Abstract
Cow's milk is an important foodstuff and beneficial to human health. In the present study, commercial milks from China and Japan and raw milk from Inner Mongolia of China were collected. The contents of 18 elements were determined using inductively coupled plasma-optical emission spectrometry (ICP-OES), atomic absorption spectrometry (AAS) and atomic fluorescence spectrometry (AFS). Our analysis showed both Chinese and Japanese milks are rich in macroelements, such as calcium and potassium. However, the milk contents of chromium, manganese, and zinc, which belong to microelements, were higher in Chinese commercial milks than in Japanese commercial milks. Heavy metals in food pose potential health risks. Although lead and cadmium contents in Chinese milk did not exceed the tolerance limits of Chinese National Standards, they were higher than those in Japanese commercial milks. Based on the high contents of some microelements and heavy metals in Chinese milk, we should innovate the technology and improve quality control for milk processing and decrease environmental pollution.
Introduction
As milk consumption rapidly increases across East Asia, ensuring its safety and nutritional consistency is paramount. While milk is a primary source of calcium (Ca) and potassium (K), it can also inadvertently serve as a pathway for toxic heavy metals like lead (Pb) and cadmium (Cd) or excessive amounts of trace elements.
Prior to this study, comparative data on the mineral profiles of commercial milks in China versus Japan were sparse, often relying on less sensitive analytical methods. The authors sought to fill this gap by using high-precision spectrometry to evaluate whether regional environmental factors or industrial processing methods significantly alter the elemental makeup of the milk reaching consumers.
Methodology and Datasets
The researchers employed a suite of sophisticated analytical techniques to detect elements at varying concentrations. Samples underwent microwave-assisted digestion using nitric acid ($HNO_3$) and hydrogen peroxide ($H_2O_2$) to break down the organic matrix.
- ICP-OES: Used for macroelements present in higher concentrations, such as Ca, K, Mg, P, and Na.
- AAS: Flame-AAS was used for iron (Fe), manganese (Mn), and zinc (Zn), while Graphite-furnace-AAS provided the sensitivity needed for trace elements and heavy metals like Cd, Cr, Cu, Mo, and Pb.
- AFS: Specifically utilized for hydride-forming elements and mercury (As, Hg, Se).
The study analyzed commercial milk from two major national brands in China and Japan, alongside raw milk from nomadic herders in Inner Mongolia to serve as a baseline. Results were validated against certified standard reference materials and compared with national food composition tables.
Results and Discussion
The core nutritional value (macroelements like Ca and K) remained remarkably consistent across all samples, confirming that milk remains a high-quality nutrient source in both countries. Both Chinese and Japanese milks are excellent sources of Ca and K, with concentrations typically exceeding 1000 mg/kg.
However, significant disparities were found in microelements and heavy metals. Chromium (Cr), Manganese (Mn), and Zinc (Zn) were significantly higher in Chinese commercial milks. For instance, Mn in Chinese milk (~0.37 mg/kg) was roughly double that of Japanese milk (~0.18 mg/kg). Manganese levels were also significantly higher in Chinese commercial milk than in the raw milk from Inner Mongolia, suggesting that industrial collection and processing machinery may contribute to these levels.
Regarding heavy metals, lead (Pb) and cadmium (Cd) levels were notably higher in Chinese samples. Chinese commercial milks averaged ~33–35 $\mu g/kg$ of Pb, whereas Japanese milks were significantly lower at ~12–13 $\mu g/kg$. Cadmium levels in Chinese samples were 2–4 times higher than Japanese samples. The authors attribute this to the "soil-cattle-feed-milk" chain, where atmospheric pollution from coal burning and traffic accumulates in the ecosystem. While these levels generally remained within safety limits, the narrow margin for lead in some Chinese samples was flagged as a concern. Encouragingly, Arsenic (As) and Mercury (Hg) were below detection limits in all samples.
Conclusion
This study highlights the impact of environmental pollution and industrial processing on the elemental composition of milk. While the basic nutritional profile is stable, the elevated levels of heavy metals and certain microelements in Chinese milk underscore the need for stricter environmental controls and technological innovation in processing. Future work should expand the sample size and geographic range to better represent national markets and account for regional industrial variations.
Summary updated