Abstract
We carry out multifractal analyses of multiple tracers namely the main galaxy sample, the LRG sample and the quasar sample from the SDSS to test the assumption of cosmic homogeneity and identify the scale of transition to homogeneity, if any. We consider the behaviour of the scaled number counts and the scaling relations of different moments of the galaxy number counts in spheres of varying radius $R$ to calculate the spectrum of the Minkowski-Bouligand general dimension $D_{q} (R)$ for $-4 \leq q \leq 4$. The present analysis provides us the opportunity to study the spectrum of the generalized dimension $D_{q}(R)$ for multiple tracers of the cosmic density field over a wide range of length scales and allows us to confidently test the validity of the assumption of cosmic homogeneity. Our analysis indicates that the SDSS main galaxy sample is homogeneous on a length scales of $80\, h^{-1}\, {\rm Mpc} $ and beyond whereas the SDSS quasar sample and the SDSS LRG sample show transition to homogeneity on an even larger length scales at $\sim 150\, h^{-1}\, {\rm Mpc}$ and $\sim 230\, h^{-1}\, {\rm Mpc}$ respectively. These differences in the scale of homogeneity arise due to the effective mass and redshift scales probed by the different tracers in a Universe where structures form hierarchically. Our results reaffirm the validity of cosmic homogeneity on large scales irrespective of the tracers used and strengthens the foundations of the Standard Model of Cosmology.
Introduction
The Cosmological Principle is a cornerstone of modern cosmology, asserting that on sufficiently large scales, the universe is both isotropic and homogeneous. While the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) provides robust evidence for isotropy, verifying homogeneity—the idea that the universe looks the same from every location—is more challenging. This study addresses the long-standing debate over whether the universe is truly homogeneous or possesses a fractal structure that remains clumpy at all scales.
Methodology: Multifractal Analysis
To test for homogeneity, the researchers employed multifractal analysis, a statistical framework that characterizes the distribution of matter across different scales. The primary metric used is the Minkowski-Bouligand dimension ($D_q$).
By calculating the number of objects within spheres of radius $R$, the team determined how the distribution scales. In a perfectly uniform 3D space, $D_q$ should equal 3. The "transition scale" to homogeneity is defined as the radius $R$ at which $D_q$ remains within 1% of the value 3. The parameter $q$ allows the analysis to weight different density environments: high $q$ values emphasize overdense regions, while low $q$ values focus on underdense voids.
Datasets and Tracers
The study utilizes three distinct datasets from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS), each probing different cosmic epochs and structures:
- Main Galaxy Sample (MGS): Represents the local universe ($z \leq 0.106$).
- Luminous Red Galaxy (LRG) Sample: Massive galaxies that trace the most significant dark matter concentrations ($z \approx 0.36$).
- SDSS DR12 Quasars: Highly luminous active galactic nuclei that probe the distant universe ($2.2 \leq z \leq 3.2$).
Results: The Scale of Homogeneity
The analysis reveals that while all tracers eventually confirm a transition to homogeneity, the specific scale at which this occurs varies significantly. This variation is attributed to "tracer bias"—the tendency of different objects to inhabit specific environments. LRGs, for instance, are more biased toward the densest parts of the cosmic web and thus require a larger volume of space before the distribution appears smooth.
- Main Galaxy Sample: Reaches homogeneity at approximately 80 $h^{-1}$ Mpc.
- Quasar Sample: Shows a transition at roughly 150 $h^{-1}$ Mpc.
- LRG Sample: Requires the largest scale, approximately 230 $h^{-1}$ Mpc, to appear uniform.
Conclusion
The findings of this study provide strong empirical support for the Cosmological Principle. By demonstrating that multiple independent tracers—ranging from local galaxies to distant quasars—all converge to a homogeneous distribution ($D_q \to 3$), the research validates the $\Lambda$CDM standard model of cosmology. While challenges like quasar sparsity and shot noise remain, the results reaffirm that the universe eventually becomes a "smooth soup" on scales larger than about 750 million light-years.
Summary updated