The Predictive Brain and Psychopathology: Searching for the hidden links across anxiety, hallucination and apathy

Haiyang Geng2020 · DOI

Abstract

Clinical neuroscience and psychiatric research increasingly acknowledge the important roles of prediction in psychopathology including anxiety, hallucination and apathy. Currently, transdiagnostic neuroimaging studies have found that common disruption of key large-scale brain networks including the frontoparietal network (FPN), the default mode network (DMN) and the salience network (SN) were manifested widely across autism, anxiety disorders, and schizophrenia. However, it still remains unsolved whether there are common cognitive mechanisms in relation to these shared alterations of large-scale brain networks. This thesis exploited functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging (fMRI) measures including brain activation, functional connectivity and dynamic brain networks to examine putative common neurocognitive mechanisms across the prevalent symptoms of anxiety, apathy, and hallucinations, with an emphasis on the role of prediction. Based on our findings, I propose a hypothesis of a common neurocognitive mechanism across anxiety, hallucination and apathy was proposed: the predicting brain model. Core brain networks, including the SN, FPN and DMN and peripheral regions involved in specific cognitive elements, underlie the common prediction of uncertain threats in anxiety, auditory stimuli in hallucinations and motivational drive in apathy. Our studies provide enhanced understanding of brain network organization during predictive processing underlying symptoms in psychiatric disorders may aid the development of more effective diagnostic and treatment strategies.

Introduction: Beyond Symptom Silos

In traditional clinical practice, anxiety, hallucinations, and apathy are often categorized as distinct symptoms belonging to separate diagnostic categories. However, contemporary neuroimaging research has revealed a significant overlap in the neural substrates of these conditions. Patients across the spectrum of psychiatric disorders frequently exhibit similar disruptions in "core" large-scale brain networks, specifically the Salience Network (SN), the Frontoparietal Network (FPN), and the Default Mode Network (DMN).

This research addresses a critical gap in psychiatric neuroscience: identifying the common cognitive mechanism that links these shared neural alterations. We propose that the unifying framework is Predictive Processing. Under this model, the brain is viewed not as a passive receiver of sensory information, but as an active "prediction machine" that constantly generates internal models to anticipate future events. Psychopathology, therefore, can be understood as a breakdown in these predictive mechanisms.

Methodological Framework

To investigate these mechanisms, we utilized functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging (fMRI) across several cohorts, including individuals with trait anxiety, hallucination proneness, and clinical patients with schizophrenia. Our analysis moved beyond static localization to examine the brain's functional architecture through three lenses:

  1. Task-based Activation: Assessing regional responses to specific stimuli, such as uncertain threats.
  2. Functional Connectivity: Mapping the synchronization between distinct brain regions.
  3. Dynamic Brain Networks: Analyzing how connectivity patterns fluctuate over time, providing a more nuanced view of the brain's "state-switching" capabilities.

The Predicting Brain Model: Key Insights

Our findings support a "Predicting Brain Model," where core networks serve as the hardware for a predictive engine that manifests specific symptoms when different "software" errors occur.

Anxiety as Threat Prediction Error

In individuals with high trait anxiety, the brain becomes hyper-sensitized to uncertainty. Our research indicates that anxiety is characterized by altered connectivity during the anticipation of uncertain threats, suggesting a failure in the brain's ability to accurately model and predict potential danger.

Hallucinations as Perception Prediction Error

Auditory verbal hallucinations (AVH) emerge when internal "top-down" expectations (what the brain expects to hear) override "bottom-up" sensory inputs. We identified the dorsal anterior cingulate cortex (dACC) as a critical hub that mediates this balance between semantic prediction and auditory perception. Furthermore, resting-state analysis revealed that AVH are associated with abnormal dynamic organization, suggesting that the brain's ability to maintain stable perceptual states is impaired.

Apathy as Reward Prediction Error

Apathy, particularly in schizophrenia, was linked to failures in affective forecasting—the ability to predict the emotional value of future rewards. Our study demonstrated that apathy is reflected in impaired dynamic functional synchronization during the mental simulation of future emotional states. If the brain cannot accurately predict the "joy" of a future outcome, the motivational drive to pursue it is lost.

Conclusion and Future Directions

By demonstrating that anxiety, hallucinations, and apathy share a common foundation in predictive processing failures, this research provides a transdiagnostic framework for understanding mental illness. Moving forward, these insights can facilitate the development of targeted diagnostic tools and personalized treatments. Rather than treating symptoms in isolation, clinicians may eventually be able to "recalibrate" specific predictive mechanisms through pharmacological or behavioral interventions, leading to more effective and precise psychiatric care.

Summary updated

Abstract

Clinical neuroscience and psychiatric research increasingly acknowledge the important roles of prediction in psychopathology including anxiety, hallucination and apathy. Currently, transdiagnostic neuroimaging studies have found that common disruption of key large-scale brain networks including the frontoparietal network (FPN), the default mode network (DMN) and the salience network (SN) were manifested widely across autism, anxiety disorders, and schizophrenia. However, it still remains unsolved whether there are common cognitive mechanisms in relation to these shared alterations of large-scale brain networks. This thesis exploited functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging (fMRI) measures including brain activation, functional connectivity and dynamic brain networks to examine putative common neurocognitive mechanisms across the prevalent symptoms of anxiety, apathy, and hallucinations, with an emphasis on the role of prediction. Based on our findings, I propose a hypothesis of a common neurocognitive mechanism across anxiety, hallucination and apathy was proposed: the predicting brain model. Core brain networks, including the SN, FPN and DMN and peripheral regions involved in specific cognitive elements, underlie the common prediction of uncertain threats in anxiety, auditory stimuli in hallucinations and motivational drive in apathy. Our studies provide enhanced understanding of brain network organization during predictive processing underlying symptoms in psychiatric disorders may aid the development of more effective diagnostic and treatment strategies.
BibTeX
@misc{geng2020predictive,
  author = {Haiyang Geng},
  title = {{The Predictive Brain and Psychopathology: Searching for the hidden links across anxiety, hallucination and apathy}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.33612/diss.131330743},
}
Figure