the impact of culture on firm value change as a company progresses through its life cycle stages (growth, maturity, decline)? Understanding this dynamic is crucial for managers seeking to optimize their organizational strategies.

Methods

The researchers employed the Competing Values Framework (CVF) to categorize corporate cultures into four types:

  • Adhocracy: High flexibility, external focus (innovation, entrepreneurship).
  • Market: Low flexibility, external focus (achievement, competitiveness).
  • Clan: High flexibility, internal focus (teamwork, participation).
  • Hierarchy: Low flexibility, internal focus (rules, order, stability).

To proxy for changes in a firm's environment, they utilized life cycle theory, dividing firms into growth, maturity, and decline stages. They used Tobin's Q as a measure of firm value. The study employed multivariate regression analysis, including ordinary least squares (OLS) and lead-lag regressions to address potential endogeneity concerns. They also conducted sensitivity tests using continuous variables for culture types instead of dummy variables.

Datasets

The study utilized data from the Human Capital Corporate Panel (HCCP), a survey conducted by the Korea Research Institute for Vocational Education and Training (KRIVET). This dataset, collected from managers in HR departments of 500 companies, was chosen for its comprehensiveness and reduced sample selection bias. Financial statement and stock price data were sourced from the KIS-Value database and the TS-2000 database. The analysis covered survey years 2011, 2013, and 2015.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Culture Matters, But Not All Cultures Equally: Not all corporate cultures are created equal when it comes to impacting firm value. The study clearly differentiates between cultures that foster growth and those that stifle it.
  • Flexibility and External Focus are Key: Adhocracy culture, characterized by flexibility, autonomy, and an outward-looking approach, consistently showed a positive impact on firm value. This suggests that embracing change and innovation is directly linked to financial success.
  • Rigidity is a Drag: Conversely, hierarchy culture, with its emphasis on rules, order, and internal stability, was found to negatively affect firm value. This highlights the potential downside of bureaucratic structures in a dynamic market.
  • Life Cycle is a Critical Moderator: The impact of corporate culture isn't static; it's significantly influenced by the firm's stage of development. This is perhaps the most novel contribution of the paper.
  • Growth Stage is Prime Time for Culture: During the growth stage, when firms face dynamic environmental shifts, adhocracy and clan cultures provide an incremental boost to firm value. This suggests that adaptable and internally-focused cultures can be particularly beneficial when navigating rapid change.
  • Maturity and Decline Stages Dampen Culture's Impact: As firms mature or decline, the dynamic changes in their operational environment lessen, and consequently, the effect of culture on firm value becomes restricted.

Key Results

  • Adhocracy Culture: Had a statistically significant and positive effect on firm value (Tobin's Q and adjusted Tobin's Q).
  • Hierarchy Culture: Had a statistically significant and negative effect on firm value.
  • Market and Clan Cultures: Showed no significant impact on firm value in the overall analysis.
  • Life Cycle Interaction:
    • Adhocracy and Clan cultures had a statistically significant and positive incremental effect on firm value specifically during the growth stage.
  • This incremental effect was not observed in the maturity or decline stages.
  • Market and Hierarchy cultures did not show significant incremental effects across any life cycle stage.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Cross-sectional Attributes: While hierarchy culture was found to be negative, further research is needed to identify specific cross-sectional attributes within this culture that might mitigate its negative influence.
  • CVF Framework Applicability: The study acknowledges that the CVF framework, while widely used, might not perfectly align with every aspect of their specific questionnaire.
  • Generalizability: As the study used Korean data, generalizing the findings to other countries and companies requires caution.
  • Life Cycle Proxy: Using life cycle stages as a proxy for environmental change is a simplification, and other alternatives might exist.

Future work suggested includes:

  • Investigating how cultural differences affect other corporate decisions and outcomes beyond financial performance (e.g., financing, tax planning, non-financial reporting).
  • Further exploring the dynamic interplay between corporate culture and the environment, especially in later life cycle stages.
  • Developing policies to support entrepreneurial activities in early-stage firms and to encourage adaptability and innovation in later-stage firms facing environmental volatility.

Summary updated

Abstract

Despite the general agreement that a firm embodies its own culture, there is still a lack of empirical research on how a firm’s culture affects its value. Another caveat on previous studies is that they implicitly assume that a firm’s culture does not vary over time. In this paper, we examine the following two questions to address this lack: (1) Does a firm’s culture affect the firm’s value? (2) If a firm’s culture varies at different life cycle stages, do these changes have an impact on firm value? By using a competing values framework, we identify four types of corporate culture—adhocracy, market, clan, and hierarchy—and use life cycle stages to proxy for changes in a firm’s environment. The results reveal that adhocracy culture has a positive effect on a firm’s value. In contrast, we find a negative association between hierarchy culture and a firm’s value. This can be interpreted as the features of adhocracy culture, which gives autonomy to its members (flexible and discretion) and keeps challenging a firm to grow (external focus and differentiation), positively impacting firm value more than the other cultures. Furthermore, at a growth stage in which a firm faces dynamic environmental changes, both adhocracy and clan cultures have an incrementally positive effect on firm value. This implies that firms in mature or decline stages lose dynamic changes in their operational environment, therefore, the effect of culture on firm value is restricted in those stages.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{park2021relationship,
  author = {Sung Ook Park and Seung Uk Choi and Seong Tae Kim and Hyung Jong Na},
  title = {{The Relationship between Corporate Culture and Value at Different Life Cycle Stages}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3390/su13042334},
}
Figure