The local and systemic response to SARS-CoV-2 infection in children and adults

Masahiro Yoshida, Kaylee B. Worlock, Ni Huang, Rik G.h. Lindeboom, Colin R. Butler, Natsuhiko Kumasaka, Cecilia Domínguez Conde, Lira Mamanova, Liam Bolt, Laura Richardson, Krzysztof Polański, Elo Madissoon, Josephine L. Barnes, Jessica Allen-Hyttinen, Eliz Kilich, Brendan C. Jones, Angus de Wilton, Anna Wilbrey-Clark, Waradon Sungnak, J. Patrick Pett, Elena Prigmore, Henry Yung, Puja Mehta, Aarash Saleh, Anita Saigal, Vivian Chu, Jonathan Cohen, Clare Cane, Aikaterini Iordanidou, Soichi Shibuya, Ann‐Kathrin Reuschl, A. Christine Argento, Richard G. Wunderink, Sean B. Smith, Taylor A. Poor, Catherine A. Gao, Jane E. Dematte, Gary Reynolds, Muzlifah Haniffa, Georgina Bowyer, Matthew Coates, Menna R. Clatworthy, Fernando J. Calero‐Nieto, Berthold Göttgens, Christopher O’Callaghan, Neil J. Sebire, Clare Jolly, Paolo De Coppi, Claire M. Smith, Alexander V. Misharin, Sam M. Janes, Sarah A. Teichmann, Marko Nikolić, Kerstin B. MeyermedRxiv 2021 · DOI

Abstract

While a substantial proportion of adults infected with SARS-CoV-2 progress to develop severe disease, children rarely manifest respiratory complications. Understanding the differences in the local and systemic response to SARS-CoV-2 infection between children and adults may provide important clues about the pathogenesis of the virus. This study presents a comprehensive single-cell multi-omics map of the human immune system and airway lining across the human lifespan, comparing healthy children to those with COVID-19 and contrasting them with adult cohorts. The findings reveal that children possess a unique "innate-like" immune state in their naive lymphocytes and a regenerative epithelial response that likely protects them from severe respiratory failure.

Introduction: The Pediatric Paradox

Since the emergence of the COVID-19 pandemic, a "pediatric paradox" has been observed: while SARS-CoV-2 can be lethal for adults, children rarely manifest severe respiratory complications. Understanding this discrepancy is crucial for developing better treatments for adults and understanding the fundamental maturation of the human immune system.

Previous research often focused on either blood or the respiratory tract in isolation. This study addresses that gap by utilizing triple-matched samples—nasal brushings, tracheal brushings, and peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs)—to track the infection's spatial dynamics from the site of entry to the systemic immune response.

Methodology and Data Integration

The researchers employed a suite of high-resolution multi-omic techniques to profile the cellular landscape:

  • scRNA-seq (Single-cell RNA sequencing): To analyze gene expression at the individual cell level.
  • CITE-seq: To simultaneously measure RNA and surface protein levels, providing high resolution for identifying specific immune cell subtypes.
  • VDJ Sequencing: To track the clonality of T and B cells, determining whether the immune system is utilizing a "memory recall" of specific clones or a diverse pool of new cells.

The Dataset

The study generated a massive healthy reference dataset, profiling 30 children across five developmental stages: neonates, infants, young children, children, and adolescents. This reference was then contrasted with data from a COVID-19 cohort consisting of 4 pediatric patients and 18 adult patients. In total, the study analyzed over 138,000 cells from the upper airways and 317,000 cells from the blood.

Key Findings

1. The "Fetal Legacy" in Pediatric Immunity

The healthy reference revealed that naive B and T cells in infants and neonates are not merely "blank slates." Instead, they carry a unique gene expression signature bearing hallmarks of innate immunity. This suggests that younger individuals maintain fetal-like immune characteristics that allow for a broad, rapid response to novel pathogens without requiring prior exposure.

2. Discovery of Inflammatory Epithelial Transit Cells (IETCs)

The study identified a novel inflammatory epithelial cell population termed Inflammatory Epithelial Transit Cells (IETCs). These cells represent a transitional regenerative state between secretory and ciliated cells. While found in healthy children, they were significantly enriched in both pediatric and adult COVID-19 patients, suggesting they are a primary regenerative response to viral-induced damage. These cells express high levels of S100A8 and S100A9 (calprotectin), which act as potent recruiters for neutrophils.

3. The Interferon Paradox

A striking difference was found in the interferon (IFN) response. Children with COVID-19 exhibited a more limited interferon-response signature in their airways compared to adults. In adults, a massive, late-stage interferon "storm" is often associated with severe tissue damage and hyper-inflammation. The pre-activated innate state in children may allow them to manage viral loads more efficiently, avoiding the need for a high-intensity, damaging systemic interferon blast.

