The PA-X host shutoff site 100 V exerts a contrary effect on viral fitness of the highly pathogenic H7N9 influenza A virus in mice and chickens

Xia Chen, Ming Kong, Chunxi Ma, Manyu Zhang, Zenglei Hu, Min Gu, Xiaoquan Wang, Ruyi Gao, Shunlin Hu, Yu Chen, Xiaowen Liu, Daxin Peng, Xiufan Liu, Jiao HuVirulence 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study identifies a specific amino acid (V at position 100) in the influenza A virus PA-X protein that plays a crucial, yet opposing, role in viral fitness. While this mutation enhances viral replication and virulence in mice, it significantly reduces them in chickens, offering new insights into the complex pathogenesis of influenza.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Influenza A viruses (IAVs) are notorious for their ability to hijack host cell machinery to promote their own replication and suppress antiviral responses. A key mechanism for this is "host shutoff," where viruses degrade host messenger RNAs (mRNAs) to gain preferential access to translation machinery and dampen host defenses. The influenza A virus protein PA-X is a known player in this process, selectively degrading host mRNAs. However, the precise functional role of specific sites within PA-X in influencing viral fitness across different hosts remained poorly understood. This paper aims to pinpoint critical residues within PA-X that contribute to host shutoff and investigate their impact on the viral fitness and pathogenicity of the highly pathogenic H7N9 influenza A virus in both mammalian (mice) and avian (chickens) hosts.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Bioinformatics Analysis: They analyzed a large dataset of PA-X gene sequences from various influenza A virus subtypes to identify polymorphic sites, particularly focusing on position 100.
  • Site-Directed Mutagenesis and Viral Reconstitution: They generated mutant H7N9 influenza viruses with specific alterations at the PA-X 100 position (e.g., introducing a V at position 100, or creating PA-X deficient viruses).
  • In Vitro Assays:
    • Host Shutoff Assays: Using 293T cells, they measured the impact of PA-X mutations on the expression of reporter genes (GFP and Renilla luciferase) to quantify host shutoff activity.
  • Viral Replication Assays: They assessed viral growth kinetics in various cell lines (MDCK, A549, 293T, DF-1, CEF) infected with wild-type and mutant viruses.
  • Viral Polymerase Activity Assays: They used luciferase reporter assays to measure the activity of the viral RNA polymerase complex in the presence of different PA-X variants.
  • RNA-Seq Analysis: They performed high-throughput RNA sequencing on infected cells to globally analyze changes in host gene expression, identifying differentially expressed genes (DEGs) and their associated biological pathways.
  • In Vivo Studies:
    • Mouse Infection Models: Mice were infected with different viral strains to assess viral virulence, weight loss, mortality, and viral dissemination to various organs.
  • Chicken Infection Models: Chickens were infected to evaluate viral virulence, mortality, and viral replication in different tissues.
  • Histopathological Analysis: Lung tissues from infected mice and chickens were examined to assess the severity of tissue damage.
  • Cytokine/Chemokine Analysis: Levels of immune response mediators were measured in infected tissues.
  • Structural Modeling: They used SWISS-MODEL to predict the structural impact of the PA-X 100 V mutation on the PA-X protein and its interaction within the viral polymerase complex.

Datasets

  • GISAID Database: Used for analyzing PA-X gene sequences from avian and human H5N1, H5N6, H5N8, H9N2, and H7N9 influenza viruses (sequences up to June 2024).
  • Publicly Available PDB Structures: Used as templates for structural modeling (e.g., PDB accession 2W69.2.A and 6evj.2).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • PA-X 100 V is a Key Determinant of Viral Fitness: The study pinpoints the amino acid at position 100 in PA-X as a critical site influencing viral behavior, with a specific V at this position having significant effects.
  • Host-Specific Effects: The most striking finding is the diametrically opposed impact of PA-X 100 V on viral fitness in mice versus chickens. This highlights the complex interplay between viral factors and host-specific cellular environments.
  • Mechanism in Mammals: In mice, PA-X 100 V enhances viral replication by boosting polymerase activity and significantly dampening host responses, particularly those related to energy metabolism and inflammation. This suggests a strategy to create a more favorable cellular environment for viral replication.
  • Mechanism in Avian Hosts: In chickens, PA-X 100 V appears to restrain viral fitness, contrasting with its effect in mammals. This suggests that the host shutoff activity of PA-X might be less effective or even detrimental in avian cells, or that other viral factors compensate differently.
  • Structural Context: The V at position 100 is located near the endonuclease active site of PA-X, suggesting a direct role in its enzymatic function and subsequent host shutoff activity. It also appears to interact with other polymerase subunits, hinting at a broader regulatory role.

