The Paths of Enterprises Independent Innovation Based on Products Upgrade

Xiaohua Sun, Wentao GuoInternational Journal of Business and Management 2009 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores how Chinese enterprises can achieve independent innovation by focusing on product upgrades. It proposes a three-phase path: knowledge accumulation, product upgrade, and finally, independent innovation, highlighting the crucial role of entrepreneurs, R&D personnel, effort, and incentive mechanisms in this process.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper addresses the challenge faced by Chinese enterprises in achieving independent innovation, particularly in contrast to developed countries. It notes that while developed nations invest heavily in R&D (over 2% of GDP, even 4% in Israel), China's R&D intensity is significantly lower (1.49%). This lack of investment hinders the accumulation of necessary knowledge for true independent innovation. The authors argue that a common strategy of simply introducing and absorbing foreign technology isn't enough. Instead, they propose that focusing on "product upgrade" can serve as a bridge to independent innovation, reducing risks and building capabilities.

Methods

The paper's methodology is primarily conceptual and analytical, drawing on existing literature and proposing a framework. It doesn't present empirical data or experimental results in the traditional sense. The core "method" involves:

  • Analyzing the interactive relationship: Examining how product upgrades and independent innovation influence each other.
  • Proposing a path: Outlining a sequential model for achieving independent innovation through product upgrades, consisting of three phases: knowledge accumulation, product upgrade, and independent innovation.
  • Identifying product upgrade directions: Detailing four specific ways enterprises can upgrade products: expanding features, enhancing quality/service life, improving design, and reducing production/use costs.
  • Analyzing influencing factors: Discussing the impact of four key elements on the success of this path: the quality of entrepreneurs, the quantity and quality of R&D personnel, the level of effort, and the incentive mechanism.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Product Upgrade as a Stepping Stone: The central idea is that product upgrades aren't just about incremental improvements; they can be a strategic pathway to building the foundational capabilities and reducing the risks associated with full-blown independent innovation.
  • Reducing Innovation Risk: By leveraging existing product knowledge and core technologies, product upgrades make innovation less risky than entirely novel product development. This is particularly relevant for enterprises with limited R&D budgets.
  • Market Validation and Profitability: Product upgrades can lead to increased market acceptance, higher profits (e.g., through differentiation and avoiding price wars), and a stronger brand effect, creating a virtuous cycle.
  • Four Paths to Product Upgrade: The paper clearly defines how to upgrade products:
  • Expand Features: Adding new functionalities to existing, recognized products.
  • Enhance Quality & Service Life: Improving durability and performance to build brand loyalty.
  • Make Leading Designs: Focusing on aesthetic and functional design to appeal to consumers.
  • Reduce Cost: Optimizing production and use costs to gain a competitive price advantage.
  • The Human Element is Crucial: The success of this path heavily relies on the quality of entrepreneurs (vision, strategy), the availability and skill of R&D personnel, the dedication (effort) of the workforce, and effective incentive systems that reward innovation.

Key Results

The paper doesn't present quantitative results from experiments or surveys. Its "results" are conceptual:

  • A proposed three-phase model for independent innovation based on product upgrades: Knowledge Accumulation → Products Upgrade → Independent Innovation.
  • Identification of four key directions for product upgrades.
  • An analysis of how four factors (entrepreneur quality, R&D personnel, effort, incentive mechanism) influence the success of this innovation path.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Lack of Empirical Validation: The paper is largely theoretical. It proposes a framework but does not empirically test its effectiveness or provide quantitative data on the success rates of enterprises following this path.
  • Generalizability: While the paper focuses on Chinese enterprises, the extent to which this model applies to enterprises in different economic contexts or industries is not deeply explored.
  • Future Work: The authors implicitly suggest future work would involve empirical studies to validate the proposed model and analyze the specific impact of each influencing factor in real-world scenarios. Further research could also delve deeper into the specific types of knowledge accumulation and product upgrade combinations that are most effective.

Summary updated

Abstract

On basis of the interactive relationship between products upgrade and independent innovation, the possibility of the paths of enterprises independent innovation based on products upgrade are studied. Then, four directions of products upgrade further and the paths of enterprises independent innovation are brought out. Finally, the paper analyzes the impact of the quality of entrepreneurs, R & D personnel, the level of effort, and the incentive mechanism on the paths of enterprises independent innovation based on products upgrade.
BibTeX
@article{sun2009paths,
  author = {Xiaohua Sun and Wentao Guo},
  title = {{The Paths of Enterprises Independent Innovation Based on Products Upgrade}},
  journal = {International Journal of Business and Management},
  year = {2009},
  doi = {10.5539/ijbm.v4n9p25},
}
Figure