The Need for Ecotourism at Our Third Pole and Their Sustainable Development and Policy Responses

Yi Wang, Chenhaojia Liu, Chenyu WangFrontiers in Business Economics and Management 2021 · DOI

Abstract The term ecotourism was originally proposed to rethink culture, education, and tourism, and has developed into a foundational concept for international natural ecological sustainability. This paper uses a combination of desktop research and literature research to explore the necessity, feasibility, and sustainability of ecotourism in the Third Pole, specifically analyzing the current situation, strengths and weaknesses, and four potential problems of ecotourism in the Tibetan Plateau, and making recommendations, including, but not limited to, the introduction of encouraging and restrictive policies for local tourism practitioners and people from the tourism industry.

Introduction: The "Third Pole" Paradox

The Tibetan Plateau is a critical ecological barrier, home to the headwaters of major rivers and unique biodiversity. However, it faces a "development-conservation" paradox. While tourism has become a vital economic pillar, the region’s extreme environment—characterized by high altitudes, low oxygen, and a short "suitable" season—makes it hyper-vulnerable to human impact.

Map of China highlighting the Tibetan Plateau and major road networks.

The authors tackle the challenge of "over-tourism" in a region where the self-healing capacity of the environment is nearly zero. They identify a lack of standardized management, insufficient funding, and a growing trend of rural depopulation as primary hurdles. The core question is: How can China develop a tourism model that respects the "Third Pole's" ecological limits while providing a sustainable livelihood for its indigenous population?

Methodology

The researchers employ a SWOT (Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, Threats) strategic analysis model. This is a standard qualitative framework used to synthesize internal and external factors affecting regional development. The study relies on desktop and literature research, aggregating data from government white papers (such as the 2021 White Paper on Tibet), national park system reform plans, and demographic statistics. They also incorporate qualitative insights from interviews with local ecological protection associations to ground their policy recommendations in the lived experience of the community.

Data and Regional Context

While not a data-heavy computational paper, the authors utilize several key secondary data sources:

  • Tourism Resource Surveys: Data indicating 29 "excellent" and 160 "excellent" tourism resources within the autonomous region.
  • Demographic Data: Population statistics from the National Bureau of Statistics of China, specifically focusing on rural population loss in Qinghai Province from 2006 to 2020. This trend underscores the urgency of creating local economic incentives to prevent community collapse.
Rural population decline in Qinghai Province from 2006 to 2020.
  • Economic Case Studies: Financial performance data from local handicraft cooperatives (e.g., the Sanjiangyuan Ecological Protection Association).

Strategic Framework for Sustainable Ecotourism

The "Banff" Model for the Third Pole

One of the most significant proposals is the implementation of a strict zoning system inspired by Canada’s Banff National Park. The authors suggest dividing the plateau into "Core Areas" (strictest protection, scientific research only), "Buffer Zones" (off-limits to visitors), and "Human Disturbance Areas" (where tourism and residence are permitted).

Ecotourism as a Demographic Fix

The paper highlights a critical link between tourism and rural flight. By creating roles for "eco-advocates," local guides, and patrol officers, ecotourism can provide high-value jobs that encourage young residents to return to their hometowns, mitigating the aging crisis in remote areas.

Digital Innovation and Cultural Authenticity

To solve the problem of "overly long distances" and physical accessibility, the authors suggest leveraging an "Internet+" strategy. Live streaming and digital cultural education allow for "remote tourism" without increasing the physical footprint on fragile soil. Furthermore, they argue that traditional lifestyles, such as "Black Tent" accommodations, are unique "special products" that provide a competitive edge based on preservation rather than modernization.

Key Results and Policy Responses

The paper cites that local handicraft cooperatives earned approximately 200,000 RMB in a single year, demonstrating that community-led ecological economics can be profitable. The authors successfully map out a dual-track policy response:

  • Restrictive Measures: Plastic bans, visitor quotas, and "ecological blacklists" for misconduct.
  • Incentive Measures: Tax breaks, free skill training for locals, and subsidies for residents starting commercial eco-activities.

The analysis confirms that the suitable sightseeing window is extremely narrow (April–May and September–October), necessitating a management strategy that can handle high-intensity bursts of visitors without exceeding environmental carrying capacity.

Limitations and Future Outlook

The paper serves as a high-level strategic overview rather than a quantitative modeling study. It does not provide a specific mathematical "carrying capacity" for different zones, which would be necessary for actual policy implementation.

Future research should focus on Quantitative Impact Modeling using GIS to track soil degradation, Longitudinal Economic Studies on youth retention, and the development of specialized Waste Management Infrastructure for high-altitude environments where traditional decomposition is inhibited.

Summary updated

Abstract

The term ecotourism was originally proposed to rethink culture, education, and tourism, and has developed into a foundational concept for international natural ecological sustainability. This paper uses a combination of desktop research and literature research to explore the necessity, feasibility, and sustainability of ecotourism in the Third Pole, specifically analyzing the current situation, strengths and weaknesses, and four potential problems of ecotourism in the Tibetan Plateau, and making recommendations, including, but not limited to, the introduction of encouraging and restrictive policies for local tourism practitioners and people from the tourism industry.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2021need,
  author = {Yi Wang and Chenhaojia Liu and Chenyu Wang},
  title = {{The Need for Ecotourism at Our Third Pole and Their Sustainable Development and Policy Responses}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Business Economics and Management},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.54097/fbem.v2i3.183},
}
Figure