The Multi‐BMBY Mechanism: Proportionality‐Preserving and Strategyproof Ownership Restructuring in Private Companies

Gal Danino, Moran Koren, Omer MadmonJournal of Economics & Management Strategy 2025 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces the Multi-BMBY Mechanism (MBM), a novel approach to ownership restructuring in private companies. MBM allows for a controlled reduction in the number of shareholders while ensuring that remaining owners retain their proportional stakes and that the process is strategyproof, budget-balanced, and individually rational. This offers a practical solution for startups facing complex ownership dynamics.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Private startups often accumulate a diverse set of owners over time, including early investors, venture capital firms, and employees. As the company matures, this complex ownership structure can hinder decision-making and streamline operations. The challenge lies in restructuring ownership – reducing the number of shareholders – without disrupting existing power dynamics or unfairly disadvantaging any party. Traditional methods like share buybacks are difficult in private firms due to the lack of a market-determined price, and sequential negotiations can be time-consuming and prone to manipulation. The core problem is how to efficiently reallocate shares to preserve proportionality among remaining owners and maximize overall welfare, all while ensuring truthful valuation elicitation from participants.

Methods

The paper extends the classic two-agent "buy me out or I will buy you out" (BMBY) mechanism to a multi-agent setting. The proposed Multi-BMBY Mechanism (MBM) takes as input the current ownership allocation and bids from all agents regarding their valuation of the asset. It then determines a single asset price and allocates shares such that a predetermined number of owners (or one less) remain.

Key features of the MBM include:

  • Strategyproofness: Agents are incentivized to bid their true valuations, as deviating from this strategy does not improve their outcome.
  • Proportionality Preservation: The ratio of shares among the remaining owners is maintained relative to their initial holdings.
  • Budget Balance: The mechanism ensures that all transactions balance, with no net gain or loss for the firm.
  • Individual Rationality: Each agent's utility is at least as good as their initial utility.
  • Controlled Owner Reduction: The mechanism allows for a flexible reduction in the number of owners, accommodating specific startup needs like incentivizing employee ownership.

The mechanism achieves these properties by setting the asset price based on the m-th highest bid and then allocating shares and payments accordingly. A novel aspect is the introduction of a probabilistic element in determining the final number of owners (either $m$ or $m-1$), which is crucial for achieving strategyproofness while maintaining proportionality.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bridging the Gap: The MBM provides a practical bridge between the theoretical ideal of allocating assets to the highest-valuing agent and the real-world need to maintain a certain level of distributed ownership for reasons like employee morale and investor relations.
  • The Power of Randomness: Introducing a controlled probabilistic element in the number of remaining owners is key to achieving strategyproofness in a multi-agent setting while still preserving proportionality. This is a clever way to overcome the limitations of deterministic mechanisms.
  • Beyond Efficiency: While many mechanisms focus solely on maximizing social welfare, the MBM explicitly balances this with the designer's objectives of controlling the number of owners and preserving existing power structures. This highlights a trade-off between pure efficiency and practical business needs.
  • Intuitive and Implementable: The mechanism's design is relatively straightforward, making it easier to understand and implement in real-world startup scenarios, which is a significant advantage over more complex theoretical models.

Key Results

The paper demonstrates that the MBM is:

  • Strategyproof: Agents are incentivized to bid truthfully.
  • Weakly Group Strategyproof: No subset of agents can collectively deviate and strictly improve their outcome.
  • Budget Balanced: All transactions are financially balanced.
  • Individually Rational: No agent is worse off after the restructuring.
  • Proportionality-Preserving Ex-Post Efficient: The mechanism ensures that remaining owners maintain their proportional shares and that no seller with a higher valuation is forced to sell to a buyer with a lower valuation.

The analysis also shows that the MBM improves social welfare compared to the initial allocation, especially when the number of owners is significantly reduced. The efficiency loss (compared to the first-best allocation) is shown to decay linearly with the fraction of remaining owners, particularly in scenarios with equal initial shares and uniform valuations.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the MBM does not achieve the absolute first-best allocation (giving the entire asset to the single highest-valuing agent) due to the constraint of proportionality preservation. While the mechanism improves social welfare, it is not explicitly designed to maximize it.

Future work suggested includes:

  • Extending the mechanism to handle non-linear utilities.
  • Incorporating additional constraints, such as upper bounds on individual ownership percentages.
  • Exploring how the gap between the highest-ranking seller's willingness to pay and the lowest-ranking buyer's valuation could be utilized to raise funds for the firm.
  • Developing dynamic implementations, such as an ascending clock auction, to further enhance strategyproofness and trust.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{danino2025multibmby,
  author = {Gal Danino and Moran Koren and Omer Madmon},
  title = {{The Multi‐BMBY Mechanism: Proportionality‐Preserving and Strategyproof Ownership Restructuring in Private Companies}},
  journal = {Journal of Economics \& Management Strategy},
  year = {2025},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=lKb5Ao4RIg},
}
Figure