The Next Generation of Cosmological Measurements with Type Ia Supernovae

D. Scolnic, S. Perlmutter, G. Aldering, Dillon Brout, T. M. Davis, Alex Filippenko, R. J. Foley, Renée Hložek, Rebekah Hounsell, Saurabh W. Jha, D. O. Jones, Pat Kelly, Rick Kessler, Alex Kim, D. Rubin, Adam G. Riess, S. Rodney, J. Roberts-Pierel, C. W. Stubbs, Yun Wang, J. Asorey, Arturo Avelino, Chetan Bavdhankar, P. J. Brown, A. Challinor, Christophe Balland, Asantha Cooray, Suhail Dhawan, G. Dimitriadis, Cora Dvorkin, Julien Guy, Will Handley, Ryan E. Keeley, Jean‐Paul Kneib, Benjamin L’Huillier, M. Lattanzi, Kaisey S. Mandel, James B. Mertens, M. Rigault, Pavel Motloch, Suvodip Mukherjee, Gautham Narayan, A. Nomerotski, Lyman A. Page, Levon Pogosian, Giuseppe Puglisi, Marco Raveri, N. Regnault, A. Rest, C. Rojas-Bravo, M. Šako, Feng Shi, Srivatsan Sridhar, Aritoki Suzuki, Yu-Dai Tsai, W. M. Wood‐Vasey, Y. Copin, Gong‐Bo Zhao, Ningfeng ZhuarXiv 2019 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

While Type Ia Supernovae (SNe Ia) are one of the most mature cosmological probes, the next era promises to be extremely exciting in the number of different ways SNe Ia are used to measure various cosmological parameters. Here we review the experiments in the 2020s that will yield orders of magnitudes more SNe Ia, and the new understandings and capabilities to constrain systematic uncertainties at a level to match these statistics. We then discuss five different cosmological probes with SNe Ia: the conventional Hubble diagram for measuring dark energy properties, the distance ladder for measuring the Hubble constant, peculiar velocities and weak lensing for measuring sigma8 and strong-lens measurements of H0 and other cosmological parameters. For each of these probes, we discuss the experiments that will provide the best measurements and also the SN Ia-related systematics that affect each one.

Introduction

Type Ia Supernovae (SNe Ia) are evolving from simple "standard candles" into a multi-tool kit for precision cosmology. As we move into the 2020s, upcoming surveys like the Vera C. Rubin Observatory (LSST) and the Nancy Grace Roman Space Telescope (formerly WFIRST) will increase our SN Ia samples by orders of magnitude. This shift allows the scientific community to move beyond simply measuring the expansion of the universe to probing the growth of structure, dark matter distribution, and the nature of gravity itself.

The Future of SN Ia Cosmology at a Glance: This infographic summarizes the expected SN Ia yields across different redshift ranges and the various cosmological probes they will enable in the 2020s.

The Precision Bottleneck

For decades, SNe Ia have been the premier tool for measuring cosmic distances, leading to the Nobel-winning discovery of the universe's accelerating expansion. However, the field is currently facing a "precision bottleneck." Our ability to constrain cosmological parameters, such as the dark energy equation of state ($w$), is no longer limited by the quantity of supernovae we can find, but by our understanding of systematic uncertainties. These include telescope calibration, dust interference, and potential "population drift"—the physical evolution of SNe over cosmic time. Overcoming these systematics is the primary goal for the next decade of research.

Methodological Framework: From Candles to Tools

The transition to high-precision cosmology requires a shift from traditional imaging or spectroscopic approaches to a hybrid strategy. Key methodological advancements include:

  • Photometric Classification: With hundreds of thousands of SNe expected, manual spectroscopic confirmation is impossible. The field is developing sophisticated light-curve modeling to identify SNe Ia from imaging data alone.
  • Spectrophotometric "Twinning": To mitigate population drift, researchers propose using integral field spectroscopy to match distant SNe with nearby counterparts that possess identical spectral features.
  • Multi-Probe Integration: SNe Ia will be utilized across five distinct avenues:
  • Conventional Hubble Diagram: Measuring dark energy properties ($w$).
  • Local Distance Ladder: Calibrating the Hubble constant ($H_0$) to address the "Hubble Tension."
    1. Peculiar Velocities ($f\sigma_8$): Using low-redshift SNe to probe the growth of structure and gravity.
  • Weak Lensing: Measuring magnification by intervening dark matter at high redshifts.
  • Strong Lensing: Utilizing time delays in multi-imaged SNe for direct geometric $H_0$ measurements.

