The Potential for Tidal Range Energy Systems to Provide Continuous Power: A UK Case Study

Lucas Mackie, Daniel Coles, Matthew D. Piggott, Athanasios AngeloudisJournal of Marine Science and Engineering 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores how a cooperative system of UK tidal range energy plants can provide a more continuous power supply by optimizing their operational schedules. While fully continuous power isn't achieved, the study demonstrates that strategic coordination can deliver consistent output for over half the year, offering a valuable, predictable energy source that could reduce grid strain and potentially be financially viable with market adjustments.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The UK's transition to renewable energy sources faces a challenge: while variable renewables like wind and solar are growing, they require significant grid management to compensate for their intermittency. Dispatchable, predictable sources are crucial for grid stability and a reliable energy supply. Tidal range energy offers predictability but suffers from intermittency within individual schemes. This paper investigates whether a network of tidal range power plants, by exploiting natural tidal phase differences and employing flexible operational control, can overcome this intermittency to provide a more consistent, baseload-like power output, thereby enhancing grid integration and potentially creating new economic opportunities.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach:

  • Hydrodynamic Modeling: A depth-averaged hydrodynamic model of the Irish Sea was used to simulate tidal conditions around the proposed power plant locations. This model, based on the Thetis coastal flow solver and the Firedrake PDE framework, captures the complex water elevations and flows.
  • Tidal Power Plant Modeling: A 0D (zero-dimensional) operational model was developed to simulate the energy generation of individual tidal power plants. This model takes into account water level data from the hydrodynamic model, the surface area of the basins, and the characteristics of hydraulic structures (turbines and sluices).
  • Optimization Techniques: Gradient-based optimization algorithms were used to determine optimal control schedules for the tidal power plants. Two primary objectives were explored:
  • Energy Maximization (EM): Aiming to produce the most energy possible.
  • Continuous Generation (CG): Aiming to ensure at least one plant is generating power at any given time.
  • Both inflexible (fixed schedules) and flexible (schedules that can adapt between tidal cycles) control strategies were investigated.
  • Economic Assessment: An idealized energy market framework was created, incorporating both an hourly variable market (HVM) and a baseload market (BM). The economic feasibility of different operational strategies was assessed by simulating income generation under various pricing scenarios, including the impact of scaling baseload market prices.

Datasets

  • Hydrodynamic Model Domain: The model covered the west coast of Great Britain and the east coast of Ireland, utilizing bathymetry data from LiDAR Composite DSM and the Edina Digimap Service.
  • Tidal Constituents: Eight tidal constituents from the TPXO database were used to force the hydrodynamic model.
  • River Flow Data: Water volume fluxes from the National River Flow Archive were incorporated.
  • Tide Gauge Data: Data from the British Oceanographic Data Centre (BODC) tide gauge network was used for validating the hydrodynamic model.
  • Energy Market Data: Hourly Variable Market (HVM) price signals were derived from the Nord Pool N2EX market for 2018. For the Baseload Market (BM), daily, weekly, and monthly averages of the HVM price signal were tested, reflecting a simplified representation of baseload pricing.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Cooperation is Key: Operating multiple tidal range schemes cooperatively, rather than as independent entities, unlocks significant potential for continuous generation by leveraging tidal phase differences.
  • Flexibility Pays Off: Flexible operational control, allowing schedules to adapt between tidal cycles, is crucial for maximizing continuous generation, especially when compared to rigid, inflexible schedules.
  • Baseload Market Needs a Boost: The current market structure doesn't inherently reward the continuous, albeit lower-output, generation characteristic of optimized tidal systems. A significant scaling of baseload market prices (subsidies) would be required to make continuous generation financially competitive with pure energy maximization strategies.
  • Neap Tides are the Bottleneck: Continuous generation is consistently not achievable during neap tides, highlighting a fundamental limitation of the tidal resource itself.
  • Default Strategies Matter: When continuous generation isn't possible, the "default" strategy (e.g., reverting to energy maximization) significantly impacts the system's ability to achieve continuous generation in subsequent cycles.

Key Results

  • Significant Continuous Generation Achieved: Under optimized continuous generation (CG-F) schedules, the system achieved continuous power supply for up to 66% of the days in the year (242 days).
  • Consistent Minimum Output: On these "CG days," the average daily minimum cumulative power output was consistently over 500 MW, out of a total installed capacity of 6195.3 MW.
  • Reduced Variability: Continuous generation optimization notably reduced the difference between average daily minimum and maximum power outputs, leading to a more stable power profile.
  • Economic Viability Requires Subsidies: While continuous generation strategies yielded less total energy than pure energy maximization, the economic analysis indicated that a substantial increase in baseload market prices (scaling factor of ~1.75-1.9) would be necessary to make continuous generation financially advantageous over energy maximization.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Idealized Market: The economic assessment used an idealized energy market. Future work could incorporate more realistic market dynamics, including demand-side response and the impact of grid congestion management costs.
  • No Pumping: The study did not include pumping operations, which could potentially increase head differences and extend continuous generation periods. Incorporating pumping would significantly increase computational complexity.
  • Limited Number of Plants: The study focused on three specific tidal range proposals. Expanding the analysis to include more sites or different types of tidal energy technologies could provide further insights.
  • Sensitivity Analysis: While the study explored some optimization parameters, further sensitivity analyses on factors like bathymetry, hydraulic structure design, and the number of plants could refine the understanding of system performance.
  • Storage Integration: The paper suggests that integrating energy storage solutions (like batteries) could complement the variable power peaks and further enhance economic feasibility.
  • Alternative Generators: Supplementing the tidal system with other dispatchable generators (e.g., biomass) or tidal stream arrays could also improve overall system reliability and continuous supply.

Summary updated

Abstract

The extraction of tidal energy from head differences represents a predictable and flexible option for generating electricity. Here, we investigate the generation potential of prospective tidal power plants in the UK. Originally conceived as separate projects, operating these schemes as a cooperative system could prove beneficial. Combined with the inherent operational flexibility of tidal range-based schemes, a notable tidal phase difference in selected sites allows for the system to spread power generation over a larger proportion of the day. Using depth-averaged modelling and gradient-based optimisation techniques, we explore how a flexible cumulative operation schedule could be applied to provide a degree of continuous supply if desirable. While fully continuous operation is not achieved, a number of different optimisation schedules deliver cumulative continuous supply for over half of the year. The average minimum cumulative power output on these days is consistently over 500 MW out of a total installed capacity of 6195.3 MW. Furthermore, by introducing financial incentives associated with reliable, baseload supply, we provide an economic assessment of the tidal power plant system. The daily minimum cumulative power output determines income in the modelled idealised baseload market, while excess supply is traded in an hourly variable wholesale energy market. Results indicate that subsidies would be required in order to make a pursuit of continuous generation financially advantageous over energy maximisation strategies.
BibTeX
@article{mackie2020potential,
  author = {Lucas Mackie and Daniel Coles and Matthew D. Piggott and Athanasios Angeloudis},
  title = {{The Potential for Tidal Range Energy Systems to Provide Continuous Power: A UK Case Study}},
  journal = {Journal of Marine Science and Engineering},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3390/jmse8100780},
}
Figure