The pivotal role of the X-chromosome in the genetic architecture of the human brain

Zhiwen Jiang, Patrick F. Sullivan, Tengfei Li, Bingxin Zhao, Xifeng Wang, Tianyou Luo, Shuai Huang, Peter Y. Guan, Jie Chen, Yue Yang, Jason L. Stein, Yun Li, Dajiang J. Liu, Lei Sun, Hongtu ZhumedRxiv 2023 · DOI

Abstract

Genes on the X-chromosome are extensively expressed in the human brain. However, little is known for the X-chromosome's impact on the brain anatomy, microstructure, and functional network. We examined 1,045 complex brain imaging traits from 38,529 participants in the UK Biobank. We unveiled potential autosome-X-chromosome interactions, while proposing an atlas outlining dosage compensation (DC) for brain imaging traits. Through extensive association studies, we identified 72 genome-wide significant trait-locus pairs (including 29 new associations) that share genetic architectures with brain-related disorders, notably schizophrenia. Furthermore, we discovered unique sex-specific associations and assessed variations in genetic effects between sexes. Our research offers critical insights into the X-chromosome's role in the human brain, underscoring its contribution to the differences observed in brain structure and functionality between sexes.

Introduction

Despite comprising approximately 5% of the human genome, the X-chromosome has historically been treated as the "dark matter" of genetic research. Most large-scale Genome-Wide Association Studies (GWAS) exclude the X-chromosome due to the biological complexities of sex-linked inheritance. In humans, biological females typically possess two X-chromosomes, while males possess one X and one Y. To balance gene expression, females undergo Dosage Compensation (DC)—traditionally thought to be the complete silencing of one X-chromosome. However, this process is often incomplete, leading to variations in gene "dosage" that influence brain development and structure. This study systematically maps the X-chromosome's influence on brain anatomy, white matter microstructure, and functional networks.

Methodology and Datasets

The research team conducted an X-chromosome-wide association study (XWAS) utilizing a primary discovery set of approximately 34,000 participants from the UK Biobank, specifically focusing on individuals of European ancestry with high-quality brain MRI data. To validate the findings, independent replication cohorts totaling 4,900 individuals from diverse ancestries (including South Asian, Chinese, and African) were analyzed.

The researchers employed a sophisticated model selection strategy to determine the optimal DC fit for 2,822 brain imaging traits. They tested three primary models:

  1. Full DC: The standard model where one X-chromosome is fully silenced in females.
  2. No DC: A model where both X-chromosomes remain active, potentially leading to higher expression in females.
  3. Equal Variance: A statistical middle ground designed to account for complex genetic interactions.

Heritability was estimated using GCTA-GREML, and the XWAS was performed via PLINK2. To ensure statistical rigor across thousands of traits, a "wild bootstrap" method was applied to control for multiple testing.

The Dosage Compensation Atlas

A central contribution of this work is the creation of a Dosage Compensation Atlas for the human brain. The study revealed that DC is not a uniform process across all brain structures. While 69.4% of brain traits followed the traditional Full DC model, nearly 23% favored the "No DC" model. This suggests that for nearly a quarter of the brain's architectural traits, females may naturally receive a higher genetic dosage of X-linked influences than males.

Furthermore, the study identified significant "crosstalk" between the X-chromosome and the 22 pairs of autosomes. Traits that deviated from standard DC rules often exhibited lower autosomal heritability, suggesting that the X-chromosome plays a more dominant regulatory role in those specific brain structures.

Key Genetic Discoveries

The XWAS identified 72 genome-wide significant trait-locus pairs, 29 of which represent entirely new associations. Notable findings include:

  • The Xq28 Hotspot: A region on the long arm of the X-chromosome emerged as a critical hub for brain genetics, particularly influencing white matter tracts such as the superior corona radiata.
  • Schizophrenia and Intelligence Links: The study pinpointed a specific locus (rs2361468) near the gene PJA1 associated with the volume of the right ventral diencephalon. This locus shares a genetic architecture with schizophrenia and educational attainment.
  • White Matter and Motor Control: The X-chromosome showed a disproportionate impact on the corticospinal tract, which is essential for motor control, as well as various visual functional networks.

Sex-Specific Genetic Architecture

The study highlighted a distinct disparity in genetic associations between sexes. Significantly more associations were identified in males (33) than in females (9), despite comparable sample sizes. This suggests a "male vulnerability" or sensitivity to X-linked variants. Because males carry only one X-chromosome, they directly express the variants they carry. In contrast, the mosaic nature of X-inactivation in females may act as a biological buffer, masking or mitigating the effects of certain genetic variants.

Conclusion and Future Directions

This research provides a foundational map of how the X-chromosome shapes the human brain, offering a possible explanation for observed sex differences in brain structure and psychiatric vulnerability. However, the authors note that genetic associations are only one piece of the puzzle. Future research must integrate multi-omics data—including the transcriptome and proteome—to uncover the exact mechanisms by which these X-linked genes influence neurobiology. Additionally, expanding XWAS efforts to more diverse global populations is essential to ensure these insights are applicable across all human ancestries.

Summary updated

Abstract

Genes on the X-chromosome are extensively expressed in the human brain. However, little is known for the X-chromosome's impact on the brain anatomy, microstructure, and functional network. We examined 1,045 complex brain imaging traits from 38,529 participants in the UK Biobank. We unveiled potential autosome-X-chromosome interactions, while proposing an atlas outlining dosage compensation (DC) for brain imaging traits. Through extensive association studies, we identified 72 genome-wide significant trait-locus pairs (including 29 new associations) that share genetic architectures with brain-related disorders, notably schizophrenia. Furthermore, we discovered unique sex-specific associations and assessed variations in genetic effects between sexes. Our research offers critical insights into the X-chromosome's role in the human brain, underscoring its contribution to the differences observed in brain structure and functionality between sexes.
BibTeX
@misc{jiang2023pivotal,
  author = {Zhiwen Jiang and Patrick F. Sullivan and Tengfei Li and Bingxin Zhao and Xifeng Wang and Tianyou Luo and Shuai Huang and Peter Y. Guan and Jie Chen and Yue Yang and Jason L. Stein and Yun Li and Dajiang J. Liu and Lei Sun and Hongtu Zhu},
  title = {{The pivotal role of the X-chromosome in the genetic architecture of the human brain}},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1101/2023.08.30.23294848},
  howpublished = {medRxiv},
}
Figure