The Quest for the FFA and Where It Led

Nancy KanwisherJournal of Neuroscience 2017 · DOI

Abstract

This article tells the story behind our first paper on the fusiform face area (FFA): how we chose the question, developed the methods, and followed the data to find the FFA and subsequently many other functionally specialized cortical regions. The paper's impact had less to do with the particular findings in the paper itself and more to do with the method that it promoted and the picture of the human mind and brain that it led to. The use of a functional localizer to define a candidate region in each subject individually enabled us not just to make pictures of brain activation, but also to ask principled, hypothesis-driven questions about a thing in nature. This method enabled stronger and more extensive tests of the function of each cortical region than had been possible before in humans and, as a result, has produced a large body of evidence that the human cortex contains numerous regions that are specifically engaged in particular mental processes. The growing inventory of cortical regions with distinctive and often very specific functions can be seen as an initial sketch of the basic components of the human mind. This sketch also serves as a roadmap into the vast and exciting new landscape of questions about the computations, structural connections, time course, development, plasticity, and evolution of each of these regions, as well as the hardest question of all: how do these regions work together to produce human intelligence?

Introduction: The Challenge of Individual Variability

In the early 1990s, the nascent field of functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging (fMRI) faced a significant hurdle: individual brains are anatomically different. The standard approach at the time was "group analysis," which involved warping multiple subjects' brain scans onto a single template and averaging the results. While this worked for primary sensory areas, it tended to wash out smaller, more specialized regions that vary in exact location from person to person.

Furthermore, early imaging studies often compared faces to very simple controls (like "blobs"), leaving a critical question unanswered: Is there a region specifically dedicated to face perception, or are these areas just part of a broader system for general shape recognition or visual expertise?

Methodology: The Localize-and-Test fROI Approach

To address these challenges, researchers developed the localize-and-test functional Region of Interest (fROI) method. This approach involves a two-step process:

  1. The Localizer: Instead of looking at the whole brain at once, researchers use an initial "localizer" scan (e.g., comparing faces vs. objects) to identify a candidate region in each individual subject.
  2. The Test: They then use a completely independent set of data from the same subject to test specific hypotheses about that identified region (e.g., "Does this specific blob respond to hands? To scrambled faces? To cars?").

This approach was revolutionary because it allowed for principled, hypothesis-driven "cognitive psychology on a little patch of brain." It elegantly bypassed the "multiple comparisons problem" (the statistical risk of finding false positives when testing tens of thousands of voxels) by focusing the analysis on a single, pre-defined functional unit. It also prevented "double-dipping" (using the same data to find a result and test it), which remains a major concern in neuroimaging statistics today.

Key Results and the 'Glorious Picture'

The application of the fROI method led to the discovery of the Fusiform Face Area (FFA)—a consistent region in the fusiform gyrus (usually in the right hemisphere) that responds significantly more to faces than any other object category. This discovery was followed by the identification of other specialized regions, such as the Parahippocampal Place Area (PPA) for scenes and the Extrastriate Body Area (EBA) for body parts.

Evolution of cortical mapping from 1990 to 2016, showing the discovery of numerous specialized functional regions.

The research eventually produced what has been called a "glorious picture" of the human cortex: a map populated by dozens of specialized regions, including those for music, speech perception, and even "Theory of Mind" (thinking about others' thoughts). Causal validation through transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) and direct electrical stimulation in neurosurgery patients confirmed that these regions are not merely active during tasks but are causally necessary for the specific functions they represent.

Discussion: Domain Specificity and Future Directions

These findings suggest that the human mind is organized more like a "Swiss Army knife" of specialized modules than a general-purpose processor. While some regions like the FFA may have evolutionary roots, others, like the Visual Word Form Area, demonstrate the brain's ability to carve out dedicated "real estate" for culturally learned skills like reading.

However, significant questions remain. fMRI voxels average the activity of hundreds of thousands of neurons, leaving the underlying "neural code" and specific computations within an fROI largely unknown. Furthermore, not all of the brain is specialized; large "multiple demand" regions respond to any difficult task. Understanding how these general-purpose systems interact with specialized modules is the next great challenge. Future work must move beyond identifying where things happen to understanding how they are computed and integrated to produce human intelligence.

Summary updated

Abstract

This article tells the story behind our first paper on the fusiform face area (FFA): how we chose the question, developed the methods, and followed the data to find the FFA and subsequently many other functionally specialized cortical regions. The paper's impact had less to do with the particular findings in the paper itself and more to do with the method that it promoted and the picture of the human mind and brain that it led to. The use of a functional localizer to define a candidate region in each subject individually enabled us not just to make pictures of brain activation, but also to ask principled, hypothesis-driven questions about a thing in nature. This method enabled stronger and more extensive tests of the function of each cortical region than had been possible before in humans and, as a result, has produced a large body of evidence that the human cortex contains numerous regions that are specifically engaged in particular mental processes. The growing inventory of cortical regions with distinctive and often very specific functions can be seen as an initial sketch of the basic components of the human mind. This sketch also serves as a roadmap into the vast and exciting new landscape of questions about the computations, structural connections, time course, development, plasticity, and evolution of each of these regions, as well as the hardest question of all: how do these regions work together to produce human intelligence?
BibTeX
@article{kanwisher2017quest,
  author = {Nancy Kanwisher},
  title = {{The Quest for the FFA and Where It Led}},
  journal = {Journal of Neuroscience},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1523/jneurosci.1706-16.2016},
}
Figure