The Long-Term Effect of Famine Exposure on Cognitive Performance: Evidence from the 1959–1961 Chinese Famine

Han Zhang, Wing‐Chung HoInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the lasting impact of the 1959-1961 Chinese Famine on cognitive performance. It reveals that childhood exposure to famine, particularly between ages 1-18, significantly impairs immediate word recall in adulthood, while prenatal exposure shows no negative effect, likely due to survival biases.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding the long-term consequences of early-life nutritional deprivation on cognitive development is crucial, especially given the global challenge of population aging and the increasing prevalence of cognitive decline. While previous research has explored the effects of famines on health, the specific impact of the 1959-1961 Chinese Famine on cognitive performance across different life stages (prenatal, childhood, and early adulthood) has not been fully elucidated. A key challenge in this research area is the difficulty in establishing a true control group, as the Chinese Famine was a widespread, nationwide event.

Methods

The researchers employed two primary analytical approaches:

  1. Cohort Comparison Analysis: This method used data from the 2010 China Family Panel Study (CFPS) to compare individuals born in different periods relative to the famine. Three cohorts were defined: pre-famine (1955-1958), famine (1959-1962), and post-famine (1963-1966). A difference-in-differences (DID) model was used to estimate the effect of famine exposure on vocabulary test scores, considering provincial famine severity.
  2. Migrant-Stayer Comparison Approach: To address the lack of a perfect control group in the cohort analysis, this innovative approach was used. It compared individuals who remained in Guangdong province and experienced the famine (stayers) with those who migrated to Hong Kong before the famine and were thus spared its effects (emigrants). This quasi-experimental design leveraged data from the 2016 CFPS and the 2017 Hong Kong Panel Study of Social Dynamics (HKPSSD). Three birth cohorts were again used (1923-1940, 1941-1958, and 1963-1968), and DID models were applied to analyze immediate and delayed word recall. This approach helps to control for potential migration selectivity biases.

Datasets

  • 2010 China Family Panel Study (CFPS): A nationally representative, longitudinal survey of households and adults in mainland China. Used for the initial cohort comparison analysis.
  • 2016 China Family Panel Studies (CFPS): Used in conjunction with the HKPSSD for the migrant-stayer comparison.
  • 2017 Hong Kong Panel Study of Social Dynamics (HKPSSD): A citywide representative dataset providing detailed demographic and migration information. Used in conjunction with the CFPS for the migrant-stayer comparison.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Childhood is a Critical Window: The most striking finding is that exposure to famine during childhood (specifically ages 1-18) has a significant and lasting negative impact on cognitive performance, particularly immediate word recall. This highlights that the brain's development and function are highly sensitive to nutritional status during these formative years.
  • Prenatal Exposure is Different: Unlike childhood exposure, prenatal exposure to the famine did not show a negative association with adult cognitive performance. The authors suggest this is likely due to a "positive selection" effect, where fetuses severely impacted by malnutrition may not have survived, leaving only those who were more resilient.
  • Migrant-Stayer as a Powerful Control: The migrant-stayer approach proved valuable in creating a more robust comparison group, allowing for a clearer estimation of the famine's effects by accounting for factors that might influence both migration and cognitive outcomes.
  • Immediate Word Recall is Particularly Vulnerable: The study found a stronger effect of childhood famine exposure on immediate word recall compared to delayed word recall, suggesting specific cognitive functions are more susceptible to early-life nutritional stress.

Key Results

  • Cohort Analysis: Individuals who experienced the famine in early childhood (ages 1-3) showed lower scores on a vocabulary test. Prenatal exposure did not yield significant differences compared to those born after the famine.
  • Migrant-Stayer Analysis:
    • Individuals born between 1941-1958 (ages 1-18 during the famine) who stayed in Guangdong had significantly worse immediate word recall (0.806 points lower) compared to emigrants who moved to Hong Kong before the famine.
  • Exposure to famine during early adulthood (ages 19-36) did not show a significant long-term impact on either immediate or delayed word recall.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Cognitive Measures: The study relied on vocabulary tests and word recall tests. The authors acknowledge that using multi-dimensional measures of cognitive abilities would provide a more comprehensive assessment, as different cognitive indicators are affected by varying brain structures.
  • Data Limitations: While the migrant-stayer approach improved control, potential migration selectivity biases could still exist.
  • Future Research: The authors suggest future studies should explore the effects of early-life adverse experiences on a broader range of adult cognitive abilities, using more comprehensive data. They also emphasize the policy implications of their findings, calling for effective interventions to address childhood malnutrition, especially in the context of global uncertainties like the post-pandemic era.

Summary updated

Abstract

We examined the long-term impact of the 1959-1961 Chinese Famine on the survivors' cognitive performance in this study. Using data from the 2010 China Family Panel Study, our cohort comparison analysis showed that people who experienced the famine in early childhood (aged 1-3) had a lower score on a vocabulary test and that those who were exposed to the famine in utero did not differ from those born after the famine, probably due to positive selection for the in utero survivors. To deal with the problem of the lack of a comparable control group, we further applied a migrant-stayer comparison approach, with data from the 2016 China Family Panel Study and the 2017 Hong Kong Panel Study of Social Dynamics, to examine the effects of famine exposure at different life stages on adult cognition. We compared the people who stayed in Guangdong with the people who crossed the border to Hong Kong before the famine. The results showed that Guangdong stayers who experienced the famine when they were aged 1-18 had worse performance in immediate word recall. The findings suggested that exposure to malnutrition during childhood has long-term adverse effects on cognitive performance.
BibTeX
@article{zhang2022long,
  author = {Han Zhang and Wing‐Chung Ho},
  title = {{The Long-Term Effect of Famine Exposure on Cognitive Performance: Evidence from the 1959–1961 Chinese Famine}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph192416882},
}
Figure