The Mechanism of the Ordinal Position Effect: Stability Across Sense Modalities and the Hands Crossed Context

Qiangqiang Wang, Tingting Nie, Weixia Zhang, Wendian Shii-Perception 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the ordinal position effect (OPE), where early items in a sequence are processed faster with the left hand and later items with the right. The researchers demonstrate that the OPE is robust, extending to auditory stimuli and persisting even when participants cross their hands, suggesting a fundamental cognitive mechanism rather than a simple sensory or motor artifact.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The ordinal position effect (OPE) describes a phenomenon where the position of an item in a sequence influences response times. Specifically, items presented earlier in a sequence are typically responded to faster with the left hand, while later items are responded to faster with the right hand. This effect is conceptually similar to the Spatial-Numerical Association of Response Codes (SNARC) effect, where smaller numbers are associated with the left hand and larger numbers with the right. While the SNARC effect has been extensively studied across various modalities and contexts, the OPE's generalizability, particularly to auditory stimuli and under different physical constraints like crossed hands, remained less clear. This paper aims to bridge this gap by systematically investigating whether the OPE holds true in the auditory modality and when participants cross their hands, thereby exploring its stability and underlying mechanisms.

Methods

The study employed a series of five experiments using days of the week as the "order information." This choice was motivated by the familiarity of days and their inherent sequential nature, while minimizing confounding "magnitude" information.

  • Stimuli: Days of the week (e.g., "yesterday," "today," "tomorrow") were presented either visually (as text) or auditorily (spoken by male or female voices).
  • Tasks: Two main task types were used:
  • Days-relevant task: Participants judged whether a presented day was before or after "today."
    • Days-irrelevant task: Participants performed a task unrelated to the temporal order of the days, such as identifying the color of the visual stimulus or the gender of the voice. This was done to assess automatic activation of the OPE.
  • Response Mapping: Participants used their left or right index finger to indicate their response. In Experiment 5, participants were instructed to cross their hands, reversing the typical left-right mapping.
  • Data Analysis: Reaction times (RTs) were the primary measure. Repeated measures ANOVAs were used to analyze the effects of day sequence (before today vs. after today) and side of response (left key vs. right key), along with their interaction.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study used self-generated stimuli (days of the week) presented in a controlled experimental setting.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Auditory OPE is Real: The most significant finding is that the ordinal position effect is not limited to visual stimuli. It reliably appears when processing temporal order information presented auditorily, suggesting that the underlying cognitive mechanism is modality-independent.
  • Automatic Activation: The OPE can be automatically activated, even when participants are performing a task unrelated to temporal order (days-irrelevant task). This implies that the association between sequence position and response hand is deeply ingrained and can operate without conscious effort.
  • Hands Crossed, OPE Persists: The OPE remains robust even when participants cross their hands, reversing the typical left-right response mapping. This is a crucial finding, as it suggests the effect is not simply a consequence of the physical arrangement of the hands or a direct motor response, but rather a more abstract representation of order.
  • "Today" as a Powerful Reference Frame: The authors propose that using "today" as a reference point for temporal judgments leads to stronger OPE effects compared to using a less salient reference like "Wednesday" (as in previous studies). This highlights the importance of familiar and egocentric reference frames in cognitive processing.

Key Results

  • Experiment 1 & 2 (Visual): Confirmed the ordinal position effect in the visual modality for both days-relevant and days-irrelevant tasks. Days before today were faster with the left key, and days after today were faster with the right key.
  • Experiment 3 (Auditory, Relevant Task): Demonstrated the ordinal position effect in the auditory modality when participants performed a days-relevant task. Days before today were faster with the left key, and days after today were faster with the right key.
  • Experiment 4 (Auditory, Irrelevant Task): Showed that the ordinal position effect was automatically activated in the auditory modality, even when participants performed a days-irrelevant task (identifying voice gender).
  • Experiment 5 (Auditory, Hands Crossed): Revealed that the ordinal position effect persisted in the auditory modality when participants crossed their hands. The pattern of faster left-key responses for days before today and faster right-key responses for days after today remained, despite the reversed hand mapping.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Stimulus Set: The study used a limited set of stimuli (days of the week). Future research could explore the OPE with other types of sequential information (e.g., numbers, letters, musical notes) to further generalize the findings.
  • Reference Frame: While the study highlights the importance of "today" as a reference frame, further investigation into how different reference frames influence the OPE would be valuable.
  • Mechanism Exploration: While the study demonstrates the robustness of the OPE, further research using neuroimaging techniques (e.g., fMRI, EEG) could provide deeper insights into the neural mechanisms underlying these effects. The authors suggest that the findings support a correlation between number processing and order information processing, which could be further explored.

Summary updated

Abstract

The ordinal position effect posits that items positioned earlier in an ordinal sequence are responded to faster with the left key than the right key, and items positioned later in an ordinal sequence are responded to faster with the right key than the left key. Although the mechanism of the ordinal position effect has been investigated in many studies, it is unclear whether the ordinal position effect can extend to the auditory modality and the hands crossed context. Therefore, the present study employed days as the order information to investigate this question. Days were visually or acoustically displayed on a screen in random order, and participants were instructed to judge whether the probe day they perceived was before or after the current day (days-relevant task) or to identify the color or voice of the probe day they perceived (days-irrelevant task). The results indicate the following: (a) The days before the current day were responded to faster with the left key than the right key, and the days after the current day were responded to faster with the right key than the left key, both when the days-relevant task and the days-irrelevant task were performed, regardless of the sense modality. (b) The ordinal position effect for judgments of days was also obtained in the auditory modality even when the hands were crossed. These results indicate that the ordinal position effect can extend to the auditory modality and the hands crossed context, similar to the spatial-numerical association of response codes effect of numbers.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2019mechanism,
  author = {Qiangqiang Wang and Tingting Nie and Weixia Zhang and Wendian Shi},
  title = {{The Mechanism of the Ordinal Position Effect: Stability Across Sense Modalities and the Hands Crossed Context}},
  booktitle = {i-Perception},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1177/2041669519841071},
}

Loading related content...

Figure