THE PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF BDS POSITIONING IN NORDIC AREAS BASED ON THE SMARTPHONE

Chen Chen, Chunxia Jiang, Yuming Bo, James Jiusi Jia, Haibin Sun, Zhiguo He2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the performance of China's BeiDou Navigation Satellite System (BDS) for smartphone-based positioning in Nordic regions. The study found that BDS offers good satellite visibility and comparable horizontal positioning accuracy to GPS, though with some limitations in the vertical dimension, especially with BDS-3 signals. Integrating BDS with other GNSS systems significantly enhances positioning accuracy.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The increasing prevalence of smartphones with GNSS capabilities has opened up new avenues for location-based services (LBS). While traditional GNSS like GPS, Galileo, and GLONASS have been extensively studied, China's BeiDou Navigation Satellite System (BDS), particularly with its global coverage after the BDS-3 deployment, is a relatively newer player. There's a need to understand its performance, especially in regions outside its primary service area, like the Nordic countries. This paper aims to fill this gap by evaluating the quality of BDS signals and its positioning accuracy using a smartphone in Espoo, Finland, and comparing it against established GNSS.

Methods

The researchers conducted both static and kinematic experiments in Espoo, Finland.

  • Static Experiment: Data was collected for one hour in an open-sky environment at the Finnish Geospatial Research Institute (FGI). A specialized experimental box provided Real-Time Kinematic (RTK) results as a centimeter-level ground truth.
  • Kinematic Experiment: Data was collected during a 15-minute drive along a pre-planned route in Espoo, designed to include challenging environments like urban canyons and tunnels. RTK data from a Novatel antenna mounted on the vehicle served as the ground truth trajectory.

The Huawei Mate 40 Pro smartphone was used to collect GNSS data (BDS, GPS, Galileo, GLONASS) using the GEO++RINEX Android app. The analysis focused on:

  • Signal Quality: Carrier-to-noise density ratio (C/N0) was analyzed to assess signal strength.
  • Satellite Geometry: Dilution of Precision (DOP) values (GDOP, PDOP, HDOP, VDOP) were calculated to evaluate the spatial distribution of visible satellites.
  • Satellite Visibility: The number of tracked satellites for each constellation was monitored.
  • Positioning Performance: Single-point positioning (SPP) accuracy was evaluated for BDS, GPS, GLONASS, and combinations thereof, comparing them against RTK ground truth.

Datasets

The study utilized real-world GNSS observation data collected by a Huawei Mate 40 Pro smartphone during static and kinematic experiments in Espoo, Finland. The data included signals from BDS, GPS, Galileo, and GLONASS. Ground truth data was obtained using RTK positioning from a specialized experimental box (static) and a Novatel antenna (kinematic). No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, existing GNSS signals were analyzed in a specific geographical context.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • BDS's Global Reach is Real: The successful deployment of BDS-3 means it can indeed offer navigation services worldwide, including in Nordic regions, as demonstrated by the experiments.
  • BDS Signal Strength Varies: While BDS-2 signals showed C/N0 comparable to GPS, BDS-3 signals were slightly weaker. This is attributed to a higher proportion of BDS-3 satellites being tracked at lower elevation angles in this specific experiment.
  • Nordic Environment Challenges BDS-3: The study suggests that BDS-3 signals might be less robust in Nordic areas, potentially due to the observed low elevation angles and the short observation period.
  • Fusion is Key for Accuracy: Combining BDS with other GNSS systems (GPS, GLONASS) significantly improves positioning accuracy and reliability, especially in challenging environments. This highlights the benefit of multi-constellation receivers.
  • Galileo's Limited Smartphone Performance: Despite good geometric distribution, Galileo's performance on the tested smartphone was hampered by a consistently low number of visible satellites (often less than 4), making it difficult to achieve reliable positioning.

Key Results

  • Satellite Visibility: BDS demonstrated excellent satellite visibility in Espoo, often tracking more satellites than other constellations.
  • C/N0: BDS-2 C/N0 was comparable to GPS (BDS-2: 34.22 dB-Hz, GPS: 35.16 dB-Hz). BDS-3 C/N0 was lower.
  • Horizontal Positioning: BDS horizontal positioning accuracy was comparable to GPS in the east direction but slightly inferior in the north direction.
  • Vertical Positioning: BDS showed poorer precision in the up (vertical) direction compared to GPS.
  • Multi-GNSS Improvement: Combining BDS with GPS and GLONASS significantly improved positioning accuracy in both static and kinematic scenarios, reducing deviations and increasing the concentration of results. For instance, the RMSE for GPS/BDS/GLONASS in the static experiment was 7.40m (Up), compared to 21.69m for BDS alone.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Short Observation Period: The authors acknowledge that the observation periods (1 hour static, 15 minutes kinematic) were relatively short. Longer observation times would provide more robust statistical results.
  • Smartphone Hardware Limitations: The performance of GNSS chips in smartphones can be a limiting factor, especially for weaker signals like BDS-3 at low elevations. Future studies could explore different smartphone models.
  • Nordic Signal Quality: The observed lower C/N0 for BDS-3 in Nordic areas warrants further investigation. The authors suggest this could be due to the specific satellite geometry and the short duration of the experiment.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that future research should focus on longer observation periods, different smartphone hardware, and the continued evolution of BDS and smartphone GNSS chipsets, which are expected to enhance positioning performance.

Summary updated

Abstract

Nowadays, the Global Navigation Satellite System (GNSS) is widely used in many applications. As a new system, China's BeiDou navigation system (BDS) is emerging in recent years. The last satellite of the third generation global BeiDou navigation system (BDS-3) has been successfully launched on June 23 in 2020, which means that BDS can offer navigation services worldwide. We evaluate the quality of BDS signals and analyze the performance of BDS positioning based on the smartphone in Espoo, Finland. The static and kinematic experiments were implemented in the parking lot of the Finish Geospatial Research Institute (FGI) and a highway route in Espoo, respectively. Experimental results show that BDS has good satellite visibility and geometric distribution. The signal carrier-to-noise density ratio (C/N0) of BDS-2 reaches 34.22 dB-Hz, which is comparable to the Global Positioning System (GPS). However, the signal carrier-to-noise density of BDS-3 is slightly lower than BDS-2, which is due to the significant number of BDS-3 satellites at low elevation angles. The horizontal precision of BDS positioning in the static and kinematic experiment is comparable to GPS in the east direction and slightly inferior to GPS in the north direction. However, the BDS shows poor precision in the up direction. In addition, the integration of BDS with other GNSS systems can significantly improve the positioning precision. This study intends to provide a reference for further research on the BDS global Positioning, Navigation, and Timing (PNT) services, particularly for LBS and smartphone positioning.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chen2022performance,
  author = {Chen Chen and Yuwei Chen and Chunxia Jiang and Yuming Bo and James Jiusi Jia and Haibin Sun and Zhiguo He},
  title = {{THE PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF BDS POSITIONING IN NORDIC AREAS BASED ON THE SMARTPHONE}},
  booktitle = {˜The},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.5194/isprs-archives-xlvi-3-w1-2022-21-2022},
}
Figure