The possible impact of novel mutations in human papillomavirus 52 on the infection characteristics

Yingxin Gong, Yan Wang, Qi Zhou, Wenjie Qu, Fang Chen, Yaping Wang, Jiayin Mo, Hongwei Zhang, Lin Lin, Tianyi Bi, Xujie Wang, Jiashi Gu, Long Sui, Yanyun LiMicrobial 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how genetic variations in Human Papillomavirus type 52 (HPV52) influence its infection patterns and potential for causing cervical lesions in Chinese women. Researchers identified specific mutations in the HPV52 genome that are linked to single vs. multiple infections, persistent vs. transient infections, and the severity of cervical cytology, offering crucial insights for HPV prevention and treatment strategies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Human Papillomavirus (HPV) is a major cause of cervical cancer, with HPV52 being particularly prevalent in Asia. While the oncogenic potential of HPV is well-established, and some variations are linked to cancer risk, there's a significant knowledge gap regarding how specific genetic mutations in HPV52 affect its behavior within the host, such as how long it persists, whether it co-infects with other HPV types, and its association with different grades of cervical lesions. Understanding these genotype-specific variations is crucial for developing more targeted diagnostic tools, therapeutic interventions, and effective vaccines.

Methods

The researchers analyzed full-length E6 and L1 genes from 197 HPV52-positive cervical samples collected from women in China. They employed standard molecular biology techniques:

  • DNA Extraction and PCR Amplification: Standard kits and type-specific primers were used to amplify the E6 and L1 genes.
  • Sequencing: Amplicons were sequenced using an ABI 3730xl DNA Analyzer.
  • Phylogenetic Analysis: Maximum likelihood trees were constructed using MEGA V11.0 to determine the evolutionary relationships and lineage/sublineage classifications of the HPV52 variants.
  • Statistical Analysis: Various statistical tests (t-tests, Mann-Whitney Rank sum test, Chi-squared, Fisher's exact test) were used to correlate genetic variations with clinical and epidemiological data, including infection patterns (single/multiple, transient/persistent) and cervical cytology/histopathology.

Datasets

The study utilized HPV52 E6 and L1 gene sequences from 197 cervical samples collected from women in China. These sequences were compared against reference sequences for HPV52 lineages and sublineages obtained from the GenBank database (NCBI). The study also collected clinical data from these patients, including age, HPV genotype, infection duration, cytology results, histopathology, and lifestyle factors (e.g., age of coitarche, condom usage, vaccination history).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Dominance of Sublineage B2: The vast majority (98.39%) of the HPV52 variants identified belonged to the B2 sublineage, confirming its widespread prevalence in the studied population.
  • E6/L1 Phylogenetic Incongruence: Two variants showed conflicting classifications between their E6 and L1 gene phylogenetic trees, suggesting potential recombination events or different evolutionary pressures on these genes.
  • Specific Mutations Link to Infection Patterns:
    • The C6480A/T mutation in the L1 gene was significantly associated with single HPV52 infections and persistent infections.
  • The A6516G mutation in L1 was linked to transient HPV52 infections.
  • Mutations and Cytology Severity: Certain variations, like T309C in E6 and C6480T/C6600A in L1, were more frequently found in patients with high-grade cervical cytology, suggesting a potential role in disease progression.
  • Vaccine Escape Hint: The identification of one case of HPV52 breakthrough infection after vaccination, coupled with multiple infections by non-vaccine types, raises concerns about potential immune escape mechanisms.
  • Lifestyle Factors Matter: Younger age at first sexual intercourse (coitarche) and infrequent condom use were strongly correlated with multiple HPV infections.

Key Results

  • Prevalence: 98.39% of HPV52 variants belonged to sublineage B2.
  • Mutation Associations:
    • C6480A/T in L1: Associated with single infection (P=0.01) and persistent infection (P=0.047).
  • A6516G in L1: Associated with transient infection (P=0.018).
  • T309C (E6), C6480T (L1), C6600A (L1): More common in high-grade cytology (P<0.05).
  • C6480T in L1: Showed a significant positive correlation with high-grade cytology (P=0.035).
  • Lifestyle Factors: Younger coitarche age (P=0.021) and lower condom usage (P=0.045) were linked to multiple infections.
  • Vaccine Breakthrough: One case of HPV52 breakthrough infection was identified post-vaccination.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Geographic Limitation: The study population was primarily from Shanghai and Jiangsu provinces, limiting the generalizability of findings to other regions.
  • Low Frequency of Some Variations: Many identified variations occurred only once, making it difficult to definitively interpret their clinical significance.
  • Incomplete Genome Analysis: The study focused on E6 and L1 genes; a whole-genome analysis could provide a more comprehensive understanding of variations and their interactions.
  • Synonymous Mutations: The functional impact of synonymous mutations, particularly in L1, warrants further investigation as they can influence gene expression and RNA processing.
  • Recombination: The observed phylogenetic incongruence between E6 and L1 genes suggests potential recombination, which requires further study to understand its role in HPV evolution and pathogenicity.
  • Vaccine Escape: While one case of breakthrough infection was noted, more extensive studies are needed to fully assess the impact of HPV52 variants on vaccine efficacy and the mechanisms of immune escape.

Summary updated

Abstract

Human papillomavirus 52 (HPV52) infection is prevalent in the Chinese population, and variations in HPV52 show correlations with oncogenicity. However, no specific variation in HPV52 was reported to show relevancy to infection characteristics. In this study, we retrieved 222 isolates of E6 and L1 full-length genes from 197 Chinese women with HPV52 infection. After sequence alignment and phylogenetic tree construction, we found that 98.39 % of the collected variants belonged to the sublineage B2 and two variants displayed incongruence between the phylogenetic tree of E6 and L1. The analysis of the infection pattern showed that the presence of C6480A/T mutation in the L1 gene was associated with single infection (<i>P</i>=0.01) and persistent infection (<i>P</i>=0.047) of HPV52, while the A6516G nucleotide change was relevant to transient infection (<i>P</i>=0.018). Our data also indicated that variations T309C in the E6 gene and C6480T, C6600A in L1 were more commonly presented in patients with high-grade cytology (<i>P</i><0.05). One HPV52 breakthrough infection after vaccination was identified, which hinted at the immune escape post-vaccination. Young coitarche age and non-condom usage were correlated to multiple infections. This study provided insight into the polymorphism of HPV52 and revealed the impact of variations in HPV52 on its infection characteristics.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{gong2023possible,
  author = {Yingxin Gong and Yan Wang and Qi Zhou and Wenjie Qu and Fang Chen and Yaping Wang and Jiayin Mo and Hongwei Zhang and Lin Lin and Tianyi Bi and Xujie Wang and Jiashi Gu and Long Sui and Yanyun Li},
  title = {{The possible impact of novel mutations in human papillomavirus 52 on the infection characteristics}},
  booktitle = {Microbial},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1099/mgen.0.000962},
}
Figure