The neural control of movement: a century of in vivo motor unit recordings is the legacy of Adrian and Bronk

Dario Farina, Simon C. GandeviaThe Journal of Physiology 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This review celebrates the foundational work of Adrian and Bronk in the late 1920s, who pioneered in vivo motor unit recordings in humans using a novel concentric needle electrode. Their seminal papers laid the groundwork for understanding how the nervous system controls movement by revealing key principles like motor unit recruitment and rate coding, principles that remain central to the field a century later.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper addresses the historical gap in understanding the neural control of human movement at the most fundamental level: the motor unit. Before Adrian and Bronk's work, studying how individual nerve signals translate into muscle force was largely confined to animal models and required invasive dissection techniques. The challenge was to find a way to record neural activity related to movement directly from humans during voluntary actions, providing insights into the "final common pathway" of motor control.

Methods

The core methodological innovation highlighted is the concentric needle electrode, first described by Adrian and Bronk in 1929. This electrode allowed for the recording of electrical activity from individual muscle fibers (or small groups of fibers) innervated by a single motor neuron. This technique bypassed the need for nerve dissection, enabling in vivo recordings in humans during voluntary contractions. The paper also discusses earlier, more invasive methods involving nerve dissection in anesthetized animals, which provided initial insights into nerve impulse patterns.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Motor Unit" as a Fundamental Unit of Control: Adrian and Bronk's work solidified the concept of the motor unit (a single motor neuron and the muscle fibers it innervates) as the basic building block of voluntary movement.
  • Muscle Fiber Recordings as a Proxy for Nerve Activity: They astutely recognized that recording from muscle fibers could accurately reflect the firing rate of the innervating motor neuron, a crucial insight that enabled human studies.
  • Recruitment and Rate Coding: Their papers anticipated and described two primary mechanisms for force modulation:
  • Recruitment: Activating more motor units as force demands increase.
  • Rate Coding: Increasing the firing frequency of already active motor units.
  • The Power of the Concentric Needle Electrode: This invention democratized motor unit research, making it accessible in human subjects and paving the way for a century of advancements in understanding motor control, neurorehabilitation, and clinical diagnostics.
  • Early Glimpses of Motor Unit Properties: Even with rudimentary technology, they observed phenomena like the dependence of discharge rate on recruitment threshold and the asynchronous nature of motor unit firing.

Key Results

  • Demonstrated in vivo motor unit recordings in humans: This was a paradigm shift, moving from animal studies to direct human observation.
  • Described the concentric needle electrode: This invention remains the basis for many modern EMG electrodes.
  • Identified recruitment and rate coding as key mechanisms for force control: These principles were observed in both autonomous (respiration) and voluntary contractions.
  • Observed a range of motor unit firing rates: From as low as 6 pulses per second for low forces to higher rates for increased force.
  • Anticipated future research directions: Their work foreshadowed concepts like motor unit size principle and the correlation of motor unit activity, though the precise mechanisms were elucidated later.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations of early techniques: The early methods required nerve dissection in animals and were limited in their ability to isolate single motor unit activity in humans without sophisticated signal processing. The paper notes that Adrian and Bronk themselves acknowledged they couldn't precisely determine the extent of a muscle unit they were recording from.
  • Speculative aspects: Their initial ideas on synchronisation of motor unit discharges, while insightful, were not entirely accurate and have been refined by later research.
  • Future Directions (implied): The paper highlights the continuous evolution of electrode technology (e.g., multi-channel, surface EMG) and signal processing algorithms for more precise motor unit analysis. It also points to the ongoing exploration of neuromodulatory pathways and the application of motor unit recording in clinical diagnostics and understanding various physiological conditions (fatigue, aging, exercise). The legacy of Adrian and Bronk continues to inspire advancements in both fundamental neuroscience and clinical applications.

Summary updated

Abstract

In two papers dated 1928 to 1929 in The Journal of Physiology, Edgar Adrian and Detlev Bronk described recordings from motor nerve and muscle fibres. The recordings from motor nerve fibres required progressive dissection of the nerve until a few fibres remained, from which isolated single fibre activity could be detected. The muscle fibre recordings were performed in humans during voluntary contractions with an intramuscular electrode - the concentric needle electrode - that they describe for the first time in the second paper. They recognised that muscle fibres would respond to each impulse sent by the innervating motor neurone and that therefore muscle fibre recordings provided information on the times of activation of the motor nerve fibres which were as accurate as a direct record from the nerve. These observations and the description of the concentric needle electrode opened the era of motor unit recordings in humans, which have continued for almost a century and have provided a comprehensive view of the neural control of movement at the motor unit level. Despite important advances in technology, many of the principles of motor unit behaviour that would be investigated in the subsequent decades were canvassed in the two papers by Adrian and Bronk. For example, they described the concomitant motor neurones' recruitment and rate coding for force modulation, synchronisation of motor unit discharges, and the dependence of discharge rate on motor unit recruitment threshold. Here, we summarise their observations and discuss the impact of their work. We highlight the advent of the concentric needle, and its subsequent influence on motor control research.
BibTeX
@article{farina2023neural,
  author = {Dario Farina and Simon C. Gandevia},
  title = {{The neural control of movement: a century of <i>in vivo</i> motor unit recordings is the legacy of Adrian and Bronk}},
  journal = {The Journal of Physiology},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1113/jp285319},
}
Figure