THE "MANUFACTURING RESHORING" STRATEGY IN THE UNITED STATES AND ITS IMPLICATIONS TO CHINA

Pan Hui, Di ZhuEurasian 2019 · DOI

Abstract

The manufacturing reshoring is the strategic decision of the United States, based on the assessment of the development trend about the domestic and international market. Its fundamental goal is to promote the upgrading of the manufacturing industry and maintain America's leadership during the new round of global technological revolution. In order to achieve the manufacturing reshoring goal, the U.S. government has formulated a series of policies and regulations, including technological progress policy, investment and financing policy, talent training policy, energy policy, market development policy and investment environment policy. Based on the data from the U.S. think tank, this paper systematically reviewed the latest developments in the total volume, technical composition, industrial structure, origins and whereabouts of the U.S. manufacturing reshoring, and concluded that U.S. manufacturing reshoring has a far-reaching negative impact on China's manufacturing industry. The main findings are that China's "industrial hollowing out", weakened technology spillover effect of foreign direct investment (FDI), a reduction in competitiveness of Chinese manufacturing exports, and China's heavy technology dependence on the U.S. are the results of U.S. manufacturing reshoring strategy. This paper thus proposed some countermeasures.

Introduction

For decades, the United States underwent a period of significant "de-industrialization," with the manufacturing sector's share of GDP declining from approximately 16% in 1997 to 11% by 2017. While this transition initially bolstered the service economy, it eventually led to an "industrial hollowing out" that exacerbated wealth inequality and contributed to the vulnerabilities exposed by the 2008 financial crisis. In response, the U.S. has pivoted toward an aggressive "manufacturing reshoring" strategy. This initiative aims to reclaim industrial leadership, mitigate domestic inequality, and secure a dominant position in the emerging "Industry 4.0" landscape.

Theoretical Framework: The Cobb-Douglas Approach

To understand the multifaceted nature of these reshoring efforts, the authors utilize the Cobb-Douglas production function as a conceptual lens. In this model, industrial output ($Y$) is viewed as a function of technological progress ($A$), capital investment ($K$), labor quality ($L$), and energy costs ($E$).

Figure 1: Conceptual framework of U.S. reshoring policies influencing production factors.

As illustrated in Figure 1, the U.S. government has deployed a suite of policies targeting each of these variables. For instance, the National Network for Manufacturing Innovation (NNMI) drives technological advancement ($A$), while tax reforms and financing incentives stimulate capital ($K$). Simultaneously, talent training programs enhance labor productivity ($L$), and the "shale gas revolution" provides a critical advantage in energy costs ($E$). Together, these policies create a favorable environment for manufacturing to return to domestic soil.

The scale of this shift is significant. By 2016, the number of jobs reshored to the U.S. surpassed those lost to offshoring for the first time in nearly four decades. Data from the Reshoring Initiative and UNCTAD indicate a reversal in Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) trends, with net inflows showing a sharp upward trajectory starting around 2015.

A critical finding of this study is the origin of these reshored activities. China has emerged as the primary source of returning manufacturing, accounting for nearly 60% of the total volume between 2010 and 2018.

Figure 4: Ranking of countries by reshored job posts and firms to the U.S.

As shown in Figure 4, China leads all other nations by a wide margin in both the number of job posts (over 64,000) and the number of firms (791) returning to the U.S. This "siphon effect" is driven by narrowing cost gaps. By 2014, the combined costs of manufacturing in China and the U.S.—accounting for land, logistics, and energy—reached near-parity, despite China's lower nominal labor costs.

Strategic Implications for China

The U.S. reshoring strategy poses several long-term challenges for China’s manufacturing sector:

  1. Industrial Hollowing Out: The departure of high-value manufacturing and R&D centers threatens to erode China's industrial base.
  2. Weakened Technology Spillovers: As U.S. firms exit, the traditional "technology spillover" effect from FDI—where domestic firms learn from foreign counterparts—diminishes.
  3. Technological Dependence: The U.S. focus on high-end manufacturing and Industry 4.0 could leave China increasingly dependent on American technology for its own industrial upgrades.
  4. Export Competitiveness: Near-parity in manufacturing costs, combined with U.S. automation, reduces the competitive advantage of Chinese exports in the North American market.

Conclusion and Countermeasures

The U.S. reshoring strategy is not merely a political slogan but a systematic economic realignment. To mitigate its negative impacts, the Chinese government must take proactive steps. First, it should lead targeted research into core technologies to drive industrial upgrading. Second, continuing market reforms to lower operational costs and improve the business environment is essential to retain manufacturing attractiveness. Finally, leveraging the "Belt and Road Initiative" can help diversify international markets and reduce over-reliance on U.S.-centric value chains.

Summary updated

Abstract

The manufacturing reshoring is the strategic decision of the United States, based on the assessment of the development trend about the domestic and international market. Its fundamental goal is to promote the upgrading of the manufacturing industry and maintain America's leadership during the new round of global technological revolution. In order to achieve the manufacturing reshoring goal, the U.S. government has formulated a series of policies and regulations, including technological progress policy, investment and financing policy, talent training policy, energy policy, market development policy and investment environment policy. Based on the data from the U.S. think tank, this paper systematically reviewed the latest developments in the total volume, technical composition, industrial structure, origins and whereabouts of the U.S. manufacturing reshoring, and concluded that U.S. manufacturing reshoring has a far-reaching negative impact on China's manufacturing industry. The main findings are that China's "industrial hollowing out", weakened technology spillover effect of foreign direct investment (FDI), a reduction in competitiveness of Chinese manufacturing exports, and China's heavy technology dependence on the U.S. are the results of U.S. manufacturing reshoring strategy. This paper thus proposed some countermeasures. First the Chinese government should actively lead manufacturing industry to conduct researches for technology advancement as well as industrial upgrade. Second, it should continue with the market reform, lower labor cost, improve business environment, and enhance the attractiveness of manufacturing industry. Third, with the help of "Belt and Road Initiative" strategy, it is recommended to spread the international market for China's manufacturing and lessen its technological dependence on the U.S.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{hui2019manufacturing,
  author = {Pan Hui and Di Zhu},
  title = {{THE "MANUFACTURING RESHORING" STRATEGY IN THE UNITED STATES AND ITS IMPLICATIONS TO CHINA}},
  booktitle = {Eurasian},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.15604/ejef.2019.07.03.001},
}
Figure