The MBD7 complex promotes expression of methylated transgenes without significantly altering their methylation status

Dongming Li, Ana Marie S. Palanca, So Youn Won, Lei Gao, Ying Feng, Ajay A. Vashisht, Li Liu, Yuanyuan Zhao, Xigang Liu, Xiuyun Wu, Shaofang Li, Brandon H. Le, Yun Ju Kim, Guodong Yang, Shengben Li, Jinyuan Liu, James A. Wohlschlegel, Hongwei Guo, Beixin Mo, Xuemei Chen, Julie A. LaweLife 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that the MBD7 complex in Arabidopsis thaliana promotes the expression of methylated transgenes by acting downstream of DNA methylation, rather than enforcing silencing. This complex is unique in its ability to overcome DNA methylation-induced gene silencing, offering a new perspective on how epigenetic marks influence gene regulation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

DNA methylation is a well-established epigenetic mark often associated with gene silencing in eukaryotes. While the mechanisms for establishing, maintaining, and removing DNA methylation are relatively well understood, how DNA methylation influences gene expression, particularly in promoting expression, remains less clear. Specifically, there's a gap in understanding factors that act after DNA methylation has occurred to modulate gene activity, especially those that counteract silencing. This paper investigates the role of the MBD7 complex in Arabidopsis in this context, aiming to elucidate its mechanism of action in regulating gene expression in the presence of DNA methylation.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Forward Genetic Screens: They used LUCIFERASE (LUC) reporter lines in Arabidopsis to screen for mutants that suppressed gene silencing. This involved identifying mutations that led to increased LUC expression from methylated transgenes.
  • Molecular Cloning and Sequencing: Identified mutated genes were cloned and sequenced to pinpoint the specific genetic disruptions.
  • Yeast Two-Hybrid (Y2H) Screens: Used to identify protein-protein interactions, specifically to find proteins that interact with LIL (a gene identified in the screen).
  • Affinity Purification and Mass Spectrometry: Used to identify components of protein complexes, particularly those involving MBD5 and MBD7.
  • MethylC-sequencing (MethylC-seq): A high-resolution technique to map DNA methylation patterns across the genome and at specific transgene loci.
  • Traditional Bisulfite Sequencing: Another method to analyze DNA methylation patterns, used for validation and detailed analysis of specific regions.
  • RT-qPCR: To quantify gene expression levels (LUC and NPTII transcripts).
  • Chromatin Immunoprecipitation (ChIP): To investigate the association of MBD7 with specific genomic regions.
  • Transcriptome Profiling (RNA-seq): To assess genome-wide changes in gene expression in mutant lines.

Datasets

The study utilized several datasets:

  • Arabidopsis thaliana Genome: The reference genome (TAIR10) was used for genome-wide analyses.
  • Newly Generated MethylC-seq Data: Methylation profiles were generated for various mutant lines (lil, mbd7, rdd, ago4, nrpe1) and their corresponding wild-type controls.
  • Newly Generated RNA-seq Data: Transcriptome data was generated for Col, mbd7-3, mbd7-4, YJ, YJ lil-1, LUCH, and LUCH lil-2 lines.
  • Publicly Available Datasets: Data from previous studies on Arabidopsis epigenetics and gene expression were referenced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • MBD7 Complex as an Anti-Silencing Factor: The most striking finding is that the MBD7 complex acts to promote gene expression from methylated transgenes, directly opposing the typical silencing role of DNA methylation.
  • Downstream of DNA Methylation: The mechanism of action for the MBD7 complex appears to be largely downstream of the DNA methylation event itself, meaning it doesn't directly control the methylation process but rather responds to it.
  • Genetic Uncoupling of Methylation and Expression: The study demonstrates that increased DNA methylation at a reporter locus doesn't necessarily lead to gene silencing. The MBD7 complex can maintain high expression even with elevated methylation, highlighting a complex interplay.
  • Distinct MBD Complexes: MBD5 and MBD7 form distinct protein complexes with different Alpha Crystallin Domain (ACD) proteins, suggesting specialized roles for these MBD family members.
  • LIL as a Key Partner: LIL (LOW IN LUCIFERASE EXPRESSION) is identified as a crucial interacting partner of MBD7, and mutations in LIL phenocopy the effects of MBD7 disruption on LUC expression.

Key Results

  • Mutations in components of the MBD7 complex (MBD7, LIL, ROS4, ROS5) led to decreased LUC reporter gene expression.
  • These mutations also caused modest increases in DNA methylation at the reporter transgene's promoter, but the gene expression defect was disproportionately larger than the methylation change.
  • Genome-wide analyses showed minimal and inconsistent changes in DNA methylation in mbd7 and lil mutants, suggesting the complex doesn't globally regulate DNA methylation.
  • The MBD7 complex was found to associate with specific ACD proteins, forming distinct complexes with MBD5.
  • The MBD7 complex's role in promoting LUC expression was dependent on the presence of DNA methylation, confirming its role in transcriptional regulation.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Absence of Detectable Endogenous Targets: The study found no clear endogenous genes transcriptionally regulated by the MBD7 complex, suggesting it might function redundantly with other MBD-ACD complexes or be required under specific conditions.
  • Mechanism of Action: While the MBD7 complex's role downstream of DNA methylation is established, the precise molecular mechanism by which it promotes gene expression remains unknown and is a key area for future research.
  • Locus Specificity: The hyper-methylation observed in reporter transgenes was not consistently found at the same genomic locations across different reporters, suggesting it might be an indirect effect of MBD7 disruption rather than direct regulation of methylation at specific sites.
  • Further Characterization of MBD Complexes: The authors suggest exploring the composition, dynamics, and regulatory roles of various MBD and ACD complexes, as well as investigating their genetic relationships and contributions to chromatin modulation.

Summary updated

Abstract

DNA methylation is associated with gene silencing in eukaryotic organisms. Although pathways controlling the establishment, maintenance and removal of DNA methylation are known, relatively little is understood about how DNA methylation influences gene expression. Here we identified a METHYL-CpG-BINDING DOMAIN 7 (MBD7) complex in <i>Arabidopsis thaliana</i> that suppresses the transcriptional silencing of two <i>LUCIFERASE</i> (<i>LUC)</i> reporters via a mechanism that is largely downstream of DNA methylation. Although mutations in components of the MBD7 complex resulted in modest increases in DNA methylation concomitant with decreased <i>LUC</i> expression, we found that these hyper-methylation and gene expression phenotypes can be genetically uncoupled. This finding, along with genome-wide profiling experiments showing minimal changes in DNA methylation upon disruption of the MBD7 complex, places the MBD7 complex amongst a small number of factors acting downstream of DNA methylation. This complex, however, is unique as it functions to suppress, rather than enforce, DNA methylation-mediated gene silencing.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2017mbd,
  author = {Dongming Li and Ana Marie S. Palanca and So Youn Won and Lei Gao and Ying Feng and Ajay A. Vashisht and Li Liu and Yuanyuan Zhao and Xigang Liu and Xiuyun Wu and Shaofang Li and Brandon H. Le and Yun Ju Kim and Guodong Yang and Shengben Li and Jinyuan Liu and James A. Wohlschlegel and Hongwei Guo and Beixin Mo and Xuemei Chen and Julie A. Law},
  title = {{The MBD7 complex promotes expression of methylated transgenes without significantly altering their methylation status}},
  booktitle = {eLife},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.7554/elife.19893},
}
Figure