The long-term associations between parental behaviors, cognitive function and brain activation in adolescence

Orwa Dandash, Nicolas Cherbuin, Orli Schwartz, Nicholas B. Allen, Sarah WhittleScientific 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This longitudinal fMRI study reveals that maternal behaviors in early adolescence can influence adolescent brain development and cognitive function. Specifically, positive maternal interactions are linked to reduced brain activation in key cognitive control regions during mid-adolescence, while aggressive maternal behavior is associated with slower reaction times on cognitive tasks in late adolescence. These findings highlight the enduring impact of parenting on neurocognitive development through adolescence.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Adolescence is a critical period of brain maturation, particularly in the frontal lobe, which underpins higher cognitive functions like impulse control and decision-making. While it's understood that parenting significantly shapes child development, the specific neurobiological mechanisms linking parental behaviors to cognitive performance and brain activation during adolescence remain underexplored. Previous research has hinted at associations between parenting styles and abnormal brain activation, but a longitudinal investigation directly connecting early parental behaviors to later cognitive function and brain activity in adolescents was lacking. This paper aims to bridge that gap by examining how maternal behaviors in early adolescence predict changes in cognitive performance and brain activation during mid- and late-adolescence.

Methods

The researchers employed a longitudinal design, collecting data from participants at three time points: early adolescence (12 years), mid-adolescence (16 years), and late adolescence (19 years).

  • Maternal Behavior Assessment: In early adolescence, maternal behaviors were assessed during two structured family interaction tasks: an event-planning interaction (EPI) and a problem-solving interaction (PSI). These interactions were video-recorded and coded for aggressive (e.g., contempt, anger) and positive (e.g., warmth, approval) behaviors.
  • Cognitive Task and fMRI: In mid- and late-adolescence, participants underwent functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) while performing the Multi-Source Interference Task (MSIT). The MSIT is a cognitive task designed to assess interference control and behavioral inhibition, reliably activating the cingulo-fronto-parietal (CFP) brain network. Participants' reaction times and accuracy were recorded during the task.
  • Data Analysis: Linear regression models were used to correlate maternal behaviors from early adolescence with fMRI activation and in-scanner behavioral scores from mid- and late-adolescence. Temporal differences in brain activation were also analyzed to track developmental changes.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Adolescent Brain Maturation is Dynamic: The study observed a significant reduction in inhibitory-control-related brain activation in the posterior parietal and cingulate cortices as participants transitioned from mid- to late-adolescence. This suggests ongoing maturation and refinement of cognitive control networks during this period.
  • Positive Parenting Buffers Cognitive Load: Higher levels of positive maternal behavior in early adolescence were associated with lower activation in the left parietal cortex and dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (DLPFC) during the MSIT in mid-adolescence. This counterintuitive finding might suggest that adolescents with more positive maternal experiences are more efficient in their cognitive processing, requiring less neural effort for tasks demanding cognitive control.
  • Aggressive Parenting Slows Cognitive Processing: Conversely, maternal aggressive behavior in early adolescence was linked to longer reaction times to incongruent trials (the more difficult trials) in late adolescence. This indicates that early exposure to aggressive parenting may have a lasting impact on the speed and efficiency of cognitive processing, particularly under demanding conditions.
  • Maternal Influence Persists: The findings strongly support the notion that maternal behavior during early adolescence can have a long-term influence on neurocognitive development throughout adolescence, impacting both brain activation patterns and behavioral performance on cognitive tasks.

Key Results

  • A significant reduction in MSIT activation (incongruent > congruent contrast) was observed in the posterior cingulate cortex, posterior parietal cortex, and visual cortex between mid- and late-adolescence.
  • Participants showed a significant behavioral effect on the MSIT, responding faster and more accurately to congruent trials than incongruent trials at both mid- and late-adolescence.
  • Longitudinally, reaction times to incongruent trials were significantly faster in late adolescence compared to mid-adolescence, with no change in accuracy.
  • Positive maternal behavior in early adolescence was associated with lower activation in the left DLPFC and posterior parietal cortex in mid-adolescence.
  • Maternal aggressive behavior in early adolescence was associated with longer reaction times to incongruent trials in late adolescence (p = 0.022, r = 0.265).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Sample Size and Variability: The study was limited by the number of participants for whom complete data were available, and the variability in maternal aggressive behavior was smaller than in positive behavior, potentially limiting the detection of effects.
  • Maternal Focus: The study primarily focused on maternal interactions, as the number of fathers participating in interviews was small. Future research should investigate the role of paternal behavior.
  • Laboratory vs. Real-World Interactions: The family interactions were conducted in a laboratory setting, which may differ from naturalistic interactions. However, the authors note that these lab-based interactions have shown good predictive validity.

Future work could explore the specific neural pathways mediating these associations and investigate the impact of other family members and broader social environmental factors. The findings also suggest potential targets for interventions aimed at supporting healthy adolescent neurocognitive development.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Parenting behavior has a vital role in the development of the brain and cognitive abilities of offspring throughout childhood and adolescence. While positive and aggressive parenting behavior have been suggested to impact neurobiology in the form of abnormal brain activation in adolescents, little work has investigated the links between parenting behavior and the neurobiological correlates of cognitive performance during this age period. In the current longitudinal fMRI study, associations between parenting behaviors and cognitive performance and brain activation across mid- and late-adolescence were assessed. Observed measures of maternal aggressive and positive behavior were recorded in early adolescence (12 years) and correlated with fMRI activation and in-scanner behavioral scores on the multi-source interference task (MSIT) during mid- (16 years; 95 participants) and late-adolescence (19 years; 75 participants). There was a significant reduction in inhibitory-control-related brain activation in posterior parietal and cingulate cortices as participants transitioned from mid- to late-adolescence. Positive maternal behavior in early-adolescence was associated with lower activation in the left parietal and DLPFC during the MSIT in mid-adolescence, whereas maternal aggressive behavior was associated with longer reaction time to incongruent trials in late-adolescence. The study supports the notion that maternal behavior may influence subsequent neurocognitive development during adolescence.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{dandash2021long,
  author = {Orwa Dandash and Nicolas Cherbuin and Orli Schwartz and Nicholas B. Allen and Sarah Whittle},
  title = {{The long-term associations between parental behaviors, cognitive function and brain activation in adolescence}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-021-90474-2},
}
Figure