The past and future of the generalist general surgeon

Eric M. Webber, Vivian C. McAlister, Lisa Gorman, Sarah Taber, Kenneth D. HarrisCanadian 2014 · DOI

Abstract

Over the past 2 years, the national Task Force on the Future of General Surgery has grappled with questions related to the future configuration of the discipline. The goal is to ensure training that optimally prepares surgeons for practice in the full range of settings where general surgeons work.

Introduction

The discipline of general surgery is currently navigating a profound identity crisis. As medical knowledge expands and surgical techniques become increasingly sophisticated, the field has fractured into numerous subspecialties, such as vascular, thoracic, and colorectal surgery. While this hyper-specialization often leads to improved outcomes for specific conditions, it creates a significant gap in the "generalist" skillset. In a geographically vast country like Canada, the generalist general surgeon remains a cornerstone of the healthcare system, providing essential care in underserviced and rural areas where a full suite of subspecialists is not available.

The Historical Context of Specialization

Specialization is not a new phenomenon, but its formalization has changed the landscape of surgical practice. Historically, specialization was often a matter of personal interest rather than formal certification. For instance, "oculists" (early specialists in eye and ear disorders) operated under the umbrella of general medicine long before ophthalmology was recognized as a distinct, regulated discipline in 1937.

Today, the proliferation of specialized skills has created a tension between "depth" and "breadth." The modern general surgeon is increasingly viewed not just as a technician, but as a coordinator of care for patients with complex, multi-system problems that cross traditional disciplinary boundaries.

Addressing the Geographic Imperative

Canada’s unique geographic dispersion dictates a need for versatile surgeons. A surgical model optimized for a major urban academic center in Toronto is often unsustainable for a community hospital in a remote province. To address this, the national Task Force on the Future of General Surgery has advocated for a strategic shift in how surgeons are trained and deployed. The goal is to move away from a "one-size-fits-all" curriculum toward a model that recognizes the variable requirements of practices molded by location, patient need, and healthcare costs.

Competence by Design: A New Educational Framework

The core of this proposed transformation is "Competence by Design" (CBD), a hybrid model of competency-based medical education (CBME). Unlike traditional residency programs, which are largely time-based (requiring a trainee to spend a fixed number of years in a program), CBD focuses on the mastery of specific competencies and milestones.

This approach allows for "tailored" training. A resident can focus on acquiring the specific technical expertise required for their intended practice context, whether that be high-volume specialized surgery or broad-spectrum rural general surgery.

Strategic Recommendations for the Future

The Task Force outlined four primary pillars to reshape the discipline:

  1. Curriculum Redesign: Introducing "enhanced areas of expertise" within general surgery training that are specifically tailored to different practice contexts.
  2. Transition to Practice: Incorporating an explicit period during residency focused on the transition to independent practice, ensuring trainees are prepared for the logistical and clinical demands of their first post-residency roles.
  3. Competency-Based Education: Fully implementing the CBD model across postgraduate medical education to ensure consistent standards of mastery.
  4. Post-General Surgery Training: Developing recognized subspecialty residency programs and "Areas of Focused Competence" (diplomas). These are intended to complement general surgery expertise rather than replace it, allowing surgeons to maintain a broad base while gaining specialized skills.

Conclusion and Future Directions

While the shift toward competency-based education offers a promising solution to the generalist-specialist divide, it is not without challenges. As a policy-driven framework, the long-term efficacy of Competence by Design remains to be seen. Future research must involve longitudinal studies to determine if this approach improves surgical outcomes, enhances physician retention in rural areas, and effectively balances the need for specialized expertise with the necessity of broad-based surgical care. Ultimately, the future of general surgery depends on its ability to adapt to the diverse needs of the population it serves.

Summary updated

Abstract

Over the past 2 years, the national Task Force on the Future of General Surgery has grappled with questions related to the future configuration of the discipline. The goal is to ensure training that optimally prepares surgeons for practice in the full range of settings where general surgeons work in
BibTeX
@inproceedings{webber2014past,
  author = {Eric M. Webber and Vivian C. McAlister and Lisa Gorman and Sarah Taber and Kenneth D. Harris},
  title = {{The past and future of the generalist general surgeon}},
  booktitle = {Canadian},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.1503/cjs.033213},
}
Figure