The Mechanical Properties and Failure Mechanisms of Steel-Fiber- and Nano-Silica-Modified Crumb Rubber Concrete Subjected to Elevated Temperatures

Yihong Wang, Jiawei ChenSustainability 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the mechanical properties and failure mechanisms of crumb rubber concrete (CRC) modified with steel fibers and nano-silica when exposed to elevated temperatures. The findings demonstrate that these additives significantly improve the concrete's integrity and performance under fire conditions, offering a more sustainable and resilient construction material.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The automotive industry generates a massive amount of waste tires annually, posing a significant environmental challenge. Recycling these tires into crumb rubber for concrete (CRC) offers a sustainable solution, but the hydrophobic nature of rubber can lead to weaker interfaces and reduced mechanical properties, limiting its structural applications. Furthermore, concrete's performance degrades significantly at elevated temperatures, as experienced during fires, posing a risk to structural safety. This paper addresses the need to enhance the high-temperature performance of CRC by incorporating steel fibers and nano-silica, aiming to improve its mechanical properties and failure mechanisms under fire scenarios.

Methods

The researchers conducted experiments on 12 different concrete mixture proportions, totaling 288 specimens. They systematically varied three key parameters: steel fiber volume ratio (0%, 0.5%, 1.0%, 1.5%), nano-silica content (0%, 1%, 2%), and elevated temperatures (20°C, 200°C, 400°C, 600°C). A custom-built heating and loading apparatus was used to test the compressive and splitting tensile strengths of the specimens. To understand the underlying failure mechanisms, Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) and X-ray Diffraction (XRD) analyses were performed on micro-samples.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on experimental data generated from the prepared concrete specimens.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Synergistic Improvement: The combination of steel fibers and nano-silica offers a synergistic effect, significantly enhancing the performance of crumb rubber concrete at elevated temperatures.
  • Ductility Enhancement: Steel fibers and nano-silica transform the brittle failure of CRC at high temperatures into a more ductile behavior, improving the overall integrity of the material.
  • Optimal Additive Ratios: The study identified optimal content levels for the additives: 1.0% steel fiber and 1.0% nano-silica, which provided the best balance of mechanical properties and workability.
  • Microstructural Transformation: SEM and XRD analyses revealed that nano-silica densifies the concrete matrix and promotes the formation of C-S-H gel, while elevated temperatures influence the decomposition and formation of various mineral phases, impacting strength.
  • Fire Resistance: The modified concrete exhibits improved resistance to spalling and maintains better structural integrity under high-temperature conditions compared to unmodified CRC.

Key Results

  • Strength Increase: Compressive and splitting tensile strengths of the modified concrete generally increased with higher steel fiber content, especially at elevated temperatures.
  • Nano-Silica Impact: Nano-silica significantly improved compressive strength at elevated temperatures, with an optimal content of 1.0% showing notable gains.
  • Temperature Effects: Concrete strength initially decreased at 200°C due to water evaporation and microcrack expansion, then increased at 400°C due to new substance formation and decomposition of bound water, and finally decreased at 600°C due to severe matrix decomposition.
  • Failure Mode Amelioration: Steel fibers and nano-silica significantly reduced crack width and improved the overall integrity of specimens subjected to both compressive and splitting tensile tests at elevated temperatures.
  • Mass Loss: Mass loss was primarily attributed to water evaporation and decomposition of chemically bound water, with higher mass loss observed in the higher strength grade concrete (C45CR5).

Limitations and Future Work

The paper acknowledges that at room temperature, very high dosages of steel fibers (1.5%) could lead to a slight decrease in strength due to fiber balling and defects. Future work could explore a wider range of additive combinations and investigate the long-term durability of SFNS-CRC under various environmental conditions. Further research into the specific mechanisms of hydrogarnet formation at 400°C and its precise contribution to strength could also be beneficial.

Summary updated

Abstract

Steel-fiber- and nano-silica-modified crumb rubber concrete (SFNS-CRC), a new kind of environmentally friendly concrete, is characterized by its high performance. It achieves the recycling and reuse of waste rubber and promotes sustainable development in the rubber industry. This study used 12 groups of 288 specimens to study its mechanical properties and failure mechanisms when subjected to elevated temperatures. In the experiments, a heating and loading apparatus invented in our laboratory was used. The chosen crumb rubber concrete contained 5% rubber by volume. Through specimen analysis, the failure modes, mass loss, and compressive and splitting strengths of the specimens, as well as their failure mechanisms, were tested and are discussed while taking into account three variables, namely steel fiber volume ratio (0%, 0.5%, 1.0%, and 1.5%), nano-silica content (0%, 1%, and 2%), and temperature (20 °C, 200 °C, 400 °C, and 600 °C). The test results indicate that the typical damage shapes of CRC subjected to elevated temperatures can be significantly ameliorated through the addition of steel fibers and nano-silica. This can lead to evident improvements in brittle failure and render CRC ductile. Essentially, it improves the integrity of SFNS-CRC specimens. The compressive and splitting tensile strengths of concrete mixtures subjected to elevated temperatures increase with an increase in the steel fiber content. There is an obvious improvement in the compressive strength when subjected to elevated temperatures and after adding nano-silica. The CRC with a content of 1.0% steel fiber is optimal, and the optimal content of nano-silica is 1.0%. In addition, SFNS-CRC performs better in terms of mechanical properties when subjected to elevated temperatures. The splitting tensile strength of SFNS-CRC is improved using steel fibers, and nano-silica plays a crucial role in improving compressive performance. SEM and XRD analyses helped verify the test results.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2023mechanical,
  author = {Yihong Wang and Jiawei Chen},
  title = {{The Mechanical Properties and Failure Mechanisms of Steel-Fiber- and Nano-Silica-Modified Crumb Rubber Concrete Subjected to Elevated Temperatures}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/su152316340},
}
Figure