The Number of Spanning Trees in Regular Graphs

Noga AlonRandom Struct. Algorithms 1990 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the number of spanning trees in k-regular graphs, a fundamental quantity in graph theory with connections to number theory. The authors prove that for large k, this number is tightly bounded by $k^n$, specifically $k^n(1 - o(1))^n$, showing that the number of spanning trees in a k-regular graph is largely independent of its specific structure and primarily depends on its degree k and number of vertices n.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper tackles a question posed by P. Sarnak: what is the minimum number of spanning trees a k-regular connected simple graph on $n$ vertices can have? This question arises from number theory, where the class numbers of certain function fields can be expressed in terms of spanning tree counts of related regular graphs. While it's known that for a fixed $k \ge 3$, the number of spanning trees in a k-regular connected graph on $n$ vertices, denoted $C(G)$, grows exponentially with $n$ (specifically, $C(G) \approx k^n$), the precise dependence on the graph's structure remained an open problem. The authors aim to quantify this dependence, showing that for large $k$, the number of spanning trees is remarkably close to the theoretical maximum of $k^n$.

Methods

The paper employs a combination of probabilistic methods and algebraic graph theory.

  • Probabilistic Approach: A key technique involves randomly orienting the edges of the graph. By analyzing the expected number of connected components of certain sizes in this random orientation, the authors establish bounds on the number of spanning trees. This method allows them to show that for large $k$, the number of spanning trees is close to $k^n$.
  • Kirchhoff's Matrix Tree Theorem: This fundamental theorem, which relates the number of spanning trees to the eigenvalues of the graph's Laplacian matrix, is used to derive bounds and to understand the structure of the problem.
  • Constructive Examples: The paper utilizes specific graph constructions (like those derived from Hadamard matrices or complete graphs) to establish lower bounds and to demonstrate that certain asymptotic behaviors are achievable.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical results for general classes of graphs rather than empirical evaluation on specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Near-Independence of Structure: The most striking insight is that for large $k$, the number of spanning trees in a k-regular connected graph is almost entirely determined by $k$ and $n$, and not by the intricate details of the graph's connectivity or structure. This is a powerful statement about the robustness of spanning tree counts in this regime.
  • Tight Asymptotic Bound: The paper establishes a tight asymptotic bound for the "complexity exponent" $c(k) = \lim_{n \to \infty} \inf_{G} (C(G))^{1/n}$, showing $c(k) = k - O(k(\log \log k)^2 / \log k)$. This refines previous bounds and provides a precise understanding of how the number of spanning trees scales with $n$.
  • Lower Bound for $c(k)$: The paper proves that $c(k) \ge \sqrt{2}$ for $k \ge 3$, and for infinitely many $k$, $c(k) \le k - \Omega(\sqrt{k})$. This highlights that while the number of spanning trees is close to $k^n$, there's still a non-trivial deviation that depends on $k$.
  • Connection to Number Theory: The motivation from number theory underscores the broader significance of this problem, suggesting that understanding spanning tree counts in regular graphs can shed light on deep questions in other mathematical fields.

Key Results

  • For any connected k-regular simple graph $G$ on $n$ vertices, the number of spanning trees $C(G)$ satisfies $C(G) = k^n [1 - \sigma(G)]^n$, where $\sigma(G) \to 0$ as $k \to \infty$.
  • The complexity exponent $c(k) = \lim_{n \to \infty} \inf_{G} (C(G))^{1/n}$ is shown to be $c(k) = k - O(k(\log \log k)^2 / \log k)$.
  • For $k \ge 3$, $c(k) \ge \sqrt{2}$.
  • For infinitely many values of $k$, $c(k) \le k - \Omega(\sqrt{k})$.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Precise Determination of $c(k)$: The paper acknowledges that precisely determining $c(k)$ for each $k \ge 3$ is an open and likely difficult problem.
  • Nonsimple Graphs: The paper briefly touches upon the complexity of nonsimple k-regular connected graphs (allowing loops or parallel edges) and suggests that $c'(k) = \Omega(\sqrt{k})$, but leaves the detailed analysis for future work.
  • Linear Forests: The paper mentions the concept of linear forests and their relation to spanning 2-factors, indicating potential avenues for further research.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{alon1990number,
  author = {Noga Alon},
  title = {{The Number of Spanning Trees in Regular Graphs}},
  journal = {Random Struct. Algorithms},
  year = {1990},
  doi = {10.1002/rsa.3240010204},
}
Figure