TL;DR
This paper introduces the Mesopotamian Ancient Place-names Almanac (MAPA), a Linked Open Data (LOD) gazetteer of place names in ancient Uruk and its surroundings. MAPA integrates textual data with remote sensing information to reconstruct the ancient urban landscape, offering a valuable digital resource for Assyriology and related fields.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The field of Assyriology, despite its rich textual sources, often relies on analog methods for data management and analysis. This can lead to duplicated effort, potential errors in data transfer, and a barrier to integrating diverse data types like textual records and remote sensing imagery. Specifically, reconstructing the social and physical geography of ancient Mesopotamian cities, like Uruk (one of the world's first mega-cities), is challenging due to the analog nature of many historical sources. The paper aims to bridge this gap by creating a digital, interoperable resource that facilitates the study of ancient urban landscapes.
Methods
The core methodology involves the manual extraction and curation of place names from legal, economic, and administrative texts dating to the Neo-Assyrian, Neo-Babylonian, and Achaemenid periods (roughly 8th to 4th centuries BCE). This process began with mining the comprehensive work "Geographical Names According to New- and Late-Babylonian Texts" (RGTC-8) and then cross-validating and enriching this data with information from other scholarly articles and digital resources. A significant aspect of the method is the adoption of Linked Open Data (LOD) protocols, specifically using the Linked Places format of the World Historical Gazetteer. This ensures that the gazetteer is interoperable and can be easily integrated with other datasets. The data includes variant Akkadian spellings, place terminology analysis (e.g., identifying "quays"), determinatives (like "town" or "city"), and proper nouns.
Datasets
The primary dataset introduced is the Mesopotamian Ancient Place-names Almanac (MAPA) gazetteer, version 1.0. This dataset contains close to 400 place names from the Uruk region. It is available in CSV, JSON, MD, BIB, and RIS formats. The gazetteer was built upon existing scholarly works, notably R. Zadok's "Geographical Names According to New- and Late-Babylonian Texts" (RGTC-8), and was further enriched by data from other articles and digital resources. The dataset is deposited in Zenodo and hosted on GitHub.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Bridging the Analog-Digital Divide: The paper highlights how a digital, LOD-compliant gazetteer can significantly enhance research in fields like Assyriology, which are traditionally reliant on analog resources.
- Integrating Textual and Spatial Data: MAPA represents a crucial step towards integrating textual evidence with remote sensing data, enabling a more comprehensive understanding of ancient urban geography.
- The Power of LOD: The adoption of Linked Open Data principles makes the gazetteer not just a static list but a dynamic, interconnected resource that can be easily linked with other historical and geographical datasets.
- Uruk as a Case Study: Focusing on Uruk, one of the earliest mega-cities, provides a rich context for studying the development of urbanism and its associated geographical features.
Key Results
The paper presents version 1.0 of the MAPA gazetteer, which includes approximately 400 place names. This version significantly enriches the previous iteration by adding variant Akkadian spellings, place terminology, determinatives, and proper noun analysis. The dataset is structured to follow LOD protocols, making it readily usable for computational analysis and integration with other historical data. The authors note that the gazetteer has already been used in a recent article to provide evidence for the intensity of Neo-Babylonian settlement in the Uruk region.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge that the textual record of Neo-Babylonian Uruk, while extensive, is inherently incomplete. The dataset cannot purport to represent the entirety of the ancient landscape, and the definition of the "Uruk urbanscape" can be ambiguous, with some places having only a simple textual connection. They also caution against perceiving digital resources as inherently objective and complete, emphasizing the inherent uncertainties in ancient world research.
Future work includes expanding the gazetteer by incorporating more texts and potentially applying the methodology to other periods or cities. The current data is also being analyzed to identify and map networks of canals and watercourses, with preliminary results suggesting the identification of central features and connected networks within the urban landscape. The authors also express interest in collaboration with similar projects like the Pleiades project and the World Historical Gazetteer.
Summary updated