The mitogenomes of two saprophytic Boletales species (Coniophora) reveals intron dynamics and accumulation of plasmid-derived and non-conserved genes

Peng Wu, Zhijie Bao, Wenying Tu, Lijiao Li, Chuan Xiong, Xin Jin, Ping Li, Mingying Gui, Wenli Huang, Qiang LiComputational 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study presents the first complete mitogenomes of two saprophytic fungi, Coniophora olivacea and C. puteana. These genomes reveal unique features compared to their ectomycorrhizal relatives, including a higher number of plasmid-derived and unknown genes, significant intron dynamics, and extensive gene rearrangements, offering new insights into the evolution of complex fungal lifestyles.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Fungi in the order Boletales exhibit diverse lifestyles, ranging from saprophytic (decomposers) to ectomycorrhizal (symbiotic with plant roots). While previous research has explored differences in their nuclear genomes and lifestyles, the mitochondrial genomes (mitogenomes) of saprophytic Boletales have remained largely uncharacterized. This lack of data hinders our understanding of how mitogenomes evolve and adapt to different ecological niches within this important fungal group. Specifically, the paper aims to:

  1. Characterize the mitogenomes of two saprophytic Boletales species.
  2. Compare these mitogenomes with those of ectomycorrhizal Boletales to identify variations and conservations.
  3. Investigate intron dynamics, particularly in the cox1 gene, across Boletales and broader Basidiomycetes.
  4. Clarify the phylogenetic position of Boletales within the phylum Basidiomycota using mitochondrial genes.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach:

  • Genome Assembly and Annotation: High-throughput sequencing data was used to assemble the circular mitogenomes of C. olivacea and C. puteana. Standard bioinformatics tools like SPAdes, MITObim, MFannot, MITOS, and NCBI Open Reading Frame Finder were used for assembly, annotation of protein-coding genes (PCGs), rRNA, and tRNA genes.
  • Comparative Mitogenomic Analysis: The newly assembled mitogenomes were compared with previously published mitogenomes of ectomycorrhizal Boletales species. This involved analyzing base composition, strand asymmetries, and gene content.
  • Sequence Analysis: Standard methods were used to calculate pairwise genetic distances, synonymous (Ks) and nonsynonymous (Ka) substitution rates for core PCGs, and to assess gene collinearity using Mauve.
  • Repetitive Element Analysis: BLASTN searches were conducted to identify intra-genomic duplications and interspersed repeats. Tandem Repeats Finder was used for shorter tandem repeats. Additionally, searches against nuclear genomes were performed to detect potential gene transfer events.
  • Intron Analysis: Introns within the cox1 gene of 76 Basidiomycota species were classified based on their insertion sites, allowing for the study of intron gain/loss dynamics and the identification of novel intron classes.
  • Phylogenetic Analysis: A robust phylogenetic tree of 76 Basidiomycota species was constructed using a concatenated set of 15 core PCGs and 2 rRNA genes. Both Bayesian inference (BI) and Maximum Likelihood (ML) methods were employed to ensure reliable tree topology.

Datasets

The study utilized publicly available sequencing data for Coniophora olivacea (accession SRR4171236) and C. puteana (accession SRR3927427) from the Sequence Read Archive (SRA). Additionally, mitogenome data from four previously published ectomycorrhizal Boletales species (Rhizopogon salebrosus, R. vinicolor, Paxillus involutus, and P. rubicundulus) and a broader dataset of 76 Basidiomycota species were used for comparative and phylogenetic analyses. The complete mitogenomes of C. olivacea and C. puteana were deposited in GenBank under accession numbers MT375015 and MT375016, respectively.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Saprophytic vs. Ectomycorrhizal Mitogenome Differences: The saprophytic Coniophora species possess mitogenomes with a higher burden of "non-standard" genes, including plasmid-derived genes (like DNA polymerases) and genes of unknown function. This suggests that saprophytic lifestyles might be associated with different evolutionary pressures or acquisition strategies for genetic material compared to ectomycorrhizal fungi.
  • Intron Dynamics and Contraction: The study highlights significant intron gain and loss events across Boletales and Basidiomycetes. Notably, C. olivacea showed a high number of introns, but most appeared to have undergone "contraction," meaning they lost their functional intron-encoded ORFs. This suggests a trend towards intron simplification in some lineages.
  • Gene Rearrangement Drivers: Large-scale gene rearrangements were observed in the Coniophora mitogenomes. The accumulation of intra-genomic repeats is identified as a primary suspect for driving these rearrangements, a common mechanism in organelle genome evolution.
  • Phylogenetic Utility of Mitogenomes: The study successfully used a concatenated set of mitochondrial genes to build a well-supported phylogenetic tree for 76 Basidiomycota species, reinforcing the value of mitogenomes for resolving fungal evolutionary relationships, especially at higher taxonomic levels.
  • Early Divergence of Coniophora: The phylogenetic analysis suggests that the Coniophora genus diverged from other Boletales early in their evolutionary history, potentially reflecting an early split between saprophytic and ectomycorrhizal lineages.

