The Public Perception of the #GeneEditedBabies Event Across Multiple Social Media Platforms: Observational Study

Congning Ni, Zhiyu Wan, Chao Yan, Yongtai Liu, Ellen Wright Clayton, Bradley Malin, Zhijun YinJournal of Medical Internet Research 2022 · DOI

Abstract

This research provides evidence that posts on web-based platforms can offer insights into the public's stance on gene editing techniques. However, these stances vary across web-based platforms and often differ from those raised by academics and policy makers.

Introduction

In November 2018, the scientific world was upended by Jiankui He’s announcement of the birth of the first gene-edited infants. While the academic community and global policymakers moved swiftly to condemn the breach of ethical protocols and propose moratoriums, the broader public's reaction remained largely fragmented across various digital spaces. Understanding this "voice of the people" is crucial for developing inclusive governance for human germline editing (HGE). This study addresses the gap by analyzing over 220,000 posts across four major social media platforms—Sina Weibo, Twitter, Reddit, and YouTube—to determine how cultural contexts and platform architectures influence public perception.

Methods and Data Collection

The researchers developed a comprehensive pipeline to analyze the massive dataset. Data collection involved using APIs to gather posts from November 2018 to October 2019 using keywords such as "gene-edited babies" and "Jiankui He" in both English and Chinese.

To analyze the content, the team employed Structural Topic Modeling (STM). Unlike traditional methods, STM incorporates metadata (like platform and date) to track how topics evolve. Furthermore, a critical component of the study was the manual annotation of a random sample of 8,000 posts (2,000 per platform).

The multi-stage annotation and verification process used to label post stances.

As shown in the figure above, the annotation process followed a rigorous three-round verification workflow. Bilingual annotators categorized posts as supporting, opposing, or neutral, while also identifying specific rationales such as ethical concerns, legal issues, or technical merit. Finally, language saliency analysis was used to identify the specific vocabulary distinguishing supporters from opponents.

The Multi-Platform Dataset

The study utilized a diverse dataset reflecting both Western and Chinese digital ecosystems:

  • Total Scale: Over 220,000 posts from approximately 130,000 unique users.
  • Sina Weibo: 4,941 microblogs and 131,126 comments.
  • Twitter: 47,147 tweets.
  • Reddit: 3,205 submissions and 22,417 comments.
  • YouTube: 48,172 comments.

Analysis of user behavior showed that over 95% of users posted only once, indicating that the data captures a broad cross-section of the public rather than being skewed by a few highly active individuals.

Key Insights: The "Platform Personality" Effect

The study revealed that public stance is significantly influenced by the nature of the platform. Twitter and Sina Weibo functioned primarily as news redistribution hubs. On these platforms, opposition was overwhelming, reaching approximately 85%.

In contrast, Reddit and YouTube hosted more "multidimensional" and "divided" discussions. On YouTube, support for the event reached nearly 38%, while Reddit saw 28.6% support. These platforms allowed for longer-form discourse where the "pro-innovation" minority could voice their views.

Rationales for Support and Opposition

The drivers behind public stances varied:

  • Opposition: Primarily rooted in ethical concerns (on Reddit, YouTube, and Weibo) and legal or organizational violations (on Twitter).
  • Support: Driven by the perceived technical potential of CRISPR to eradicate genetic diseases. Some supporters on Weibo even compared Jiankui He to Galileo, suggesting that revolutionary science is often initially met with unfair backlash.

Linguistic Markers

The language used by different groups was distinct. Supporters frequently used terms like innovation, exciting, protect, and successful. Opponents utilized more visceral or dramatic language, such as illegal, death, zombie, and extinction. On Weibo, the term 吐 (throw-up) was a common marker of disgust.

Conclusion and Future Directions

This study demonstrates that public perception of HGE is far from a monolith. While the scientific community's condemnation was nearly universal, a significant portion of the public—particularly on platforms like YouTube and Reddit—views the technology as a promising frontier for disease prevention.

However, the study has limitations. It did not include platforms like Facebook or Instagram, and the keyword-based search might have missed broader discussions on gene editing. Future research should apply this multi-platform framework to other controversial scientific topics, such as COVID-19 vaccination, and continue to monitor public sentiment as the long-term health outcomes of the gene-edited children become known.

Summary updated

Abstract

This research provides evidence that posts on web-based platforms can offer insights into the public's stance on gene editing techniques. However, these stances vary across web-based platforms and often differ from those raised by academics and policy makers.
BibTeX
@article{ni2022public,
  author = {Congning Ni and Zhiyu Wan and Chao Yan and Yongtai Liu and Ellen Wright Clayton and Bradley Malin and Zhijun Yin},
  title = {{The Public Perception of the \#GeneEditedBabies Event Across Multiple Social Media Platforms: Observational Study}},
  journal = {Journal of Medical Internet Research},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.2196/31687},
}
Figure