The Parameterization of the Sound Speed Profile in the Sea of Japan and Its Perturbation Caused by a Synoptic Eddy

M. A. Sorokin, A. I. Gudimenko, В. А. Лучин, Andrey G. Tyshchenko, Pavel S. PetrovJournal of Marine Science and Engineering 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel analytical parameterization for sound speed profiles (SSPs) in the Sea of Japan, specifically accounting for the influence of synoptic eddies. By linking the background SSP to the Morse potential, the authors derive analytical solutions for acoustic modes, enabling more efficient modeling of sound propagation in complex oceanic environments.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Accurately modeling how sound travels through the ocean is crucial for applications like underwater navigation, communication, and remote sensing. Sound propagation is heavily influenced by the sound speed profile (SSP), which describes how sound speed changes with depth. Real-world oceans, however, are not uniform; they contain dynamic features like internal waves, fronts, and synoptic eddies that perturb the average SSP. While analytical models exist for idealized SSPs (like the Munk profile), accurately capturing the impact of these oceanic perturbations, particularly synoptic eddies, on acoustic modes has been a significant challenge. Existing methods often rely on complex numerical simulations, which can be computationally expensive. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing an analytical framework to describe and model the effects of synoptic eddies on sound propagation.

Methods

The authors propose a two-step approach:

  1. Background SSP Parameterization: They first parameterize the "background" SSP (the average profile away from the eddy) using the canonical Munk profile, fitting experimental data using a least-squares method. However, to enable analytical solutions for acoustic modes, they then adopt a Morse potential formulation. This is a key innovation, as it transforms the Sturm–Liouville equation for acoustic modes into an eigenvalue problem analogous to the Schrödinger equation with a Morse potential. This equivalence allows for the derivation of analytical expressions for normal modes and their horizontal wavenumbers.
  2. Eddy Perturbation Parameterization: The perturbation caused by a synoptic eddy is then modeled. Instead of a simple Gaussian function, they employ a Maxwell-Boltzmann-like distribution for the vertical dependence and a more general elliptical Gaussian for the horizontal dependence. This accounts for potential asymmetries in the eddy's structure, which are often observed in real data and are not captured by simpler models.

Finally, they utilize perturbation theory for acoustic modes to analyze how the eddy-induced SSP changes affect the horizontal wavenumbers of these modes.

Datasets

The study utilizes oceanographic data collected during the summer of 1999 in the Sea of Japan. This dataset includes CTD (Conductivity, Temperature, Depth) downcasts taken along two perpendicular transects that approximately captured a stable anticyclonic synoptic eddy. These transects allowed for the determination of both the background SSP and the three-dimensional perturbation caused by the eddy. The data was used for fitting the proposed analytical models.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Morse Potential as a Bridge: The crucial insight is the equivalence between the Sturm–Liouville equation for acoustic modes and the Schrödinger equation with a Morse potential. This connection unlocks analytical solutions for acoustic modes and their wavenumbers, which is a significant advancement over purely numerical approaches.
  • Eddy Asymmetry Matters: Simple Gaussian models for eddy perturbations are insufficient. The use of a more flexible parameterization (elliptical Gaussian horizontally, Maxwell-Boltzmann vertically) better captures the observed asymmetric structure of the synoptic eddy.
  • Perturbation Theory's Utility: Standard perturbation theory for acoustic modes proves effective in describing the variability of horizontal wavenumbers within the eddy's influence, even for moderate eddy strengths. This allows for semi-analytical modeling of sound propagation through such features.
  • Adiabatic Propagation: For low-order modes (those trapped in the SOFAR channel with small grazing angles), the study suggests that sound propagation through the eddy can be considered adiabatic, meaning the modes evolve independently without significant energy transfer between them. This simplifies modeling efforts.

Key Results

  • The proposed Morse potential parameterization provides a good analytical approximation for the background SSP, with excellent agreement with numerical solutions for low-order modes.
  • The developed parameterization for the eddy perturbation accurately reproduces the observed sound speed field perturbation, with a standard deviation of 0.38 m/s and a maximum deviation of 2.05 m/s.
  • Perturbation theory, particularly second-order, shows good accuracy in predicting the changes in horizontal wavenumbers due to the eddy, especially when the eddy's influence is significant.
  • The study demonstrates that for low-order modes, the horizontal wavenumbers do not intersect as they propagate through the eddy, supporting the adiabatic approximation.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Local Approximation: The Morse potential approximation for the background SSP is noted to be most accurate locally around the SOFAR axis. For higher-order modes whose turning points lie outside this interval, discrepancies can arise.
  • Extreme Perturbation: The paper acknowledges that the full-magnitude perturbation case studied is somewhat extreme for standard perturbation theory, as the eddy's potential perturbation is large relative to the equivalent potential well.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that their analytical parameterizations could be used for performing analytical simulations of acoustic wave propagation, offering more physical insight than direct numerical solutions. They also highlight the potential for using these models in conjunction with mode parabolic equations or vertical modes/horizontal rays approximations. Further investigation into the physics of sound scattering by large-scale objects like synoptic eddies using these analytical tools is also proposed.

Summary updated

Abstract

This study presents the description of the parameterization of sound speed distribution in the Sea of Japan in the presence of a synoptic eddy. An analytical representation of the background sound speed profile (SSP) on its periphery is proposed. The perturbation of sound speed directly associated with the presence of an eddy is investigated. The proposed parameterization of the background SSP leads to a Sturm–Liouville problem for normal mode computation, which is equivalent to the eigenvalue problem for the Schrödinger equation with the Morse potential. This equivalence leads to simple analytical formulae for normal modes and their respective horizontal wavenumbers. It is shown that in the presence of an eddy causing moderate variations in sound speed, the standard perturbation theory for acoustic modes can be applied to describe the variability in horizontal wavenumbers across the area in which the eddy is localized. The proposed parameterization can be applied to the sound propagation modeling in the Sea of Japan.
BibTeX
@article{sorokin2024parameterization,
  author = {M. A. Sorokin and A. I. Gudimenko and В. А. Лучин and Andrey G. Tyshchenko and Pavel S. Petrov},
  title = {{The Parameterization of the Sound Speed Profile in the Sea of Japan and Its Perturbation Caused by a Synoptic Eddy}},
  journal = {Journal of Marine Science and Engineering},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/jmse12122207},
}

Loading related content...

Figure