Key Results

  • The mitogenomes of C. olivacea and C. puteana were assembled to lengths of 78,350 bp and 79,655 bp, respectively.
  • Saprophytic Coniophora species contained, on average, 7 plasmid-derived genes and 12 unknown functional genes, significantly more than ectomycorrhizal Boletales species.
  • Core protein-coding genes nad2 and rps3 showed evidence of positive selection pressure in some Boletales species, indicated by Ka/Ks ratios greater than 1.
  • A total of 1058 introns were found across 76 Basidiomycota species, with cox1 being the most common host gene for introns.
  • The Coniophora mitogenomes exhibited large-scale gene rearrangements, with repeat sequences identified as a potential contributing factor.
  • A well-supported phylogenetic tree of 76 Basidiomycota species was generated, placing the Coniophora species as a distinct early-diverging lineage within Boletales.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Unknown Gene Functions: A significant number of genes in the Coniophora mitogenomes have unknown functions. Further research is needed to elucidate their roles and understand their contribution to the saprophytic lifestyle.
  • Intron Origin and Evolution: The origin and evolutionary trajectory of the novel intron classes found in Coniophora species require further investigation.
  • Mechanism of Gene Rearrangement: While repeat accumulation is implicated in gene rearrangements in Coniophora, other driving mechanisms for mitogenome rearrangement in fungi, particularly in species like Rhizopogon that lack extensive repeats, need further exploration.
  • Broader Sampling: The authors emphasize the need for more mitogenome data from diverse Boletales species to fully understand the evolutionary patterns of this order with complex lifestyles.
  • Impact of tRNA Mutations: The study noted base mutations in Coniophora tRNAs. The functional implications of these mutations on protein synthesis and fungal development warrant further investigation.

Summary updated

Abstract

The order Boletales is a group of fungi with complex life styles, which include saprophytic and ectomycorrhizal mushroom-forming fungi. In the present study, the complete mitogenomes of two saprophytic Boletales species, <i>Coniophora olivacea</i>, and <i>C. puteana</i>, were assembled and compared with mitogenomes of ectomycorrhizal Boletales. Both mitogenomes comprised circular DNA molecules with sizes of 78,350 bp and 79,655 bp, respectively. Comparative mitogenomic analysis indicated that the two saprophytic Boletales species contained more plasmid-derived (7 on average) and unknown functional genes (12 on average) than the four ectomycorrhizal Boletales species previously reported. In addition, the core protein coding genes, <i>nad2</i> and <i>rps3</i>, were found to be subjected to positive selection pressure between some Boletales species. Frequent intron gain/loss events were detected in Boletales and Basidiomycetes, and several novel intron classes were found in two <i>Coniophora</i> species. A total of 33 introns were detected in <i>C. olivacea</i>, and most were found to have undergone contraction in the <i>C. olivacea</i> mitogenome. Mitochondrial genes of <i>Coniophora</i> species were found to have undergone large-scale gene rearrangements, and the accumulation of intra-genomic repeats in the mitogenome was considered as one of the main contributing factors. Based on combined mitochondrial gene sets, we obtained a well-supported phylogenetic tree for 76 Basidiomycetes, demonstrating the utility of mitochondrial gene analysis for inferring Basidiomycetes phylogeny. The study served as the first report on the mitogenomes of the family Coniophorineae, which will help to understand the origin and evolution patterns of Boletales species with complex lifestyles.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wu2020mitogenomes,
  author = {Peng Wu and Zhijie Bao and Wenying Tu and Lijiao Li and Chuan Xiong and Xin Jin and Ping Li and Mingying Gui and Wenli Huang and Qiang Li},
  title = {{The mitogenomes of two saprophytic Boletales species (Coniophora) reveals intron dynamics and accumulation of plasmid-derived and non-conserved genes}},
  booktitle = {Computational},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1016/j.csbj.2020.12.041},
}
Figure