The Relationship Between Agnostic Selective Classification, Active Learning and the Disagreement Coefficient

Roei Gelbhart, Ran El-YanivJMLR 2019

TL;DR

This paper establishes a fundamental equivalence between three key concepts in machine learning: selective classification, active learning, and the disagreement coefficient. The authors introduce a new selective classification algorithm (ILESS) and an active learning algorithm (Active-ILESS) that achieve improved performance without relying on strong assumptions, bridging the gap between realizable and agnostic learning settings.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper tackles the challenge of learning effectively in the "agnostic" setting, where the true underlying data distribution might not perfectly align with the chosen hypothesis class. Specifically, it focuses on selective classification, a paradigm where a classifier can choose to abstain from making a prediction if it's uncertain. The goal is to achieve pointwise-competitive predictions (i.e., always making the best possible prediction for non-abstain points) while minimizing the rejection mass (the proportion of points abstained from).

This is closely related to active learning, where the algorithm can actively query for labels of uncertain data points to improve its learning efficiency. A key theoretical tool in this area is the disagreement coefficient, which quantifies the complexity of the hypothesis class and the data distribution. The paper aims to unify these concepts, showing how improvements in one area translate to others, particularly in the challenging agnostic setting where previous methods often relied on restrictive assumptions like the "Bernstein property."

Methods

The authors introduce two main algorithmic contributions:

  • ILESS (Improved Low-Error Selective Strategy): This is a selective classification algorithm that improves upon existing methods like LESS. ILESS uses a tighter generalization error bound and crucially, its analysis does not require the problematic Bernstein assumption. It achieves a fast rejection rate that smoothly interpolates between the realizable and agnostic settings.
  • Active-ILESS: This is an agnostic active learning algorithm designed to work in a stream-based setting. Its querying strategy is conservative, requesting a label only when the optimal classifier's prediction cannot be inferred from the current knowledge. Active-ILESS is shown to have improved label complexity compared to existing algorithms.

The core of the paper's theoretical contribution lies in establishing a complete equivalence between:

  1. The existence of a fast rejection rate for a selective classification algorithm (like ILESS).
  2. A bound on the disagreement coefficient.
  3. An exponential speedup for an active learning algorithm (like Active-ILESS).

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The theoretical nature of the work means it focuses on general properties of distributions and hypothesis classes rather than specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Unification of Concepts: The paper's most significant contribution is demonstrating a deep, formal equivalence between selective classification, active learning, and the disagreement coefficient. This suggests that progress in one area directly implies progress in the others.
  • Breaking Free from Assumptions: ILESS achieves strong theoretical guarantees without relying on the Bernstein property, which was a common requirement for previous agnostic selective classification algorithms. This makes it more broadly applicable.
  • Agonistic Learning Improvements: Both ILESS and Active-ILESS offer improved performance and theoretical bounds in the agnostic setting, a crucial area for real-world machine learning applications.
  • Conservative Active Learning: Active-ILESS's conservative querying strategy, while potentially asking for fewer labels than more aggressive methods, leads to better theoretical guarantees and a more robust algorithm.

Key Results

The paper establishes a main equivalence between:

  1. A fast R* rejection rate for a selective classification algorithm (like ILESS).
  2. A polylogarithmic bound for Hanneke's disagreement coefficient.
  3. An exponential speedup for the Active-ILESS active learning algorithm.

Specifically, they prove that ILESS achieves a fast rejection rate, and that this is equivalent to a bounded disagreement coefficient and an exponential speedup for Active-ILESS. The bounds derived for ILESS are shown to be competitive and do not rely on the Bernstein assumption.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the construction of the selection function g in ILESS can be computationally challenging in practice, though it is theoretically sound. They also suggest future work in several directions:

  • Exploring selective classifiers that are not necessarily pointwise-competitive but still have an error budget, potentially using techniques like linear programming (LP).
  • Investigating more aggressive active learning algorithms that might consider factors beyond simple consensus, such as estimating the probability distribution Px or incorporating noise estimation.
  • Defining and analyzing algorithms that differentiate between "noisy" regions (where even the best classifier performs poorly) and "unknown" regions (due to lack of data), and developing active learners that can strategically query these different types of regions.
  • Conducting experimental work on real-world datasets to validate the theoretical findings and explore the trade-offs between different algorithmic approaches.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{gelbhart2019relationship,
  author = {Roei Gelbhart and Ran El-Yaniv},
  title = {{The Relationship Between Agnostic Selective Classification, Active Learning and the Disagreement Coefficient}},
  journal = {J. Mach. Learn. Res.},
  year = {2019},
}
Figure