Abstract
The extensive use of natural gas has created new opportunities for low-carbon primary energy composition, and has eased the peak value of carbon emissions before the complete transition to clean energy. To explore the impact of natural gas access on energy conservation and emission reduction in inland areas of developing countries, this study examines the policy intervention effects of the West-East Gas Pipeline Project in Hubei Province. In this paper, the causal inference of multi-bandwidth and multi-core analysis is made with breakpoint regression, and then the core conclusion of the counterfactual analysis is proven to be robust by using the synthetic control method. The results show that the transportation of natural gas from west-to-east to Hubei Province can reduce the intensity of carbon emissions, which demonstrates that it is an effective low-carbon energy alternative. The West-East Gas Pipeline Project can meet the demands of a large number of energy shortages caused by the rise of the manufacturing industry and can solve the energy bottleneck in the development process in the central and eastern regions of China. The West-East Gas Pipeline Project has ensured the coordinated development of the western, central and eastern regions in China, has stabilized the economic growth rate, and has achieved high-quality growth. These achievements can serve as a reference for guiding the energy conservation and emission reduction work of a considerable number of gas-importing central provinces.
Introduction: The Green Dilemma in Developing Nations
Developing nations face a "green dilemma": how to maintain high economic growth while simultaneously reducing carbon emissions. In China, this is complicated by internal industry migration, where heavy, high-carbon industries are moving from developed coastal provinces to inland regions like Hubei. While natural gas is widely touted as a cleaner alternative to coal, its actual impact on regional energy conservation and emission reduction is often debated. This study examines the policy intervention effects of the West-East Gas Pipeline Project (WEPP) in Hubei Province to determine if large-scale natural gas infrastructure truly decouples economic growth from carbon intensity.
Methodology
The study employs a decade of data (2008–2017) from the Hubei Provincial Energy Consumption Survey and Statistical Yearbooks. To ensure robust causal inference, the authors utilize two primary econometric techniques:
1. Regression Discontinuity Design (RDD)
The 2012 operational start of the WEPP's second line is treated as a "breakpoint." By comparing data immediately before and after this date, the researchers isolate the pipeline's impact from other long-term trends. The analysis uses a non-parametric approach with multiple bandwidths and kernels.
The Wald estimator (Equation 1) allows for the calculation of the treatment effect by normalizing the change in the outcome variable by the change in the probability of treatment. This is crucial for identifying the specific impact of the pipeline amidst other variables.
Equation (2) represents the basic estimator for the policy intervention effect at the 2012 breakpoint, comparing the limits of the expected outcome from both sides of the discontinuity.
2. Synthetic Control Method (SCM)
To prove causality, the authors created a "counterfactual" Hubei using a weighted combination of other Chinese provinces that did not receive the pipeline. The gap between the "real" Hubei and the "synthetic" Hubei represents the true policy effect.
Key Insights and Results
The empirical results validate the "bridge fuel" hypothesis, showing that natural gas serves as an effective intermediate step toward decarbonization.
- Emission Reduction: RDD analysis showed a significant negative Wald coefficient for total carbon emissions (approx. -0.108 to -0.319), indicating a clear drop in emissions attributable to the pipeline.
- Energy Mix Shift: Post-2012, natural gas consumption rose while coal and crude oil consumption fell. Specifically, the Wald coefficient for coal was -0.225 (significant at the 1% level), proving that gas actively displaced high-carbon fuels.
- Intensity vs. Total Volume: While the intensity of emissions (CO2 per unit of GDP) dropped significantly, total energy consumption did not decline massively. This suggests the WEPP solved an "energy bottleneck," allowing industrial expansion without proportional pollution increases.
- Counterfactual Success: The SCM test confirmed that after 2012, Hubei’s actual carbon emissions were consistently lower than the "synthetic" Hubei.
Conclusion and Future Directions
The West-East Gas Pipeline Project has ensured the coordinated development of China's regions, stabilizing economic growth while achieving higher quality, lower-carbon outcomes. However, natural gas remains a transition fuel. While it reduces emissions now, it is not a final solution for long-term carbon neutrality. Future research should explore the "tolerance mechanism" of energy consumption—determining the price point at which natural gas remains a viable economic alternative to coal for developing regions.
Summary updated