The Observational Landscape

The 2020s will see a transition from legacy samples (SDSS, SNLS, Pan-STARRS1, DES) to massive data facilities:

  • LSST (Rubin Observatory): Anticipated to provide a 300x increase in statistics at mid-redshift ($0.1 < z < 1$).
  • Nancy Grace Roman Space Telescope: Expected to provide a 1000x boost in high-redshift ($z > 1$) statistics.
  • JWST: Capable of extending the Hubble diagram to extreme redshifts ($z \approx 5$).
  • ZTF & ASAS-SN: Providing the high-cadence local samples ($z < 0.1$) necessary for distance ladder and peculiar velocity studies.

Theoretical Advancements and Expected Outcomes

We are moving toward "standardizable" candles. By understanding the correlation between a supernova’s environment and its intrinsic brightness, we can significantly reduce measurement scatter. Furthermore, gravitational lensing, once considered "noise," will be leveraged as a signal to measure the matter density of the universe ($\sigma_8$).

Future surveys aim to improve the "Figure of Merit" for time-varying dark energy ($w_0, w_a$) by a factor of approximately five. Additionally, a 1% measurement of $H_0$ via the distance ladder is targeted to determine if the discrepancy between local and early-universe measurements represents new physics.

Challenges and Future Directions

Despite the increase in data, several hurdles remain. The "spectroscopic bottleneck" persists; large-scale follow-up on 4m and 8m class telescopes is still required to train photometric classifiers and measure host-galaxy redshifts. Additionally, as imaging deepens, correctly associating a supernova with its host galaxy becomes more difficult. Finally, understanding the "reddening law" of dust and its evolution remains a primary source of systematic error, necessitating wide-wavelength coverage from the UV to the NIR.

Summary updated

Abstract

While Type Ia Supernovae (SNe Ia) are one of the most mature cosmological probes, the next era promises to be extremely exciting in the number of different ways SNe Ia are used to measure various cosmological parameters. Here we review the experiments in the 2020s that will yield orders of magnitudes more SNe Ia, and the new understandings and capabilities to constrain systematic uncertainties at a level to match these statistics. We then discuss five different cosmological probes with SNe Ia: the conventional Hubble diagram for measuring dark energy properties, the distance ladder for measuring the Hubble constant, peculiar velocities and weak lensing for measuring sigma8 and strong-lens measurements of H0 and other cosmological parameters. For each of these probes, we discuss the experiments that will provide the best measurements and also the SN Ia-related systematics that affect each one.
BibTeX
@misc{scolnic2019next,
  author = {D. Scolnic and S. Perlmutter and G. Aldering and Dillon Brout and T. M. Davis and Alex Filippenko and R. J. Foley and Renée Hložek and Rebekah Hounsell and Saurabh W. Jha and D. O. Jones and Pat Kelly and Rick Kessler and Alex Kim and D. Rubin and Adam G. Riess and S. Rodney and J. Roberts-Pierel and C. W. Stubbs and Yun Wang and J. Asorey and Arturo Avelino and Chetan Bavdhankar and P. J. Brown and A. Challinor and Christophe Balland and Asantha Cooray and Suhail Dhawan and G. Dimitriadis and Cora Dvorkin and Julien Guy and Will Handley and Ryan E. Keeley and Jean‐Paul Kneib and Benjamin L’Huillier and M. Lattanzi and Kaisey S. Mandel and James B. Mertens and M. Rigault and Pavel Motloch and Suvodip Mukherjee and Gautham Narayan and A. Nomerotski and Lyman A. Page and Levon Pogosian and Giuseppe Puglisi and Marco Raveri and N. Regnault and A. Rest and C. Rojas-Bravo and M. Šako and Feng Shi and Srivatsan Sridhar and Aritoki Suzuki and Yu-Dai Tsai and W. M. Wood‐Vasey and Y. Copin and Gong‐Bo Zhao and Ningfeng Zhu},
  title = {{The Next Generation of Cosmological Measurements with Type Ia Supernovae}},
  year = {2019},
  eprint = {1903.05128},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1903.05128},
}
Figure