The minimal COVID-19 vaccination coverage and efficacy to compensate for potential increase of transmission contacts, and increased transmission probability of the emerging strains

Biao Tang, Xue Zhang, Qian Li, Nicola Luigi Bragazzi, Dasantila Golemi‐Kotra, Jian WuResearch 2021 · DOI

Abstract

Background: Mass immunization is a potentially effective approach to finally control the local outbreak and global spread of the COVID-19 pandemic. However, it can also lead to undesirable outcomes if mass vaccination results in increased transmission effective contacts and relaxation of other public health interventions due to the perceived immunity from the vaccine. Methods: We designed a mathematical model of COVID-19 transmission dynamics that takes into consideration the epidemiological status, public health intervention status (quarantined/isolated), immunity status of the population, and the strain variations. Comparing the control reproduction numbers and the final epidemic sizes (attack rate) in the cases with and without vaccination, we quantified some key factors determining when vaccination in the population is beneficial for preventing and controlling future outbreaks. Results: Our analyses predicted that there is a critical (minimal) vaccine efficacy rate (or a critical quarantine rate) below which the control reproduction number with vaccination is higher than that without vaccination, and the final attack rate in the population is also higher with the vaccination. We also predicted the worst-case scenario occurs when a high vaccine coverage is achieved for a vaccine with lower efficacy rate and when the vaccines increase the transmission efficient contacts. Conclusions: The analyses show that an immunization program with a vaccine efficacy rate below the predicted critical values will not be as effective as simply investing in the contact tracing/quarantine/isolation implementation. This research highlights the importance of monitoring the impact on transmissibility and vaccine efficacy of emerging strains.

Introduction

A central challenge in managing the COVID-19 pandemic is the behavioral feedback loop associated with public health interventions. When a vaccine becomes available, individuals often experience a sense of "perceived immunity," which may lead to increased social contacts, reduced mask-wearing, or decreased compliance with quarantine protocols.

This study addresses a critical question: At what point does the biological protection offered by a vaccine get canceled out by the behavioral changes of the vaccinated population? This is particularly relevant as emerging mutant strains increase transmissibility, effectively "moving the goalposts" for what constitutes an effective vaccination campaign.

Methods: Modeling Transmission Dynamics

The researchers developed a sophisticated compartmental mathematical model, extending the classic SEIR (Susceptible-Exposed-Infectious-Recovered) framework to simulate COVID-19 transmission under various vaccination and behavioral scenarios.

Schematic representation of the compartmental COVID-19 transmission model, accounting for vaccination, quarantine, and clinical status.

Key features of the model include:

  • Population Stratification: The model divides the population into vaccinated and unvaccinated groups.
  • Granular Clinical States: It tracks individuals through Susceptible (S), Exposed (L), Pre-symptomatic (P), Symptomatic (I), Asymptomatic (A), Quarantined/Diagnosed (D), and Recovered (R) states.
  • Behavioral Parameters: The model introduces $\beta_v$ (transmission rate for vaccinated individuals) and compares it to $\beta$ (unvaccinated). A ratio where $\beta_v > \beta$ represents a relaxation of social distancing.
  • Analytical Metrics: The primary metrics are the control reproduction number ($R_0^v$)—the average number of new infections caused by one infected individual in a partially vaccinated population—and the final epidemic size (attack rate).

Data and Parameters

As a theoretical modeling study, the research utilizes parameter values derived from established epidemiological data, specifically referencing the Province of Ontario, Canada, during the 2020-2021 period.

Key epidemiological parameters and baseline values used in the mathematical simulations.

Baseline values for incubation periods, recovery rates, and transmission probabilities were sourced from established literature. The authors then varied efficacy ($\eta$), coverage ($v$), and contact rates ($\beta_v$) to simulate a wide array of hypothetical scenarios.

Key Insights: The "Perceived Immunity" Trap

The model identifies a mathematical "tipping point" where vaccination can paradoxically worsen an outbreak:

  • Behavioral Offset: If a vaccine has moderate efficacy (e.g., 60%) but leads to a significant increase in social contacts, the reproduction number $R_0$ may rise, making the outbreak harder to control than if no vaccination had occurred.
  • Critical Efficacy Thresholds: If vaccine efficacy falls below a calculated critical value, increasing vaccination coverage actually increases the final size of the epidemic.
  • Quarantine vs. Vaccination: In certain scenarios, the model suggests that improving contact tracing and quarantine (increasing the quarantine rate $q$) is more effective and resource-efficient than a mass campaign using a low-efficacy vaccine.

Results and Mutant Strain Pressure

The study's simulations yielded several vital benchmarks for public health policy:

  • The 70% Rule: For highly transmissible mutant strains, the model showed that even with 50% coverage, a vaccine requires at least 70% efficacy to prevent the reproduction number from exceeding the danger threshold of 1.0 if social distancing is relaxed.
  • Impact of Contact Rates: If social contacts triple ($\beta_v/\beta = 3$) and efficacy is only 60%, vaccination leads to a consistently higher reproduction number than no vaccination, regardless of quarantine efforts.
  • Non-monotonicity: The data reveals a phenomenon where, as vaccination coverage increases, the total number of cases can initially increase before eventually decreasing, depending on the underlying quarantine rate and the degree of behavioral relaxation.

Limitations and Future Directions

While providing a robust theoretical framework, the model has limitations:

  • Logistic Constraints: It assumes near-instantaneous vaccine administration and does not account for the time-lag of multi-dose regimens or supply chain delays.
  • Waning Immunity: The study focuses on the "final size" of an outbreak and does not explicitly model the long-term decay of vaccine-induced or natural immunity.
  • Homogeneous Mixing: The compartmental approach assumes uniform mixing, which may not capture the "super-spreader" dynamics of specific social networks.

The authors conclude that future public health strategies must integrate real-time monitoring of emerging strains' transmissibility to dynamically adjust vaccination targets and social distancing policies.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Background: Mass immunization is a potentially effective approach to finally control the local outbreak and global spread of COVID-19 pandemic. However, it can also lead to undesirable outcomes if mass vaccination results in increased transmission effective contacts and relaxation of other public health interventions due to the perceived immunity from the vaccine. Methods: We designed a mathematical model of COVID-19 transmission dynamics that takes into consideration the epidemiological status, public health intervention status (quarantined/isolated), immunity status of the population, and the strain variations. Comparing the control reproduction numbers and the final epidemic sizes (attack rate) in the cases with and without vaccination, we quantified some key factors determining when vaccination in the population is beneficial for preventing and controlling future outbreaks. Results: Our analyses predicted that there is a critical (minimal) vaccine efficacy rate (or a critical quarantine rate) below which the control reproduction number with vaccination is higher than that without vaccination, and the final attack rate in the population is also higher with the vaccination. We also predicted the worst case scenario occurs when a high vaccine coverage is achieved for a vaccine with lower efficacy rate and when the vaccines increase the transmission efficient contacts. Conclusions: The analyses show that an immunization program with a vaccine efficacy rate below the predicted critical values will not be as effective as simply investing in the contact tracing/quarantine/isolation implementation. We reached similar conclusions by considering the final epidemic size (or attack rates). This research then highlights the importance of monitoring the impact on transmissibility and vaccine efficacy of emerging strains.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{tang2021minimal,
  author = {Biao Tang and Xue Zhang and Qian Li and Nicola Luigi Bragazzi and Dasantila Golemi‐Kotra and Jian Wu},
  title = {{The minimal COVID-19 vaccination coverage and efficacy to compensate for potential increase of transmission contacts, and increased transmission probability of the emerging strains}},
  booktitle = {Research},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-140717/v1},
}
Figure