The observational uncertainty of coronal hole boundaries in automated detection schemes

Martin Reiß, K. Muglach, Christian Möstl, C. N. Arge, Rachel Bailey, Véronique Delouille, Tadhg M. Garton, Amr Hamada, Stefan J. Hofmeister, Egor Illarionov, Robert Jarolim, Michael S. Kirk, А. Г. Косовичев, Larisza D. Krista, Sang‐Woo Lee, Chris Lowder, P. J. MacNeice, Astrid Veronig, Cospar Iswat Coronal Hole Boundary Working TeamUniversity 2021

TL;DR

This paper highlights a significant, often overlooked, source of uncertainty in solar physics research: the variability in how different automated algorithms define the boundaries of coronal holes. By comparing nine common detection schemes, the study reveals that the choice of algorithm can lead to substantial differences in the inferred physical properties of these crucial solar features, impacting our understanding of the solar wind.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Coronal holes are regions on the Sun where magnetic field lines extend outwards into space, acting as the source of the solar wind. Understanding their properties is vital for predicting space weather. While space missions like the Solar Dynamics Observatory (SDO) provide unprecedented data, automatically identifying and delineating these coronal holes from images is challenging due to instrumental effects, varying solar conditions, and the inherent nature of the plasma. Numerous automated detection schemes exist, each with its own approach. However, a critical gap in research has been the lack of a systematic comparison of these schemes to quantify the discrepancies in their results, particularly concerning the precise location of coronal hole boundaries. This variability can lead to inconsistent interpretations of coronal hole characteristics and their influence on the solar wind.

Methods

The researchers compared nine widely-used automated coronal hole detection schemes. They selected a specific, well-defined coronal hole observed on May 30, 2018, as a case study. To ensure a fair comparison, all schemes were provided with the same pre-processed SDO data, including full-disk images from the Atmospheric Imaging Assembly (AIA) in multiple EUV wavebands (primarily 19.3 nm, but also 17.1 nm and 21.1 nm for some schemes) and line-of-sight photospheric magnetic field measurements from the Helioseismic and Magnetic Imager (HMI). The schemes employ diverse strategies, ranging from simple intensity thresholding to more complex methods like iterative clustering, sub-frame analysis, and neural networks. After obtaining the boundary detections from each scheme, the authors analyzed the physical properties within these boundaries, including area, mean EUV intensity, magnetic field strength, degree of unipolarity, and open magnetic flux.

Datasets

The study utilized data from the Solar Dynamics Observatory (SDO) spacecraft, specifically:

  • Atmospheric Imaging Assembly (AIA): Full-disk images in multiple EUV wavebands (Fe IX 17.1 nm, Fe XII 19.3 nm, Fe XIV 21.1 nm).
  • Helioseismic and Magnetic Imager (HMI): Line-of-sight (LOS) photospheric magnetic field measurements.

The paper does not introduce a new benchmark dataset but rather uses a single, well-characterized coronal hole event for evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Algorithm Choice Matters Significantly: The most striking finding is that the choice of automated detection scheme has a profound impact on the identified coronal hole boundaries. This means that results from different studies using different algorithms might not be directly comparable.
  • Variability Extends Beyond Shape: The differences aren't just in the visual outline of the coronal hole; they translate directly into significant variations in key physical properties derived from within those boundaries.
  • Implications for Solar Wind Research: Since coronal holes are the source of the solar wind, inconsistencies in their detection can propagate into our understanding of solar wind acceleration, its properties, and its impact on Earth's space environment.
  • Need for Uncertainty Quantification: The study underscores the importance of acknowledging and quantifying the uncertainties associated with automated detection methods, potentially by providing error bounds alongside detected boundaries.

Key Results

  • Area Variation: Coronal hole areas derived by the nine schemes varied by a factor of up to 4.5.
  • Intensity Variation: Mean AIA 19.3 nm intensity varied by a factor of 2.1.
  • Magnetic Field Variation: Signed average magnetic field strength varied by a factor of 2.1, while unsigned average magnetic field strength showed less variation (factor of 1.1).
  • Unipolarity and Flux Variation: The degree of unipolarity varied by a factor of 1.21, and the net open magnetic flux varied by a factor of 2.2.
  • Visual Discrepancies: Figure 2 clearly illustrates how the boundaries defined by different schemes can differ substantially, especially at the edges of the coronal hole.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Single Event Study: The current study focuses on a single coronal hole event. The authors acknowledge that this might not represent a general trend across all coronal holes.
  • Future Work: The authors plan to expand their study to a larger number of coronal holes to confirm these findings. They also intend to investigate the influence of specific factors on boundary detection, including:
  • The specific EUV wavelength used by the detection scheme.
  • The position of the coronal hole on the solar disk.
  • The phase of the solar cycle.
  • Data Availability: The SDO data and the derived coronal hole maps are made publicly available to facilitate future comparisons and research.

Summary updated

Abstract

Coronal holes are the observational manifestation of the solar magnetic field open to the heliosphere and are of pivotal importance for our understanding of the origin and acceleration of the solar wind. Observations from space missions such as the Solar Dynamics Observatory now allow us to study coronal holes in unprecedented detail. Instrumental effects and other factors, however, pose a challenge to automatically detect coronal holes in solar imagery. The science community addresses these challenges with different detection schemes. Until now, little attention has been paid to assessing the disagreement between these schemes. In this COSPAR ISWAT initiative, we present a comparison of nine automated detection schemes widely applied in solar and space science. We study, specifically, a prevailing coronal hole observed by the Atmospheric Imaging Assembly instrument on 2018 May 30. Our results indicate that the choice of detection scheme has a significant effect on the location of the coronal hole boundary. Physical properties in coronal holes such as the area, mean intensity, and mean magnetic field strength vary by a factor of up to 4.5 between the maximum and minimum values. We conclude that our findings are relevant for coronal hole research from the past decade, and are therefore of interest to the solar and space research community.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{rei2021observational,
  author = {Martin Reiß and K. Muglach and Christian Möstl and C. N. Arge and Rachel Bailey and Véronique Delouille and Tadhg M. Garton and Amr Hamada and Stefan J. Hofmeister and Egor Illarionov and Robert Jarolim and Michael S. Kirk and А. Г. Косовичев and Larisza D. Krista and Sang‐Woo Lee and Chris Lowder and P. J. MacNeice and Astrid Veronig and COSPAR ISWAT Coronal Hole Boundary Working Team},
  title = {{The observational uncertainty of coronal hole boundaries in automated detection schemes}},
  booktitle = {University},
  year = {2021},
}
Figure