Abstract
Background: The COVID-19 pandemic necessitated a global shift to web-based physical education (PE). This study aimed to compare physical fitness data of college students before and after this transition. Methods: Students from the 2018 and 2019 cohorts at Wuhan University of Technology who participated in web-based PE in 2020 were included. Annual fitness test records from 2019 and 2020 were reviewed, covering weight, height, BMI, vital capacity (VC), 50-m dash, sit-and-reach, standing long jump, and gender-specific endurance/strength tests. Results: Analysis of 11,219 male and 4,651 female students showed significant declines in endurance (male 1,000-m race slowed by 14s; female 800-m by 11s). Male obesity rose from 10.6% to 15.2%. Conversely, improvements were noted in vital capacity, sit-and-reach, and standing long jump for both genders. Conclusions: Web-based PE requires alternatives for running tests, such as shuttle runs or fast running in place, to better maintain cardiovascular fitness.
Introduction
When the COVID-19 pandemic forced universities worldwide to shutter their gates, physical education—a traditionally hands-on, field-based discipline—had to pivot to the screen. While "Web-based PE" allowed students to continue their studies, its efficacy in maintaining physical health remained a critical question. This study seeks to quantify the impact of this digital shift by comparing pre-pandemic (2019) and post-lockdown (2020) fitness results among over 15,000 students in Wuhan, China.
Methods
The researchers conducted a retrospective cohort study at the Wuhan University of Technology, analyzing the annual fitness records of students from the 2018 and 2019 grade levels. The "Web-based PE" curriculum consisted of 90-minute weekly synchronous sessions covering warm-ups, specific sports (football, basketball, gymnastics, or Chinese Kung Fu), and relaxation, supplemented by one hour of daily asynchronous homework.
To measure the impact, the team used the National Physical Health Standards for Students, evaluating seven key metrics: BMI, vital capacity (VC), 50-m dash, sit-and-reach, standing long jump, and gender-specific tests (pull-ups/1000-m race for males; sit-ups/800-m race for females). All tests were standardized using the Lingkang physical fitness test set. Statistically, the Wilcoxon signed-rank test was employed to compare longitudinal data for the 15,870 students who completed tests in both years.
Results and Discussion
The transition to remote learning revealed a distinct "fitness tradeoff," where certain physical attributes improved while others significantly declined.
Endurance and Body Composition
The most striking finding was the sharp decline in running performance. Male 1,000-m race times slowed by an average of 14 seconds, and female 800-m times slowed by 11 seconds. This suggests that while students could perform indoor drills, cardiovascular endurance requires space and specialized facilities that were inaccessible during quarantine.
Furthermore, males were significantly more affected by weight gain than females. The percentage of male obesity jumped from 10.6% to 15.2%, while normal-weight status dropped from 55.9% to 51.9%. This gendered impact may stem from a more drastic reduction in typical high-intensity outdoor activity levels for males compared to females.
Flexibility and Explosive Strength
Surprisingly, metrics like the sit-and-reach (flexibility) and standing long jump (explosive strength) actually improved for both genders. This indicates that the web-based curriculum's focus on calisthenics and indoor-friendly exercises was effective for these specific physical attributes.
Vital Capacity Paradox
Despite the decline in running, vital capacity (lung function) improved. This might be due to natural late-adolescent development or the inclusion of traditional Chinese Kung Fu in the curriculum, which emphasizes deep breathing and core engagement.
Conclusion
The changes in physical fitness before and after web-based PE suggest that future remote curricula must evolve. Educators should prioritize "field-independent" endurance exercises, such as shuttle runs or fast running in place, to bridge the gap when traditional tracks are unavailable. Additionally, integrating more practical, equipment-light sports is essential to combat rising BMI trends and maintain holistic student health.
Summary updated