The Outlook of Green Building Development in China during the “Fourteenth Five-Year Plan” Period

Suyang Xue, Jiaming Na, Libin Wang, Shuangjun Wang, Xiaoxiao XuInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper analyzes China's "14th Five-Year Plan" (2021-2025) for green building development, revealing significant spatial imbalances in regional goals and priorities. By examining 26 regional planning documents, the study highlights common challenges and pathways, offering insights for governments to better align local development with national objectives and ensure stable green building growth.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

China, as a major contributor to global carbon emissions, has set ambitious "Double Carbon" targets (peak emissions by 2030, carbon neutrality by 2060). Buildings are a significant source of energy consumption and carbon emissions, making green building (GB) development a crucial strategy. However, the vastness and diverse geographical and climatic conditions of China lead to potential disparities in how GB development is approached across different regions. This paper addresses the need to understand these regional differences in GB development goals and priorities during the current "14th Five-Year Plan" period, identifying common challenges and suggesting pathways for more effective implementation.

Methods

The study employs a qualitative research approach, focusing on the analysis of language and meaning within policy documents rather than quantitative data. The research process involved three key steps:

  1. Literature Review: A comprehensive review of existing academic literature on green building and related policies in China.
  2. Review of Plan Documents: A detailed examination of 26 regional green building development planning documents issued for the "14th Five-Year Plan" period. These documents were collected from official government websites.
  3. Spatial Analysis: An analysis of the extracted goals and indicators to identify commonalities, regional specificities, and spatial distribution patterns of GB development targets across China.

Datasets

The primary "dataset" for this study consists of 26 regional green building development planning documents from various provinces, municipalities, and autonomous regions in China, covering the "14th Five-Year Plan" period (2021-2025). These documents were collected from official government websites.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Spatial Imbalances are Real: The study confirms that significant spatial imbalances exist in green building development targets and priorities across China. This suggests that regions with better existing GB development are likely to set more ambitious goals, while those lagging may have less room for advancement.
  • "100% Green Building" is a Common Goal, but Implementation Varies: Many regions aim for 100% adoption of green building standards or a 100% proportion of new urban-rural green buildings. This reflects a strong national push, but the feasibility and specific approaches to achieve this vary significantly due to economic and geographical factors.
  • Eastern China Leads in Certain Areas: Regions in eastern China, with their more advanced economic development, tend to set higher targets for renewable energy applications and energy efficiency retrofitting of existing buildings.
  • GB Materials Still Lagging: The application rate of green building materials in China remains relatively low compared to developed countries, indicating a need for increased investment in R&D and adoption.
  • Policy and Awareness are Key Drivers (and Barriers): The study identifies improving laws and regulations, strengthening organizational management, and enhancing public awareness as crucial development paths. Conversely, insufficient awareness, imperfect market mechanisms, and a weak foundation for the GB materials industry are significant barriers.

Key Results

  • 26 Regions Analyzed: The study analyzed planning documents from 26 regions, with 17 having official "14th Five-Year Plan" documents for GB development and 9 integrating GB targets into broader housing or construction plans.
  • Common Indicators: A recurring theme across regions is the target for "Proportion of new urban-rural GBs" or "Proportion of new buildings in urban-rural areas that implement GB standards," with many aiming for 100%.
  • Regional Variations in Specific Targets:
    • Renewable Energy: Shandong, Anhui, and Hubei show higher targets for renewable energy applications, likely due to their economic development.
  • Energy Efficiency Retrofitting: Regions in the eastern coastal area show higher targets for retrofitting existing buildings.
  • Ultra-Low Energy Buildings: Chongqing and Hainan, due to challenging climatic and geological conditions, do not have specific targets for ultra-low energy buildings.
  • GB Materials: Targets for the proportion of GB materials in new buildings are relatively uniform across the analyzed regions, suggesting a general need for improvement.
  • Identified Barriers: Key barriers include low-quality GB development, slow progress in prefabricated buildings, insufficient public awareness, imperfect market mechanisms, and a weak GB materials industry.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Incomplete Coverage: Not all provinces and autonomous regions have issued specific GB planning documents for the "14th Five-Year Plan," which may lead to some deviations in the results.
  • Future Research Directions:
    • Cyclical Studies: Future research should be conducted periodically, coinciding with national Five-Year Plans, to track the evolution of national GB development.
  • Validation of Rationality: Future studies could validate the rationality of regional goals by assessing their alignment with local conditions.
  • Broader Analysis: Expanding the analysis to cover all regions and incorporating quantitative data for validation would strengthen future research.
  • Focus on Implementation: While this study focuses on planning documents, future work could investigate the actual implementation and effectiveness of these plans.

Summary updated

Abstract

To achieve the "Double Carbon" target, China is paying increasing attention to green building development. Thus, this study selected 26 regional green building development planning documents that have been put into practice since the implementation of the 14th Five-Year Plan and analyzed different development goals and common development barriers and paths presented in regional documents by conducting qualitative research. After the analysis of common goals and goals with regional characteristics, this study verified that spatial imbalances did exist in the development targets of green building in each region during the "14th Five-Year Plan", and the development priorities also varied from region to region. Due to the relation between development goals and the current situation, this study can also illustrate the spatial imbalances of the development situation between different regions. The results of this study can assist regional governments in gaining a clear self-positioning to judge whether they keep pace with the national development level of green buildings and encourage them to take measures to guarantee the stable development of green buildings.
BibTeX
@article{xue2023outlook,
  author = {Suyang Xue and Jiaming Na and Libin Wang and Shuangjun Wang and Xiaoxiao Xu},
  title = {{The Outlook of Green Building Development in China during the “Fourteenth Five-Year Plan” Period}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph20065122},
}
Figure