The Predicament and Breakthrough of Ideological and Political Education in Colleges and Universities

Zhiyuan Xu, Fan HuilingProceedings of the 5th International Conference on Education, Language, Art and Inter-cultural Communication (ICELAIC 2018) 2018 · DOI

Abstract

Currently, ideological and political education (IPE) in Chinese higher education faces significant challenges, including outdated concepts, unclear relational dynamics between teachers and students, and a lack of systemic guarantees. To address these issues, this paper proposes a framework for innovation across three dimensions: conceptual, relational, and institutional. By adhering to the cultivation of "top-notch innovative talents" under the guidance of socialist core values, promoting "intersubjective" dialogue, and establishing robust incentive mechanisms, IPE can transition from a passive "cramming" model to a dynamic, wisdom-seeking process.

Introduction: The Current Predicament

Ideological and political education (IPE) is a cornerstone of the Chinese higher education system, yet it increasingly finds itself trapped in an "ivory tower." The authors identify three primary "predicaments" that hinder its effectiveness in the modern era:

  1. Outdated Concepts: Traditional pedagogy often lacks realistic pertinence, failing to address the complex social realities students face. Theory is frequently presented as too "delicate" or abstract, losing its connection to the practical needs of a high-tech, innovative workforce.
  2. Unclear Object Relationships: A rigid hierarchy persists where teachers are the sole "subjects" (authorities) and students are "objects" (passive recipients). This "cramming" method stifles active learning and prevents the development of critical thinking.
  3. Lack of Institutional Guarantees: Systems are often unstandardized, with structural imbalances that prioritize research over teaching, leading to inefficient supervision and low engagement from both faculty and students.

Theoretical Framework and Methodology

This analysis employs a qualitative, policy-oriented approach, drawing on diverse philosophical and educational frameworks to redefine IPE:

  • Intersubjectivity and Communicative Rationality: Utilizing concepts from Husserl and Habermas, the paper advocates for a shift in the teacher-student dynamic toward mutual recognition and equal dialogue. This redefines the classroom as a shared space for growth rather than a one-way transmission of data.
  • Process Philosophy: Inspired by Whitehead’s "philosophy of process" and Tao Xingzhi’s pedagogical ideas, the authors argue for a move away from static "book knowledge" toward a model that prioritizes wisdom and active participation.
  • Policy Alignment: The recommendations are grounded in the directives of the 17th and 18th National Congresses of the CPC, ensuring the proposed reforms remain within the established political framework while addressing the needs of the "Chinese dream."

Proposed Breakthrough Strategies

The paper outlines a three-dimensional strategy to modernize IPE and break through current systemic bottlenecks.

1. Concept Innovation

IPE must shift its focus toward cultivating "top-notch innovative talents." This involves moving beyond mere moral compliance to fostering a "firm spiritual pursuit" and a "strong sense of responsibility." Education should be problem-oriented, addressing the "actual" and "major" challenges of the new era under the theoretical guidance of socialist core values.

2. Relationship Innovation: The Shift to Intersubjectivity

The most critical breakthrough is the transition from a subject-object relationship to an intersubjective one. By treating both teachers and students as equal "subjects," universities can create interactive learning platforms. This "spirit of equal dialogue" encourages student agency and transforms the classroom from a site of passive reception into a space for shared intellectual and moral development.

3. Institutional Innovation

To ensure these reforms are "routinized" and sustainable, the authors propose several institutional changes:

  • Strong Leadership: Strengthening the role of university party committees in overseeing and prioritizing IPE.
  • Standardized Work Systems: Implementing clear protocols for student assistance, instructor training, and curriculum development.
  • Dual Incentive Mechanisms: Utilizing "Target Incentives" (setting clear, operable goals to stimulate interest) and "Defense Incentives" (using examinations, reflections, and summary exchanges to evaluate and reinforce results).
  • The Class Tutorial System: To humanize management, the authors suggest dividing grades into small study groups led by tutors who provide individualized, "heart-warming" guidance rather than just administrative oversight.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

While the proposed framework offers a clear path forward, the authors acknowledge significant hurdles. Traditional psychological habits—specifically the comfort of the authoritative "cramming" model—remain deeply ingrained in both faculty and students. Furthermore, implementing individualized tutorial systems and robust incentive mechanisms requires substantial personnel and financial resources.

Future work must focus on bridging the "implementation gap" where existing systems suffer from low efficiency. Empirical studies will be necessary to measure the efficacy of these intersubjective models across diverse institutional settings, ensuring that IPE evolves to meet the demands of a rapidly changing global landscape.

Summary updated

Abstract

Currently the ideological and political education in colleges and universities in China is facing the disadvantages of outdated concepts, unclear objects relations and lack of system guarantee. To solve these problems, it is necessary to conduct the concept innovation of ideological and political education, including three aspects: adhering to the cultivation standard of "top-notch innovative talents" and being problemoriented, under the theoretical guidance of socialist core values; adhering to the innovation of object relationship, which is to promote the subject consciousness of objects, make the principle of participation clear and calling for the equal dialogue between teachers and students; adhering to the institutional innovation which means strong leadership system, standardized work system and effective incentive mechanism.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{xu2018predicament,
  author = {Zhiyuan Xu and Fan Huiling},
  title = {{The Predicament and Breakthrough of Ideological and Political Education in Colleges and Universities}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the 5th International Conference on Education, Language, Art and Inter-cultural Communication (ICELAIC 2018)},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.2991/icelaic-18.2018.17},
}
Figure