The nonlinear relationship between rural territorial functions and regional economic development—A case study of Yangtze River Delta, China

Xinming Zhang, Xinxin Wang, Huan LiSustainable 2025 · DOI

This study provides a data-driven look at how rural areas transform as a region becomes an economic powerhouse. Using China’s Yangtze River Delta (YRD) as a laboratory, the researchers demonstrate that the relationship between economic growth and rural health is not a simple upward climb, but a complex, nonlinear journey with distinct "turning points."

TL;DR

Economic growth initially boosts rural production, living standards, and ecology, but this "multifunctionality" peaks at a specific threshold (~13,000 yuan GDP per capita in 2000 constant prices). Beyond this point, the study finds that further growth can actually trigger imbalances, suggesting that rural revitalization requires stage-specific policies rather than a one-size-fits-all economic approach.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As regions undergo rapid urbanization, rural areas are forced to evolve. Traditionally, rural development was measured by agricultural output or poverty reduction. However, modern rural spaces serve a "triad" of functions: Production (agriculture and industry), Living (infrastructure and quality of life), and Ecological (environmental stewardship).

The authors argue that most existing research oversimplifies these dynamics by assuming linear relationships—essentially, that more money always equals better rural outcomes. This paper tackles the "nonlinear" reality: How do these three functions interact as a region moves from a traditional agrarian society to a high-tech metropolitan hub? Understanding these "threshold effects" is critical for planners trying to prevent rural "hollowing out" or environmental degradation in the wake of industrial success.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-stage analytical framework:

  • Production-Living-Ecological (PLE) Framework: They developed a tailored indicator system for the YRD, using 12 specific metrics (e.g., grain yield, per capita income, sewage treatment rates).
  • Entropy Weight Method (EWM): To avoid subjective bias, they used EWM to mathematically determine the importance of each function. Interestingly, the model assigned the highest weight to Ecological functions (0.40), followed by Living (0.35) and Production (0.25).
  • Environmental Kuznets Curve (EKC): This is the core of their nonlinear analysis. They modeled how each rural function changes relative to GDP per capita to find the "inflection points" where trends reverse.
  • Spatial Analysis: Using ArcGIS and the Jenks Natural Breaks method, they categorized 26 municipal units into "Leading," "Upgrading," and "Lagging" development zones.

Datasets

The study utilized a longitudinal dataset spanning two decades (2000–2020) from the following sources:

  • Yangtze River Delta Statistical Yearbook
  • China Urban Statistical Yearbook
  • Provincial Yearbooks (Zhejiang, Jiangsu, Anhui, and Shanghai)
  • Economic Normalization: All financial data were adjusted to constant 2000 prices to account for inflation and ensure longitudinal comparability.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "W-Shaped" Production Trajectory: Unlike living standards, rural production doesn't just go up. It follows a W-shape. It declines during the painful transition from traditional farming to a diversified economy, recovers as modern ag-tech and rural tourism take hold, and eventually stabilizes in high-value-added sectors.
  • The 13,000 Yuan "Sweet Spot": The comprehensive rural function index peaks at approximately 13,000 yuan per capita GDP. At this level, the balance between production, living, and ecology is at its most harmonious. Beyond this, competing demands (like industrial land use vs. ecological preservation) begin to create friction.
  • Ecological Fragility in Success: High-growth areas like Shanghai and Nanjing face "ecological strain." While they have the best infrastructure, the sheer pressure of urbanization leads to a decline in ecological function indices after the 12,000 yuan GDP threshold.
  • Multifunctionality as Maturity: The study reveals that "Leading" zones (like the southeastern coastal areas) have successfully transitioned to balanced multifunctionality, while "Lagging" zones remain stuck in a production-centric model with poor infrastructure.

Key Results

  • Turning Points:
    • Living functions plateau around 11,000 yuan GDP per capita.
  • Ecological functions begin to decline after 12,000 yuan.
  • Comprehensive functions peak at 13,000 yuan.
  • Regional Disparities: The YRD is highly stratified. Leading zones (Shanghai, Hangzhou) exhibit high coordination across all PLE functions. Lagging zones (Tongling, Xuancheng) struggle with infrastructure and have yet to reach the economic thresholds necessary for functional recovery.
  • Weighting: The study confirms that in modern metropolitan rural areas, ecological and living functions now exert a more significant influence on overall rural vitality than traditional production.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Indicator Constraints: The study focused heavily on economic drivers (GDP). The authors acknowledge that technological shifts (like "Smart Agriculture") and specific policy interventions (like the 2018 YRD Integration Strategy) were only implicitly reflected in the data and deserve direct quantitative study.
  • Static vs. Dynamic Modeling: The 2000–2020 dataset is historical. Future research could use this foundation for predictive modeling to forecast how rural functions will react to future economic shocks.
  • Qualitative Thresholds: While the study identifies economic ranges, the classification of zones (Leading vs. Lagging) remains somewhat qualitative. Establishing harder quantitative thresholds for these categories is a suggested next step.

Summary updated

Abstract

This study investigates the nonlinear relationship between rural territorial functions—encompassing production, living, and ecological dimensions—and economic development in China’s Yangtze River Delta (YRD) from 2000 to 2020, employing entropy weight and Kuznets curve analyses. Findings reveal pronounced regional disparities: economically advanced areas achieve balanced multifunctionality, whereas underdeveloped regions remain production-centric. Economic growth exhibits an inverted U-shaped relationship with rural functions, peaking at approximately 13,000 yuan per capita GDP, initially enhancing functions but leading to imbalances beyond this threshold. The production function follows a W-shaped trajectory, reflecting structural economic shifts, while living and ecological functions peak at intermediate development stages before stabilizing or declining. These insights underscore the necessity for tailored policies to harmonize rural functions, mitigate disparities, and balance economic growth with sustainability.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2025nonlinear,
  author = {Xinming Zhang and Xinxin Wang and Huan Li},
  title = {{The nonlinear relationship between rural territorial functions and regional economic development—A case study of Yangtze River Delta, China}},
  booktitle = {Sustainable},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.62617/se1513},
}
Figure