The persistence of large scale structures. Part I. Primordial non-Gaussianity

Matteo Biagetti, Alex Cole, Gary ShiuJournal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics 2021 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel pipeline using persistent homology, a topological data analysis technique, to extract cosmological information from the large-scale structure of the universe. This method can detect subtle imprints of primordial non-Gaussianity, a key feature of the early universe, in the distribution of dark matter halos, offering a complementary probe to traditional methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Cosmologists aim to understand the universe's origins and evolution by analyzing the distribution of matter on large scales. Traditional methods often rely on correlation functions, which capture only part of the complex structure. Primordial non-Gaussianity, a deviation from a perfectly smooth, random distribution of initial density fluctuations, is a crucial signature of early universe physics, particularly inflation. Detecting and quantifying this non-Gaussianity is challenging, especially at the low levels expected from many inflationary models. This paper addresses the need for new, more sensitive methods to probe these subtle signatures in the late-time structure of the universe, specifically focusing on the imprint of local primordial non-Gaussianity on dark matter halo distributions.

Methods

The core of this paper is the development and application of a persistent homology pipeline. Persistent homology is a technique from topological data analysis that quantifies the "shape" of data across multiple scales. It tracks topological features like clusters, filaments, and voids as they emerge and disappear during a "coarse-graining" process.

The pipeline involves:

  • Filtrations: Constructing a sequence of simplicial complexes from halo positions using various methods (α, αDTM, αDTMl filtrations), with the αDTMl filtration being favored for its robustness to outliers.
  • Persistence Diagrams: Computing diagrams that visualize the "birth" and "death" scales of topological features.
  • Derived Statistics: Transforming persistence diagrams into interpretable one-dimensional curves (e.g., Betti curves, birth, persistence, and death distributions) and Persistence Images (PIs) for statistical analysis.
  • Anomaly Detection: Identifying deviations between simulated "survey" data and "fiducial" mock data using a χ² statistic.
  • Template Fitting: Constructing theoretical "templates" of expected topological signatures for specific cosmological parameters (like primordial non-Gaussianity) and comparing them to observed anomalies to identify the underlying physics.
  • Subsampling: A crucial step to mitigate the impact of cosmic variance and variations in halo number density, allowing for more robust comparisons.

Datasets

The authors utilize the Eos DATASET, a suite of N-body simulations designed to study the imprint of primordial non-Gaussianity on large-scale structures. This dataset includes simulations with varying levels of local primordial non-Gaussianity ($f_{NL}^{loc}$) and $\sigma_8$. The simulations are performed at different resolutions and box sizes. For template construction, smaller box simulations with stronger non-Gaussianity are used.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Topology as a Sensitive Probe: Persistent homology offers a powerful way to capture information about the multiscale topology of the cosmic web, which is sensitive to the initial conditions of the universe, including primordial non-Gaussianity.
  • Filament Loops as Key Signatures: Filament loops, a prominent topological feature in the cosmic web, are found to be particularly sensitive to primordial non-Gaussianity.
  • Complementary to Power Spectrum: The topological statistics derived from persistent homology probe information at scales of O(10) Mpc/h, complementing traditional methods like the power spectrum that rely on larger scales. This allows for constraints without needing to sample very long-wavelength modes.
  • Interpretability is Key: The use of interpretable topological features and statistics allows for physical understanding of the results and the ability to apply cuts to exclude unreliable simulation scales.
  • Template Method for Parameter Inference: The development of an asymptotic template method provides a robust framework for identifying and constraining specific cosmological parameters, such as $f_{NL}^{loc}$.

Key Results

  • The pipeline successfully detects local primordial non-Gaussianity with $f_{NL}^{loc} = 10$ at 97.5% confidence in approximately 85% of the simulated volumes.
  • The method demonstrates the ability to resolve degeneracies between the signatures of non-Gaussianity and variations in $\sigma_8$ using an optimal template approach.
  • The analysis highlights that topological features at O(10) Mpc/h are crucial for these constraints, offering a new avenue for cosmological inference.
  • The paper reproduces known results for the effect of non-Gaussianity on void statistics and predicts new signatures for filament loop statistics.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Approximations for Real Data: The study uses halo catalogs as a proxy for galaxies, which involves several unrealistic approximations (e.g., one-to-one correspondence, baryon effects, redshift-space distortions). The authors acknowledge that these results are a preliminary assessment for real data.
  • Simulation Volume: While the method doesn't require sampling very long-wavelength modes, it still requires a large volume to obtain significant constraints.
  • Template Optimization: While the current templates are effective, further optimization of parameters in Persistence Images could potentially yield even better results.
  • Baryon Effects and Redshift-Space Distortions: Future work should incorporate these effects for a more realistic application to observational data.
  • Constraining Multiple Parameters: The paper focuses on $f_{NL}^{loc}$ and $\sigma_8$, but future work aims to extend this to a wider range of cosmological parameters and explore degeneracies more comprehensively.
  • Analytical Derivations: The authors suggest that new analytical work is needed to derive the distribution of features like filament loop deaths from first principles.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract We develop an analysis pipeline for characterizing the topology of large scale structure and extracting cosmological constraints based on persistent homology . Persistent homology is a technique from topological data analysis that quantifies the multiscale topology of a data set, in our context unifying the contributions of clusters, filament loops, and cosmic voids to cosmological constraints. We describe how this method captures the imprint of primordial local non-Gaussianity on the late-time distribution of dark matter halos, using a set of N-body simulations as a proxy for real data analysis. For our best single statistic, running the pipeline on several cubic volumes of size 40 (Gpc/h) 3 , we detect f NL loc =10 at 97.5% confidence on ∼ 85% of the volumes. Additionally we test our ability to resolve degeneracies between the topological signature of f NL loc and variation of σ 8 and argue that correctly identifying nonzero f NL loc in this case is possible via an optimal template method. Our method relies on information living at 𝒪(10) Mpc/h, a complementary scale with respect to commonly used methods such as the scale-dependent bias in the halo/galaxy power spectrum. Therefore, while still requiring a large volume, our method does not require sampling long-wavelength modes to constrain primordial non-Gaussianity. Moreover, our statistics are interpretable: we are able to reproduce previous results in certain limits and we make new predictions for unexplored observables, such as filament loops formed by dark matter halos in a simulation box.
BibTeX
@article{biagetti2021persistence,
  author = {Matteo Biagetti and Alex Cole and Gary Shiu},
  title = {{The persistence of large scale structures. Part I. Primordial non-Gaussianity}},
  journal = {Journal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1088/1475-7516/2021/04/061},
}
Figure