4. Memory vs. Naive Response

Adult COVID-19 responses are dominated by "memory recall," characterized by the massive expansion of specific T-cell clones. In contrast, children show very little clonal expansion. Instead, their systemic response is defined by a higher proportion of innate lymphoid cells (ILCs) and non-clonally expanded naive T cells in the peripheral blood.

Spatial Dynamics and Viral Load

The highest viral loads were localized within goblet and ciliated cells of the airway epithelium. By studying matched blood and airway samples, the researchers observed that while the infection is localized in the airways, it triggers significant systemic shifts. In pediatric cases, there is a notable loss of monocytes and Natural Killer (NK) cells from the blood, likely because these cells have migrated to the respiratory tract to combat the infection at the source.

Limitations and Future Directions

While the healthy pediatric reference is robust, the COVID-19 pediatric cohort was limited (n=4) due to the rarity of pediatric hospitalizations during the study period. Additionally, the use of PBMCs for blood analysis excluded neutrophils; given the strong neutrophil-recruiting signature found in the airways, future studies using whole blood are necessary to complete the systemic picture. Finally, further research is required to determine if these innate-like signatures are even more pronounced in the majority of children who experience only mild or asymptomatic infections.

Conclusion

This research provides a highly granular reference for the study of immune responses in the airways and blood across the human lifespan. By identifying the unique innate-like signatures of the pediatric immune system and the regenerative role of IETCs, the study offers important clues into why children are naturally more resilient to SARS-CoV-2, potentially informing future therapeutic strategies for older populations.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract While a substantial proportion of adults infected with SARS-CoV-2 progress to develop severe disease, children rarely manifest respiratory complications. Therefore, understanding differences in the local and systemic response to SARS-CoV-2 infection between children and adults may provide important clues about the pathogenesis of SARS-CoV-2 infection. To address this, we first generated a healthy reference multi-omics single cell data set from children (n=30) in whom we have profiled triple matched samples: nasal and tracheal brushings and PBMCs, where we track the developmental changes for 42 airway and 31 blood cell populations from infancy, through childhood to adolescence. This has revealed the presence of naive B and T lymphocytes in neonates and infants with a unique gene expression signature bearing hallmarks of innate immunity. We then contrast the healthy reference with equivalent data from severe paediatric and adult COVID-19 patients (total n=27), from the same three types of samples: upper and lower airways and blood. We found striking differences: children with COVID-19 as opposed to adults had a higher proportion of innate lymphoid and non-clonally expanded naive T cells in peripheral blood, and a limited interferon-response signature. In the airway epithelium, we found the highest viral load in goblet and ciliated cells and describe a novel inflammatory epithelial cell population. These cells represent a transitional regenerative state between secretory and ciliated cells; they were found in healthy children and were enriched in paediatric and adult COVID-19 patients. Epithelial cells display an antiviral and neutrophil-recruiting gene signature that is weaker in severe paediatric versus adult COVID-19. Our matched blood and airway samples allowed us to study the spatial dynamics of infection. Lastly, we provide a user-friendly interface for this data 1 as a highly granular reference for the study of immune responses in airways and blood in children.
BibTeX
@misc{yoshida2021local,
  author = {Masahiro Yoshida and Kaylee B. Worlock and Ni Huang and Rik G.H. Lindeboom and Colin R. Butler and Natsuhiko Kumasaka and Cecilia Domínguez Conde and Lira Mamanova and Liam Bolt and Laura Richardson and Krzysztof Polański and Elo Madissoon and Josephine L. Barnes and Jessica Allen-Hyttinen and Eliz Kilich and Brendan C. Jones and Angus de Wilton and Anna Wilbrey-Clark and Waradon Sungnak and J. Patrick Pett and Elena Prigmore and Henry Yung and Puja Mehta and Aarash Saleh and Anita Saigal and Vivian Chu and Jonathan Cohen and Clare Cane and Aikaterini Iordanidou and Soichi Shibuya and Ann‐Kathrin Reuschl and A. Christine Argento and Richard G. Wunderink and Sean B. Smith and Taylor A. Poor and Catherine A. Gao and Jane E. Dematte and Gary Reynolds and Muzlifah Haniffa and Georgina Bowyer and Matthew Coates and Menna R. Clatworthy and Fernando J. Calero‐Nieto and Berthold Göttgens and Christopher O’Callaghan and Neil J. Sebire and Clare Jolly and Paolo De Coppi and Claire M. Smith and Alexander V. Misharin and Sam M. Janes and Sarah A. Teichmann and Marko Nikolić and Kerstin B. Meyer and Kerstin B. Meyer},
  title = {{The local and systemic response to SARS-CoV-2 infection in children and adults}},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1101/2021.03.09.21253012},
  howpublished = {medRxiv},
}

Loading related content...

Figure