THE QUALITY ASSESSMENT AND CONTENT ANALYSIS OF CORPORATE WEBSITES IN CHINA: AN EMPIRICAL STUDY

Youmin Xi, Youlong Zhuang, Wenqi Huang, Congguo She, Zhipeng ZhangInternational Journal of Information Technology & Decision Making 2007 · DOI

TL;DR

This study empirically assesses the quality and content of 74 Chinese corporate websites, revealing that while they excel in ease of use and information consistency, they lag in advanced e-commerce functionalities compared to developed nations. The research identifies banking and construction as early adopters of web technology, while public services and retail are laggards, offering a valuable framework for e-business research and practical guidance for businesses operating in China.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As e-business adoption grows globally, understanding the state of corporate websites in emerging markets like China is crucial. While many companies establish websites for publicity, customer service, and sales, the effectiveness and sophistication of these sites can vary significantly. This paper addresses the need to:

  1. Assess the quality and content of Chinese corporate websites: To understand their current capabilities and how they align with business objectives.
  2. Identify industry-specific adoption patterns: To determine which sectors are leading and which are lagging in web technology adoption.
  3. Compare Chinese websites with those in developed countries: To highlight differences in functionalities and identify areas for improvement.
  4. Provide a framework for evaluation: To offer a structured method for assessing corporate websites based on their objectives, content, and functions.

Methods

The study employs a multi-faceted approach:

  • Framework Development: A research framework was developed, categorizing business objectives into four groups: general publicity, customer service, online information exchange, and online sales. This framework also outlines website contents and functions that support these objectives.
  • Assessment Criteria: Ten criteria were established to evaluate website quality, encompassing:
  • Content: Frequency of content update, consistency of information.
  • Functionality: Response speed, interactivity, security, sale process, tools to aid user decisions, customization.
  • User Satisfaction: Ease of use, complexity.
  • Empirical Study: 74 Chinese corporate websites from nine industries were randomly selected from the Shanghai Stock Exchange.
  • Data Collection: Twenty college students were trained to use the assessment framework and evaluated the websites using a 9-point Likert scale.
  • Data Analysis:
    • Average assessment scores were calculated for each criterion within each industry.
  • Statistical tests (F-tests using SPSS) were conducted to determine the significance of differences in assessment criteria across industries.
  • Comparative Analysis: Findings were compared with similar studies conducted in the United States, Singapore, and Australia.

Datasets

  • Primary Dataset: 74 Chinese corporate websites from nine industries (Retail, Information Technology, Manufacture, Public Service, Tour, Storage and Transportation, Bank, Agriculture, Construction) listed on the Shanghai Stock Exchange.
  • Secondary Data: Findings from three previous studies on corporate websites in the United States, Singapore, and Australia were used for comparative analysis.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Focus on Publicity: Chinese corporate websites primarily serve the objective of general publicity, with a lesser emphasis on online sales. This suggests a more traditional approach to online presence, focusing on brand building rather than direct e-commerce.
  • Ease of Use and Consistency are Strengths: Chinese websites generally score high on ease of use and information consistency, indicating a user-friendly design and reliable information presentation. This is attributed partly to the conciseness of the Chinese language.
  • Banking and Construction Lead: The banking and construction industries are identified as innovators and early adopters of web technology, respectively, demonstrating higher quality websites.
  • Public Service and Retail Lag: Public service and retail industries are identified as laggards, suggesting they have not fully embraced or effectively utilized web technologies.
  • Functional Gap with Developed Nations: Chinese websites exhibit less advanced functionalities compared to those in developed countries, particularly in areas like complex online sales and personalized services, likely due to resource constraints and technological infrastructure.
  • Industry-Specific Security and Sales Processes: Significant differences were found across industries in security and sale process criteria, highlighting that not all industries prioritize or implement these features equally.

Key Results

  • Industry Innovators/Laggards:
    • Innovators: Banking industry (highest scores in security, customization, and overall assessment).
  • Early Adopters: Construction industry.
  • Laggards: Public service and Retail industries.
  • Overall Assessment Scores:
    • Banking industry: Highest average score (6.53).
  • Public service industry: Lowest average score (5.28).
  • Criterion Performance:
    • Highest Scoring Criteria: Ease of use (6.29), Consistency of information (6.41), and Interactivity (6.30).
  • Lowest Scoring Criteria: Sale process (4.75), Tools to aid user decisions (4.90), and Complexity (5.32).
  • Significant Industry Differences: Only security (p=0.053) and sale process (p=0.067) showed statistically significant differences across industries at the 0.1 level.
  • Comparative Findings: Chinese websites are generally easier to use and more consistent than those in developed countries, but lack the more complicated functions found in the US, Australia, and Singapore.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • Subjective Assessment: The study relies on subjective judgments from student evaluators, which may not perfectly reflect exact measurements.
  • Limited Sample Size: While 74 websites were assessed, the number of industries and websites per industry could be expanded for broader generalizability.
  • Exploratory Nature: The study acknowledges its exploratory nature, particularly regarding the statistical significance of industry differences.
  • Future Work:
    • Cultural Factors: Future research should incorporate cultural aspects as an explanatory factor for differences in website design and adoption across countries.
  • Language Impact: Investigating the relationship between language (specifically Chinese) and ease of use could provide valuable insights for foreign firms.
  • Benchmarking: The developed assessment framework can be used by e-business managers for benchmarking their websites against competitors and identifying specific areas for improvement.
  • Dynamic Analysis: Future studies could explore how Chinese corporate websites evolve over time.

Summary updated

Abstract

This study evaluates 74 Chinese corporate websites by examining their contents and functions to understand the business objectives. It found that business objectives of these websites mainly focused on publicity, and very little on online sales. Firms in banking and construction industries develop the highest quality websites, while firms in public services and retailing are the laggards. Chinese websites are ease to use with consistent information. The article also compared the findings in China in this study with those in the United States, Australia, and Singapore in similar studies. It found that industry characteristics were similar among nations while more complicated website functions were more popular among the firms of developed countries. The findings will contribute to the research of e-business by confirming the existence of innovators and laggards of Web technology adoption in model given in E. M. Roger, Diffusion of Innovations (The Free Press, New York, 1962), and help managers understand current status of Chinese websites.
BibTeX
@article{xi2007quality,
  author = {Youmin Xi and Youlong Zhuang and Wenqi Huang and CONGGUO SHE and Zhipeng Zhang},
  title = {{THE QUALITY ASSESSMENT AND CONTENT ANALYSIS OF CORPORATE WEBSITES IN CHINA: AN EMPIRICAL STUDY}},
  journal = {International Journal of Information Technology \& Decision Making},
  year = {2007},
  doi = {10.1142/s0219622007002472},
}
Figure