The overlooked local air warming mitigation of potential tree restoration

Zhao-Liang Li, Yitao Li, Hua Wu, Xiangyang Liu, Xu Lian, Menglin Si, Jing Li, Chenghu Zhou, Ronglin Tang, Si‐Bo Duan, Wei Zhao, Pei Leng, Xiaoning Song, Qian Shi, Enyu Zhao, Caixia GaoResearch Square 2024 · DOI

This study, recently published in Nature Communications, provides a much-needed reality check on how we measure the cooling benefits of planting trees. While we often focus on forests as "carbon sinks," they also physically change the local climate. By shifting the focus from land surface temperature ($T_s$) to the air temperature ($T_a$) we actually breathe, the researchers found that while previous studies overestimated cooling, the "biophysical" bonus of tree restoration is still massive—equivalent to 50% of the carbon-sequestration benefit in many regions.

TL;DR

Tree restoration doesn't just fight global warming by sucking up $CO_2$; it physically cools the local air. This study reveals that while this physical cooling is only 15–30% as strong as previously thought, it still provides a climate benefit equal to half of the carbon-sequestration effect, especially in mitigating daytime heat extremes.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

When we talk about the climate benefits of forests, we usually focus on the biochemical effect: trees absorbing $CO_2$. However, forests also have a biophysical effect: they change the land's "roughness" and "reflectivity" (albedo), which can either cool or warm the local area.

The challenge is that most previous research relied on satellite-derived Land Surface Temperature ($T_s$). While $T_s$ is easy to measure from space, it isn't what humans or animals experience. Policy-relevant metrics rely on Air Temperature ($T_a$). Because the ground and the air don't heat up or cool down at the same rate, using $T_s$ as a proxy for climate policy is like trying to guess the temperature of a room by touching the radiator. This paper closes that gap by providing the first global, observation-based constraint on how $T_a$ responds to tree restoration.

Methods

The authors employed a multi-scale observational approach:

  • Space-for-Time Method: They used a spatial moving window (0.25° scale) to compare adjacent pixels with different tree cover, simulating what would happen if tree cover increased from 0% to 100% in a specific location.
  • Machine Learning: To create a wall-to-wall global map, they used Gradient Boosting Decision Trees (GBDT) to gap-fill sensitivity data using climate, soil, and topographic variables.
  • Vertical Profile Analysis: They used in-situ data from FLUXNET towers to analyze the temperature gradient from the ground to 2 meters high. This allowed them to decompose the temperature response into contributions from sensible heat flux ($H$) and aerodynamic resistance ($r_a$).
  • Biochemical Comparison: They compared these physical effects against the carbon-sequestration potential using a "Transient Climate Response to cumulative emissions" (TCRE) framework.

Datasets

The study integrated a massive array of data:

  • Tree Cover: GLOBMAP (250m resolution) and Global Forest Change (GFC, 30m resolution).
  • Temperature: A spatiotemporal seamless $T_a$ dataset derived from 100,000 weather stations and MODIS satellite $T_s$ data.
  • Validation: The FLUXNET 2015 Tier 1 dataset (in-situ flux towers).
  • Ancillary Data: CRU (climate variables), ERA5-land (solar radiation), SoilGrids (soil properties), and GMTED2010 (topography).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Discrepancy: The air temperature ($T_a$) response to tree cover is significantly lower—only about 22% of the $T_s$ response globally. This means previous studies using surface temperature likely overestimated the local cooling benefits of forests by a factor of four or five.
  • The "Roughness" Secret: Why the difference? Forests are "aerodynamically rougher" than open land. This roughness creates turbulence that mixes air more efficiently, leading to a "flatter" temperature profile. In simple terms, forests are better at venting heat from the ground into the atmosphere (or vice versa in winter), which dampens the temperature change at the 2-meter height where we live.
  • The Daytime Hero: While the average cooling is modest, the effect on daytime maximum temperatures is profound. In hotspots like India and China, the physical cooling from trees can actually outperform the cooling provided by carbon sequestration during the hottest parts of the day.
  • The Latitudinal Flip: The study confirms that above 50°N (boreal regions), the biophysical effect actually causes warming because dark trees absorb more sunlight than snow-covered open ground, partially offsetting their carbon benefits.

Key Results

  • Global Sensitivity: $T_a$ sensitivity to a 100% increase in tree cover is -0.14 K, compared to -0.65 K for $T_s$.
  • Regional Boosts: Biophysical cooling enhances the biochemical (carbon) cooling by 57% in India, 48% in China, and 32% in Brazil.
  • Extreme Heat Mitigation: For daytime maximum temperatures, the biophysical impact can reach 109% of the biochemical effect in India, making forestation a primary tool for fighting heatwaves.
  • Carbon Equivalent: Under a full restoration scenario, the biophysical cooling is equivalent to about 50% of the cooling provided by the 95 Pg of carbon the new trees would sequester.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Local vs. Global: The study focuses on local effects. It does not account for "teleconnections"—how a massive new forest in one country might change rainfall or wind patterns in another.
  • Static Climate: The models are based on current climate conditions. As the world warms and snow cover decreases, the "warming" effect of northern forests might change.
  • Physiological Feedbacks: The study doesn't fully account for how rising $CO_2$ levels might change tree physiology (like stomatal closure), which could alter how trees transpire and cool the air in the future.

The authors suggest that future climate policies should prioritize tree restoration in mid-to-low latitudes, where the "double whammy" of carbon storage and physical air cooling provides the highest return on investment.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> Forestation, as a key component of Nature-based solutions, has the potential to cool or warm local climate through biophysical feedbacks, thereby enhancing or offsetting the global warming mitigation from carbon assimilation. Currently, the magnitude of such biophysical feedback on local climate remains unconstrained, as most previous observational studies rely on land surface temperature (<italic>T</italic><sub><italic>s</italic></sub>), rather than the policy-relevant air temperature (<italic>T</italic><sub><italic>a</italic></sub>). Based on multi-scale observational evidence, we show that <italic>T</italic><sub><italic>a</italic></sub> response to tree cover change is significantly lower, ranging from 15% to 30%, compared to <italic>T</italic><sub><italic>s</italic></sub> response, suggesting the overestimation of forestation’s local climate effect in previous <italic>T</italic><sub><italic>s</italic></sub>-based studies. In-situ observations further show that this discrepancy is attributed to the reduced aerodynamic resistance and the resultant flatter near-surface temperature profiles in forested areas. Despite the reduced <italic>T</italic><sub><italic>a</italic></sub> sensitivity, we find potential tree restoration in hotspot countries could still offer substantial climate benefits, which are equivalent to about 50% of the carbon sequestration-related cooling effects (biochemical effect) under the fully restored scenario. The biophysical cooling can be comparable to the biochemical effect in terms of daytime maximum temperature. Our <italic>T</italic><sub><italic>a</italic></sub>-based assessment underscores the strong potential of local climate mitigation from tree restoration practices, an aspect often overlooked in current forest-related pledges and policies against global warming.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2024overlooked,
  author = {Zhao-Liang Li and Yitao Li and Hua Wu and Xiangyang Liu and Xu Lian and Menglin Si and Jing Li and Chenghu Zhou and Ronglin Tang and Si‐Bo Duan and Wei Zhao and Pei Leng and Xiaoning Song and Qian Shi and Enyu Zhao and Caixia Gao},
  title = {{The overlooked local air warming mitigation of potential tree restoration}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-3957867/v1},
}

Loading related content...

Figure