The Lick AGN Monitoring Project 2016: Dynamical Modeling of Velocity-resolved Hβ Lags in Luminous Seyfert Galaxies

Lizvette Villafaña, P. R. Williams, Tommaso Treu, Brendon J. Brewer, Aaron J. Barth, U Vivian, Vardha N. Bennert, Heiko Vogler, Hengxiao Guo, Misty C. Bentz, Gabriela Canalizo, A. V. Filippenko, E. L. Gates, Frederick Hamann, M. D. Joner, Matthew A. Malkan, Jong-Hak Woo, Bela Abolfathi, Louis E. Abramson, Stephen F. Armen, Hyun‐Jin Bae, Thomas Bohn, Benjamin D. Boizelle, K. Azalee Bostroem, Andrew Brandel, Thomas G. Brink, Sanyum Channa, Michael C. Cooper, Maren Cosens, Edward Donohue, Sean P. Fillingham, D. González–Buitrago, Goni Halevi, Andrew Halle, Carol E. Hood, K. Horne, J. Chuck Horst, Maxime de Kouchkovsky, Benjamin Kuhn, Sahana Kumar, Douglas C. Leonard, Donald Loveland, Christina Manzano-King, I. M. McHardy, R. Michel, Melanie Kae B. Olaes, Daeseong Park, Songyoun Park, Liuyi Pei, Timothy W. Ross, Jordan N. Runco, Javier Sánchez, Bryan R. Scott, Remington O. Sexton, Jaejin Shin, I. Shivvers, Chance L. Spencer, Benjamin E. Stahl, Samantha Stegman, Isak Stomberg, S. Valenti, Jonelle L. Walsh, Heechan Yuk, WeiKang ZhengThe Astrophysical Journal 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper uses a sophisticated modeling technique to analyze the structure and dynamics of the Broad Line Region (BLR) in Seyfert galaxies, revealing that these regions are generally thick disks viewed at moderate inclinations. While no strong trends with luminosity were found, there's a hint of a connection between the shape of the Hβ emission line and the galaxy's accretion rate, suggesting a complex and possibly transient nature of these energetic galactic centers.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Active Galactic Nuclei (AGNs), powered by supermassive black holes (SMBHs) at their centers, are surrounded by a region of gas called the Broad Line Region (BLR). Understanding the BLR's geometry, kinematics, and how it relates to the central SMBH is crucial for accurately measuring SMBH masses and comprehending AGN physics. Reverberation mapping, a technique that tracks the time delay between variations in the AGN's continuum emission and its broad emission lines (like Hβ), has been a key tool. However, interpreting these time delays, especially when considering the line's velocity structure, is complex. This paper aims to overcome these challenges by employing a detailed dynamical modeling approach to disentangle the BLR's structure and kinematics, and to search for systematic trends related to luminosity and line profile shape.

Methods

The authors utilize a phenomenological modeling code called CARAMEL, which describes the BLR as a collection of test particles surrounding the SMBH. Gravity is the dominant force, and particles re-emit ionizing light as emission lines. The key innovation here is the dynamical modeling of the BLR. Instead of just inferring a transfer function, CARAMEL allows for the explicit modeling of particle distributions in space and velocity.

Key aspects of the CARAMEL model include:

  • Geometry: Described by parameters like opening angle (disk thickness), inclination, and radial distribution.
  • Dynamics: Modeled by parameters controlling the fraction of particles in circular orbits versus inflow/outflow, and the rotation of their velocities relative to escape velocity.
  • Continuum Modeling: Gaussian processes are used to model the AGN continuum light curve, allowing for interpolation and extrapolation and propagating uncertainties.
  • Likelihood Function: A Gaussian likelihood function compares the modeled and observed spectra, with a "statistical temperature" parameter (T) to account for model limitations and uncertainties.
  • Parameter Estimation: DNEST4, a diffusive nested sampling code, is used to explore the parameter space and derive posterior probability distributions for the model parameters.

This approach allows for a more direct and robust inference of BLR properties compared to traditional velocity-delay mapping.

