The Past is the Link to the Present, and the Future is the Future

Na Li, Danni Li, Zheng Wang, Zixun WangFrontiers in Business Economics and Management 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the decline of the Bengbu Flower Drum Lantern, a UNESCO-recognized intangible cultural heritage in China, which is currently threatened by an aging practitioner base and the pressures of modernization. The authors propose a multi-dimensional revitalization strategy that integrates systematic academic training, "Internet +" digital promotion, and tourism-driven economic models to bridge the gap between ancient tradition and contemporary society.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Bengbu Flower Drum Lantern (Huagu Lantern) is a complex folk art combining dance, song, martial arts, and percussion, famously dubbed the "Oriental Ballet" by Premier Zhou Enlai. Despite its status as a national cultural treasure, it faces an existential "inheritance gap."

The authors identify several critical challenges:

  • Demographic Shift: Traditional "old artists" are passing away, while rural youth are migrating to cities, leaving few disciples to carry on the craft.
  • Economic Viability: Performers cannot sustain themselves on art alone; low income forces potential inheritors into more stable manual labor.
  • Cultural Disconnect: The traditional aesthetic of the Huaihe River basin struggles to compete with diversified modern entertainment and digital media.
  • Ineffective Protection: Existing "Ecological Villages" and exhibition halls suffer from poor management, low funding, and a lack of professional staff.

Methods

The researchers employed a qualitative, dual-track methodology:

  1. Literature Analysis: A systematic review of existing research via major Chinese academic databases (CNKI, Wanfang Data, and Super Star Huia eBooks) to establish the historical trajectory and artistic style of the "Feng School" of the lantern dance.
  2. Field Research: The authors conducted immersive fieldwork in the Huaihe River basin. This involved participating in dances first-hand and conducting semi-structured interviews with a diverse stakeholder group, including local residents, non-geneticists, veteran artists, and academic experts.

Datasets

As a qualitative social science study, the paper does not utilize large-scale computational datasets or standardized benchmarks. Instead, the "data" consists of:

  • Historical records and playwright accounts (e.g., Kong Shangren’s "Dancers' Words" from the Qing Dynasty).
  • Qualitative interview transcripts and field observations from Bengbu City and Huaiyuan County.
  • Performance statistics (e.g., the art has been performed in 13 Asian countries).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Three Bends" Aesthetic: The dance is characterized by specific body curves known as the "three bends," which the authors argue possess both aesthetic and scientific value in how they demonstrate the combination of movement and stillness.
  • The Training Bottleneck: Mastery is not intuitive; the paper notes that the "Lantern Field" performance requires two years of practice, while "Drum Performance" (integrating acrobatics and martial arts) requires at least five years. Current "unsystematic" training is failing to meet these rigorous requirements.
  • The Innovation Paradox: There is a tension between "protection" and "development." The authors warn against "blindly" adding foreign elements that destroy the cultural foundation, suggesting instead that innovation must be rooted in the initial form while catering to modern sensibilities.
  • Institutional Integration: The authors highlight the success of the Beijing Dance School in incorporating these folk dances into their curriculum, suggesting that academic "credits" could be a viable path for cultural inheritance.

Key Results

The paper outlines a four-stage historical evolution of the art form—from its Song Dynasty origins to its post-1949 "resurgence" and its current struggle for "rebirth."

To ensure survival, the authors propose a four-pillar roadmap:

  1. Academic Professionalization: Establishing dedicated majors in universities like Anhui Normal University to provide systematic, rather than purely oral, instruction.
  2. The "Tourism + Lantern" Model: Creating unique cultural brands that allow tourists to participate in the art, providing a direct economic engine for performers.
  3. Digital Publicity: Leveraging short-video platforms like TikTok (Douyin) and Kwai to reach younger audiences and collect community feedback for targeted reforms.
  4. Professional Teams: Moving away from fragmented individual efforts toward "brainstorming" professional teams that can manage the art's brand and innovation.

Limitations and Future Work

The paper is primarily descriptive and qualitative. It lacks quantitative data on the exact economic impact of the proposed tourism models or the conversion rates of social media engagement to actual practitioner recruitment.

Future work could involve:

  • Developing specific "Internet +" metrics to measure the success of digital outreach.
  • Longitudinal studies on the career paths of students graduating from the newly established Flower Drum Lantern university majors.
  • Comparative analysis with other intangible cultural heritage forms that have successfully modernized (e.g., certain styles of Peking Opera).

Summary updated

Abstract

As a characteristic intangible cultural heritage spread in the Huaihe River basin of Anhui Province, Huagu Lantern has emerged as early as 2006, been successfully selected and included in the national intangible cultural heritage list. However, in the context of the accelerated modernization process, the inheritance and development of Bengbu Flower Drum Lantern has been seriously hindered due to the death of traditional old artists, unsystematic personnel training and many other reasons. Therefore, through literature analysis, field survey and other research methods, this paper finds out the problems of Bengbu Flower Drum Lantern, analyzes the influencing factors, and makes Bengbu Flower Drum Lantern have a better inheritance through innovation and reform.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2022past,
  author = {Na Li and Danni Li and Zheng Wang and Zixun Wang},
  title = {{The Past is the Link to the Present, and the Future is the Future}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Business Economics and Management},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.54097/fbem.v6i1.2307},
}
Figure