The Promotion of a Bright Future and the Prevention of a Dark Future: Time Anchored Incitements in News Articles and Facebook’s Status Updates

Danilo Garcia, Karl Drejing, Clara Amato, Michał Kosiński, Sverker SikströmFrontiers in Psychology 2018 · DOI

Abstract

Research suggests humans tend to view future events more positively than past ones, a phenomenon known as temporal-valence asymmetry. While previously studied in controlled lab settings using imagined scenarios, this study investigates whether this bias exists in real-world "ecological" data. By analyzing over 160 million words from Reuters news articles and Facebook status updates using Latent Semantic Analysis (LSA), researchers found a consistent trend: the future is described with significantly higher positive sentiment (valence) than the past or present. These findings support the "Time Anchored Incitement Hypothesis," suggesting that human communication is fundamentally geared toward promoting a bright future to motivate social action and appeal.

Introduction: The "Rosy Future" Bias

Psychologists have long observed that we value the future differently than the past. In laboratory experiments, participants often assign higher emotional intensity to future events than to identical events placed in the past. However, these studies typically rely on fictional scenarios. This research sought to determine if this bias permeates our actual narratives—from professional journalism to casual social media posts. The authors aimed to move beyond self-reports to "ecological data" to see if the past is systematically devalued compared to the future in everyday language.

Methodology: Quantifying Sentiment Across Time

The researchers employed Latent Semantic Analysis (LSA), a natural language processing technique, to measure "valence" (positivity vs. negativity).

  1. Semantic Mapping: A high-dimensional semantic space was created to position words with similar meanings close together.
  2. Valence Prediction: A model trained on the Affective Norms for English Words (ANEW) list—a set of 1,000 words ranked by humans—predicted the sentiment of words within the larger corpora.
  3. Time Markers: Text was categorized into past, present, or future using two methods:
  4. Verbs: Simple past (past), past participle (present), and future auxiliaries like "will/shall" (future).
  5. Years: Specific years mentioned relative to the publication date (e.g., in a 1997 article, 1995 is "past" and 1999 is "future").
  6. Contextual Analysis: The sentiment of the 15 words surrounding each time marker was analyzed to capture the intended emotional tone.

The study utilized two massive datasets: the Reuters News Corpus (120 million words) and Facebook Status Updates (41 million words).

Key Results: A Consistent Upward Trend

The analysis revealed a robust pattern across both professional and personal writing: Valence = Past < Present < Future.

Valence scores across time markers (A: Tense, B: Year) in the Reuters corpus.

In the Reuters corpus, future valence was significantly higher than past valence ($p < 0.001$). When looking at specific years, sentiment increased almost linearly from 1994 to 1999 in articles written during 1996–1997.

The Facebook data showed an even stronger effect for the future compared to the present ($d = 0.55$). While Reuters data indicated the past is devalued against both the present and future, Facebook data suggested that both the past and present are devalued relative to the future.

Discussion: Why We Look Forward

The authors propose the Time Anchored Incitement Hypothesis (TAIH) to explain these findings. By framing the future brightly, speakers and writers create "incitements" that make them appear more appealing and persuasive. This positive framing serves to motivate others toward "promotion" (seeking rewards) or "prevention" (avoiding threats).

Furthermore, this bias may be rooted in cognitive scaffolding. Because we physically move forward in time, concepts like "progress" and "advancement" are inherently linked to "good," while "backward thinking" is viewed negatively.

Conclusion

This study provides large-scale evidence for temporal-valence asymmetry in everyday language. Whether in the objective reporting of news or the personal reflections of social media, humans consistently describe the future as "brighter" than the past. This linguistic pattern reflects a fundamental human drive to communicate hope and progress, effectively promoting a bright future while distancing ourselves from a darker past.

This summary is based on research published in Frontiers in Psychology.

Summary updated

Abstract

<b>Background:</b> Research suggests that humans have the tendency to increase the valence of events when these are imagined to happen in the future, but to decrease the valence when the same events are imagined to happen in the past. This line of research, however, has mostly been conducted by asking participants to value imagined, yet probable, events. Our aim was to re-examine this time-valence asymmetry using real-life data: a Reuter's news and a Facebook status updates corpus. <b>Method:</b> We organized the Reuter news (120,000,000 words) and the Facebook status updates data (41,056,346 words) into contexts grouped in chronological order (i.e., past, present, and future) using verbs and years as time markers. These contexts were used to estimate the valence of each article and status update, respectively, in relation to the time markers using natural language processing tools (i.e., the Latent Semantic Analysis algorithm). <b>Results:</b> Our results using verbs, in both text corpus, showed that valence for the future was significantly higher compared to the past (future > past). Similarly, in the Reuter year condition, valence increased approximately linear from 1994 to 1999 for texts written 1996-1997. In the Facebook year condition, the valence of the future was also significantly higher than past valence. <b>Conclusion:</b> Generally, the analyses of the Reuters data indicated that the past is devaluated relative to both the present and the future, while the analyses of the Facebook data indicated that both the past and the present are devaluated against the future. On this basis, we suggest that people strive to communicate the promotion of a bright future and the prevention of a dark future, which in turn leads to a temporal-valence asymmetrical phenomenon (valence = past < present < future). <b><i>"</i></b> <i>I have a dream that one day this nation will rise up and live out the true meaning of its creed: "We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal."</i>I have a dream that one day on the red hills of Georgia, the sons of former slaves and the sons of former slave owners will be able to sit down together at the table of brotherhood.I have a dream that one day even the state of Mississippi, a state sweltering with the heat of injustice, sweltering with the heat of oppression, will be transformed into an oasis of freedom and justice.I have a dream that my four little children will one day live in a nation where they will not be judged by the color of their skin but by the content of their character.I have a dream today!"Martin Luther King, Jr., 28th of August 1963, at the Lincoln Memorial, Washington, DC, United States.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{garcia2018promotion,
  author = {Danilo Garcia and Karl Drejing and Clara Amato and Michał Kosiński and Sverker Sikström},
  title = {{The Promotion of a Bright Future and the Prevention of a Dark Future: Time Anchored Incitements in News Articles and Facebook’s Status Updates}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychology},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyg.2018.01623},
}
Figure