Key Results

  • PA-X 100 V is Highly Variable in H7N9: While conserved in some subtypes, the residue at position 100 is notably variable in H7N9 viruses.
  • Enhanced Viral Fitness in Mice: The PA-X 100 V mutant virus (GD15-A100V) showed significantly increased viral replication in vitro and markedly enhanced virulence in mice, leading to greater weight loss, increased mortality, and wider dissemination.
  • Diminished Viral Fitness in Chickens: Conversely, the GD15-A100V mutant virus exhibited attenuated virulence and reduced replication in chickens.
  • Global Host Gene Regulation: In mammalian cells (293T), PA-X 100 V strongly suppressed genes involved in energy metabolism and inflammatory responses. This effect was less pronounced or different in avian cells (DF-1).
  • Increased Polymerase Activity: The PA-X 100 V mutation significantly enhanced viral polymerase activity in 293T cells.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Mechanism of Host-Specific Effects: While the study demonstrates the opposing effects of PA-X 100 V in mice and chickens, the precise molecular mechanisms underlying this discrepancy remain to be fully elucidated. Future work should focus on disentangling how host cellular machinery differs between these species to elicit such distinct responses.
  • Interaction with Other Viral Proteins: The study acknowledges that other viral proteins (like NS1 and PB1-F2) might synergize with PA-X to fine-tune host responses. Further investigation into these interactions is warranted.
  • Role of PA-X in Viral Gene Expression: The authors suggest future studies to determine if PA-X A100 V-mediated host shutoff influences the efficiency of viral gene expression, particularly for NS1 and PB1-F2.
  • Endonuclease Activity and Host Shutoff: While the V at position 100 is near the active site, further experiments are needed to directly confirm its role in endonuclease activity and how this relates to its specific targeting of host mRNAs.
  • Long-Term Lung Injury in Chickens: The study noted lung injury in chickens infected with PA-X deficient viruses, but no deaths. Further studies are needed to monitor this at later time points and understand the mechanisms behind potential recovery.

Summary updated

Abstract

Several viruses, including influenza A virus (IAV), encode viral factors to hijack cellular RNA biogenesis processes to direct the degradation of host mRNAs, termed "host shutoff." Host shutoff enables viruses to simultaneously reduce antiviral responses and provides preferential access for viral mRNAs to cellular translation machinery. IAV PA-X is one of these factors that selectively shuts off the global host genes. However, the specific role of PA-X host shutoff activity in viral fitness of IAV remains poorly understood. Herein, we successfully mapped PA-X 100 V as a novel site important for host shutoff of the H7N9 and H5N1 viruses. By analysing the polymorphism of this residue in various subtype viruses, we found that PA-X 100 was highly variable in H7N9 viruses. Structural analysis revealed that 100 V was generally close to the PA-X endonuclease active site, which may account for its host shutoff activity. By generating the corresponding mutant viruses derived from the parental H7N9 virus and the PA-X-deficient H7N9 virus, we determined that PA-X 100 V significantly enhanced viral fitness in mice while diminishing viral virulence in chickens. Mechanistically, PA-X 100 V significantly increased viral polymerase activity and viral replication in mammalian cells. Furthermore, PA-X 100 V highly blunted the global host response in 293T cells, particularly restraining genes involved in energy metabolism and inflammatory response. Collectively, our data provided information about the intricate role of the PA-X host shutoff site in regulating the viral fitness of the H7N9 influenza virus, which furthers our understanding of the complicated pathogenesis of the influenza A virus.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chen2024pa,
  author = {Xia Chen and Ming Kong and Chunxi Ma and Manyu Zhang and Zenglei Hu and Min Gu and Xiaoquan Wang and Ruyi Gao and Shunlin Hu and Yu Chen and Xiaowen Liu and Daxin Peng and Xiufan Liu and Jiao Hu},
  title = {{The PA-X host shutoff site 100 V exerts a contrary effect on viral fitness of the highly pathogenic H7N9 influenza A virus in mice and chickens}},
  booktitle = {Virulence},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1080/21505594.2024.2445238},
}
Figure