The Pediatric Emergency Care Applied Research Network: Progress and Update

Peter Dayan, James Chamberlain, Jay B. Dean, Ronald F. Maio, Nathan KuppermannClinical 2006 · DOI

TL;DR

The Pediatric Emergency Care Applied Research Network (PECARN) is a federally funded initiative established in 2001 to address the critical need for research in pediatric emergency medical services for children (EMSC). This paper details PECARN's progress over its first four years, highlighting its development of infrastructure, research agenda, and rigorous processes for conducting high-quality, generalizable studies on rare pediatric conditions, ultimately aiming to improve patient outcomes.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Prior to PECARN's establishment, research in pediatric emergency medicine, particularly concerning emergency medical services for children (EMSC), was fragmented and limited. A significant barrier was the difficulty in studying infrequent or rare adverse outcomes in diverse pediatric populations due to the lack of coordinated, multicenter research efforts. This fragmentation hindered the development of evidence-based practices and policies crucial for improving the care of acutely ill and injured children. PECARN was created to overcome these limitations by establishing a national network capable of conducting large-scale, high-quality research.

Methods

PECARN employs a structured, multicenter approach to research. Key methodological aspects include:

  • Network Infrastructure: Establishment of four nodal centers overseeing 21 emergency departments (EDs) across nine states and the District of Columbia, ensuring diverse patient populations and research capabilities.
  • Steering Committee and Subcommittees: A governing steering committee, supported by four subcommittees (Protocol Concept Review and Development, Safety and Regulatory, Quality Assurance, Grants and Publication, Feasibility and Budget), guides research prioritization, protocol development, and operational policies.
  • Research Agenda Development: Utilization of the nominal group process and Hanlon method for prioritizing research topics, focusing on EMSC-relevant conditions.
  • Protocol Development and Review: A rigorous process involving initial development within nodes or working groups, submission to the Protocol Concept Review and Development Subcommittee for detailed critique, and subsequent review and endorsement by the steering committee. External investigators are encouraged to submit proposals.
  • Data Management: Integration of the Central Data Management and Coordinating Center (CDMCC) at the University of Utah for study design, implementation, and analysis.
  • Quality Assurance: Development of report cards to measure the performance of nodes, individual sites, and the CDMCC, ensuring accountability and continuous improvement.
  • Site Monitoring: Intensive monitoring of all studies, regardless of type, to maintain scientific rigor and ensure consistent implementation of study procedures across sites.

Datasets

The paper does not explicitly list specific datasets used for training or evaluation in the traditional machine learning sense. However, it highlights the use of:

  • PECARN Core Data Project: This project collected and analyzed annual information from existing electronic sources and medical records across all network sites. This served as a foundational dataset for understanding ED visit epidemiology and generating hypotheses.
  • National data sets: The taxonomy system developed for pediatric emergencies was applied to other national datasets to assess its consistency and comprehensiveness.

No new benchmarks were introduced; rather, existing data sources were leveraged and analyzed within the PECARN framework.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Power of Collaboration: The success of PECARN underscores the critical importance of a coordinated, multicenter approach to tackle complex research questions in pediatric emergency medicine, especially those involving rare outcomes.
  • Bridging the Gap Between Research and Practice: PECARN's explicit goal of translating research findings into improved clinical practices and health outcomes (Level IV impact) is a crucial differentiator from purely academic research.
  • Addressing Rare but Critical Conditions: The network's ability to study conditions with infrequent but serious outcomes (e.g., traumatic brain injury, status epilepticus) is a significant advancement, enabling the development of evidence-based guidelines where none previously existed.
  • The Importance of Infrastructure and Process: The detailed description of PECARN's infrastructure, governance, and research processes highlights the foundational work required to conduct high-quality, multicenter research effectively.
  • Navigating Regulatory Hurdles: The challenges faced with Institutional Review Boards (IRBs) and the strategies employed to address them (e.g., advocating for waivers of informed consent for minimal-risk studies) offer valuable lessons for other multicenter research initiatives.

Key Results

  • Infrastructure Development: Within its first four years, PECARN established a fully operational infrastructure, including four nodal centers and a steering committee, and integrated a central data management center.
  • Research Agenda: A prioritized list of 16 research topics was developed, focusing on critical areas like respiratory illness, injury prevention, and medication error reduction.
  • Study Completion and Funding: Of eight proposals submitted for extramural funding, six were successfully funded.
  • Completed and Ongoing Studies: The paper details several completed and ongoing research projects, including the PECARN Core Data Project, a study on creating a diagnosis grouping system for child ED visits, and a prospective study on a neuroimaging decision rule for childhood head trauma.
  • Enrollment Success: The "Childhood Head Trauma" study successfully enrolled 30,000 patients, making it the largest of its kind, with ongoing efforts to validate the decision rule.
  • Clinical Trials: PECARN has initiated its first randomized clinical trial on the effectiveness of oral dexamethasone for acute bronchiolitis, with over 500 patients enrolled.
  • Preliminary Studies: Two preliminary studies are underway concerning therapeutic hypothermia for pediatric cardiac arrest and the pharmacokinetics of lorazepam for pediatric status epilepticus, paving the way for future randomized trials.

Limitations and Future Work

Limitations:

  • IRB Variability: Inconsistent practices and staffing of local IRBs presented challenges, leading to delays in protocol review and approval.
  • Funding Constraints: The large scope of PECARN studies necessitates significant extramural funding, and securing adequate financial support for investigators and institutions remains a challenge, often leading to less-than-optimal financial support for study site investigators.
  • Site Performance Variability: Variability in study performance across sites, particularly in patient enrollment and follow-up, required intensive monitoring.

Future Work:

  • Continued High-Priority Research: PECARN aims to continue performing rigorous hospital-based and prehospital-based EMSC research.
  • Prehospital Research Emphasis: A strong future emphasis will be placed on prehospital research, leveraging established relationships with prehospital agencies and a dedicated Prehospital Working Group.
  • Translation and Dissemination: A key focus will be on studying and promoting the transfer and translation of scientific evidence to EMSC health care leaders, policymakers, and practitioners to improve patient outcomes.
  • Implementation Studies: PECARN plans to conduct studies to implement validated decision rules (e.g., for head trauma) and measure their impact on clinical practice, patient health, and cost-effectiveness.
  • Pediatric Safety Research: The network recognizes the critical need to improve pediatric patient safety in the ED and plans to conduct studies on adverse events during procedural sedations and establish a networkwide incident reporting system for medical errors.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{dayan2006pediatric,
  author = {Peter Dayan and James Chamberlain and Jay B. Dean and Ronald F. Maio and Nathan Kuppermann},
  title = {{The Pediatric Emergency Care Applied Research Network: Progress and Update}},
  booktitle = {Clinical},
  year = {2006},
  doi = {10.1016/j.cpem.2006.03.006},
}
Figure