The Novel Coronavirus, 2019-nCoV, is Highly Contagious and More Infectious Than Initially Estimated

Steven Sanche, Yen Ting Lin, Chonggang Xu, Ethan Romero-Severson, Nicolas Hengartner, Ruian KearXiv 2020 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

The novel coronavirus (2019-nCoV) is a recently emerged human pathogen that has spread widely since January 2020. Initially, the basic reproductive number, $R_0$, was estimated to be 2.2 to 2.7. Here we provide a new estimate of this quantity. We collected extensive individual case reports and estimated key epidemiology parameters, including the incubation period. Integrating these estimates and high-resolution real-time human travel and infection data with mathematical models, we estimated that the number of infected individuals during early epidemic double every 2.4 days, and the $R_0$ value is likely to be between 4.7 and 6.6. We further show that quarantine and contact tracing of symptomatic individuals alone may not be effective and early, strong control measures are needed to stop transmission of the virus.

Introduction

In the early weeks of the 2019-nCoV outbreak, the global health community relied on preliminary estimates of the virus's transmission potential to guide containment strategies. Initial reports suggested a basic reproductive number ($R_0$) between 2.2 and 2.7, implying a doubling time of approximately 6 to 7 days. However, as the virus spread rapidly across China and internationally in late January 2020, these figures appeared increasingly inconsistent with the observed speed of the epidemic.

This study addresses the likely underestimation of the virus's infectiousness by re-evaluating early transmission dynamics. By integrating high-resolution travel data with case reports from regions outside the initial epicenter of Wuhan, the researchers provide a more robust estimate of the $R_0$ and the exponential growth rate of the virus during its initial expansion.

Methodological Approach

The primary challenge in estimating the growth of the outbreak in Wuhan was the potential for significant underreporting due to the local healthcare system being overwhelmed. To circumvent this "noise," the researchers utilized two distinct mathematical models focused on data from provinces outside Hubei, where surveillance was more intensive and case detection was considered more reliable.

1. The "First-Arrival" Model

This model utilized the arrival dates of the first confirmed cases in 26 different Chinese provinces. By combining these dates with real-time travel data from the Baidu Migration Server, the researchers could back-calculate the growth rate in Wuhan. The underlying logic is that as the infected population in the source city grows exponentially, the probability of an infected individual traveling to a new province increases in a predictable mathematical relationship.

2. The "Case Count" Model

The second approach employed a hybrid stochastic meta-population model based on the SEIR (Susceptible-Exposed-Infectious-Recovered) framework. This model was fitted to daily case counts reported in provinces outside Hubei. These provinces implemented rigorous digital tracking and testing for travelers from Wuhan early on, making their data a more accurate reflection of the epidemic's true trajectory than the data coming from the epicenter itself.

Data Integration

The study relied on three primary datasets to inform the models:

  • Baidu Migration Server: This provided high-resolution, real-time domestic travel data, capturing over 120 billion positioning requests daily. This allowed for precise quantification of population movement out of Wuhan to other regions.
  • Individual Case Reports: A curated set of 140 individual cases provided critical clinical parameters, including dates of Wuhan departure, symptom onset, and hospitalization.
  • Official Health Commission Reports: Daily confirmed case counts from various provinces and municipalities provided the longitudinal data necessary for the Case Count model.

Key Findings

The analysis revealed that 2019-nCoV was spreading significantly faster than early estimates suggested, revealing a period of "invisible" growth.

  • Transmission Potential ($R_0$): The study estimated the $R_0$ to be between 4.7 and 6.6. This is more than double the initial estimates of 2.2–2.7, placing 2019-nCoV in a much more infectious category similar to other highly contagious respiratory pathogens.
  • Exponential Growth: The virus exhibited a growth rate of 0.29 per day, which translates to a doubling time of only 2.4 days.
  • Incubation Period: The mean incubation period was estimated at 4.2 days (95% CI: 3.5–5.1), notably shorter than the 5–6 days reported in earlier studies.
  • Impact of Control Measures: Following the January 23 lockdown and subsequent national measures, the growth rate decreased to 0.14 per day, representing a 50%–59% reduction in the effective reproductive number.

Public Health Implications

The revised $R_0$ has profound implications for containment. The study suggests that the rapid growth of the virus made early containment through standard methods extremely difficult.

A critical insight involves the role of asymptomatic transmission. The researchers found that if even 20% of transmission occurs via asymptomatic individuals, standard quarantine and contact tracing of symptomatic patients would be insufficient to halt the spread. This finding underscored the necessity of the aggressive, population-wide social distancing measures and lockdowns implemented to reduce the $R_0$ to manageable levels. Furthermore, the data showed a dramatic reduction in the time from symptom onset to hospitalization—dropping from 5.5 days to 1.5 days after January 18—reflecting a massive shift in public awareness and healthcare response.

Conclusion

By leveraging high-resolution travel data and focusing on secondary surveillance sites, this study demonstrated that 2019-nCoV was significantly more contagious than initially believed. The rapid doubling time of 2.4 days and an $R_0$ as high as 6.6 explained the explosive nature of the early pandemic and highlighted the critical need for early, decisive, and large-scale public health interventions to mitigate the spread of such a highly infectious pathogen.

Summary updated

Abstract

The novel coronavirus (2019-nCoV) is a recently emerged human pathogen that has spread widely since January 2020. Initially, the basic reproductive number, R0, was estimated to be 2.2 to 2.7. Here we provide a new estimate of this quantity. We collected extensive individual case reports and estimated key epidemiology parameters, including the incubation period. Integrating these estimates and high-resolution real-time human travel and infection data with mathematical models, we estimated that the number of infected individuals during early epidemic double every 2.4 days, and the R0 value is likely to be between 4.7 and 6.6. We further show that quarantine and contact tracing of symptomatic individuals alone may not be effective and early, strong control measures are needed to stop transmission of the virus.
BibTeX
@misc{sanche2020novel,
  author = {Steven Sanche and Yen Ting Lin and Chonggang Xu and Ethan Romero-Severson and Nicolas Hengartner and Ruian Ke},
  title = {{The Novel Coronavirus, 2019-nCoV, is Highly Contagious and More Infectious Than Initially Estimated}},
  year = {2020},
  eprint = {2002.03268},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2002.03268},
}
Figure