TL;DR
This retrospective study of 2,700 young patients in Singapore reveals a significant gap between clinical guidelines and real-world primary care for acne. Researchers found high rates of antibiotic monotherapy and inappropriately short treatment courses—practices that increase the risk of antibiotic resistance—alongside a surprisingly high rate of immediate specialist referrals.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Acne vulgaris is more than just a cosmetic concern; for young people (YPs), it is a chronic inflammatory condition linked to permanent scarring, depression, and anxiety. While Clinical Practice Guidelines (CPGs) provide a roadmap for management—emphasizing the avoidance of antibiotic monotherapy and recommending specific treatment durations—adherence in primary care settings is often a "black box."
The authors sought to evaluate how primary care physicians (PCPs) in Singapore actually manage acne. By analyzing demographic profiles, prescribing patterns, and referral behaviors, the study identifies where clinical practice deviates from evidence-based standards, particularly regarding the judicious use of antibiotics.
Methods
The researchers conducted a retrospective cohort study using data from a cluster of eight public primary care clinics (polyclinics) in Singapore.
- Population: Young persons aged 10–29 years with a documented ICD-10 diagnosis of acne between July 2018 and June 2020.
- Data Source: Clinical, prescription, and referral data were extracted from the Electronic Health Intelligence System (eHINTS), which aggregates data from electronic medical records and administrative systems.
- Analysis: Descriptive statistics and Chi-square tests were used to compare the acne cohort against the general polyclinic population and to evaluate prescribing patterns against established CPGs.
Datasets
The study utilized a large-scale institutional dataset from SingHealth Polyclinics.
- Total Pool: 103,437 YPs who attended the clinics during the study period.
- Study Cohort: 2,700 YPs specifically diagnosed with acne.
- Data Points: Included nationality, age, gender, race, acne-related medications (ARM), duration of antibiotics, and specialist referral details.
Key Insights and Ideas
- The Antibiotic Resistance Trap: One of the most concerning findings was that 33.5% of patients received antibiotic monotherapy. Guidelines strictly recommend combining oral antibiotics with topical non-antibiotic agents (like benzoyl peroxide) to prevent the development of resistant Cutibacterium acnes strains.
- Subtherapeutic Durations: Over half (54.3%) of those treated with antibiotics received courses shorter than the recommended six weeks. Such short bursts are often insufficient for clinical improvement and further contribute to the risk of treatment-resistant acne.
- High Referral Threshold (or Low PCP Confidence?): More than half (51.3%) of patients were referred to a dermatologist on their very first visit. This is significantly higher than rates seen in similar UK-based studies (approx. 8.5%). This may stem from a lack of access to certain medications (like isotretinoin) in primary care or a lack of PCP confidence in managing moderate-to-severe cases.
- Demographic Trends: Males (56.1%) and those of Chinese ethnicity (73.8%) were the most frequent seekers of care. The authors note that while this mirrors Singapore’s general demographics, it also highlights that young males may experience more severe inflammatory acne during puberty, prompting them to seek medical intervention.
Key Results
- Medication Coverage: Only 69.7% of patients diagnosed with acne actually received a prescription for acne-related medication.
- Top Prescriptions: Oral doxycycline was the most common systemic treatment (53.0%), while "acne cream" (a sulfur/salicylic acid/resorcinol combo) was the top topical choice (35.0%).
- Longitudinal Care Gap: Only 15.8% of patients had more than one follow-up visit. Since acne is a chronic condition requiring months of management, this suggests that longitudinal care in the primary setting is suboptimal.
- Referral Specifics: Of those referred to specialists, 96.9% went to dermatologists, while only two patients were referred to psychiatry, despite the known psychological burden of the disease.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge several limitations:
- Severity Data: The retrospective nature of the study meant that the clinical severity of the acne (mild vs. severe) was not recorded. This makes it difficult to judge if the high referral rate was clinically justified.
- Public vs. Private: The data only covers public polyclinics. Management patterns in Singapore’s private sector, where a wider range of non-subsidized treatments (like lasers or isotretinoin) are available, may differ.
- Under-reporting: Over-the-counter treatments used by patients were not captured, potentially skewing the data on topical medication use.
Future Work: The study concludes that PCPs require "refresher training" and better access to a wider formulary of medications to manage acne effectively within the primary care "front line," reducing the burden on specialist services and improving antibiotic stewardship.
Summary updated