Datasets

The primary dataset used in this paper comes from the Lick AGN Monitoring Project 2016 (LAMP 2016). This campaign involved photometric monitoring of nine Seyfert 1 galaxies and spectroscopic monitoring to capture the Hβ emission line. The authors also combine their results with data from previous reverberation mapping studies (LAMP 2008, AGN10, LAMP 2011, AGNSTORM, SSO) to create an extended sample for trend analysis.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • BLR as a Thick Disk: The Hβ-emitting BLR in these luminous Seyfert galaxies is consistently modeled as a thick disk, not a thin disk or a sphere, viewed at moderate inclinations. This suggests a more substantial, vertically extended structure.
  • Diverse Kinematics: While the overall geometry is similar, the internal dynamics (inflow vs. outflow vs. circular motion) show significant diversity among the observed AGNs.
  • No Strong Luminosity Trends: Despite expectations that higher accretion rates might drive outflows, the study found no clear correlation between AGN luminosity (or Eddington ratio) and BLR geometry or kinematics across their extended sample.
  • Marginal Line Profile-Eddington Ratio Link: A surprising finding is the marginal evidence for an anti-correlation between the shape of the broad Hβ line (specifically, the ratio of its full width at half-maximum to its dispersion) and the Eddington ratio, particularly when using the root-mean-square spectrum. This suggests that the accretion process might subtly influence the BLR's observable line profile.
  • Transient Conditions Hypothesis: The observed diversity in BLR structure and kinematics, coupled with the lack of strong systematic trends, supports the idea that AGNs might experience "weather-like" changes in their BLRs over relatively short timescales (months to years), rather than being in a permanently fixed state.

Key Results

  • The Hβ BLR in the nine LAMP 2016 galaxies is best described as a thick disk with moderate inclination angles.
  • Black hole mass estimates derived from the CARAMEL model are consistent with those obtained from traditional velocity-resolved reverberation mapping.
  • No significant correlations were found between BLR geometry/kinematics and AGN luminosity or Eddington ratio.
  • Marginal evidence (2.7σ) for an anti-correlation between line-profile shape (log(FWHM/σ)) and Eddington ratio was found when using the rms spectrum.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Simplifications: The CARAMEL model does not explicitly include photoionization processes or radiation pressure effects. The authors note that neglecting radiation pressure could bias results for high Eddington ratio AGNs, though their sample has moderate luminosities.
  • Limited Sample Size: While the study combines multiple datasets, the extended sample is still considered small and may not be fully representative of the entire AGN population.
  • Interpretation of Transfer Functions: The authors highlight the difficulty in interpreting velocity-delay maps directly and emphasize the benefit of their quantitative modeling approach.
  • Future Work: The authors plan to extend their analysis to investigate correlations between scale factor (related to BLR size) and black hole mass/Eddington ratio. They also suggest that future reverberation mapping campaigns with higher data quality and variability will be crucial for increasing statistical significance and improving our understanding of AGN BLRs.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract We have modeled the velocity-resolved reverberation response of the H β broad emission line in nine Seyfert 1 galaxies from the Lick Active Galactic Nucleus (AGN) Monitoring Project 2016 sample, drawing inferences on the geometry and structure of the low-ionization broad-line region (BLR) and the mass of the central supermassive black hole. Overall, we find that the H β BLR is generally a thick disk viewed at low to moderate inclination angles. We combine our sample with prior studies and investigate line-profile shape dependence, such as <mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" overflow="scroll"> <mml:msub> <mml:mrow> <mml:mi>log</mml:mi> </mml:mrow> <mml:mrow> <mml:mn>10</mml:mn> </mml:mrow> </mml:msub> <mml:mo stretchy="false">(</mml:mo> <mml:mi>FWHM</mml:mi> <mml:mrow> <mml:mo stretchy="true">/</mml:mo> </mml:mrow> <mml:mi>σ</mml:mi> <mml:mo stretchy="false">)</mml:mo> </mml:math> , on BLR structure and kinematics and search for any BLR luminosity-dependent trends. We find marginal evidence for an anticorrelation between the profile shape of the broad H β emission line and the Eddington ratio, when using the rms spectrum. However, we do not find any luminosity-dependent trends, and conclude that AGNs have diverse BLR structure and kinematics, consistent with the hypothesis of transient AGN/BLR conditions rather than systematic trends.
BibTeX
@article{villafana2022lick,
  author = {Lizvette Villafaña and P. R. Williams and Tommaso Treu and Brendon J. Brewer and Aaron J. Barth and U Vivian and Vardha N. Bennert and Heiko Vogler and Hengxiao Guo and Misty C. Bentz and Gabriela Canalizo and A. V. Filippenko and E. L. Gates and Frederick Hamann and M. D. Joner and Matthew A. Malkan and Jong-Hak Woo and Bela Abolfathi and Louis E. Abramson and Stephen F. Armen and Hyun‐Jin Bae and Thomas Bohn and Benjamin D. Boizelle and K. Azalee Bostroem and Andrew Brandel and Thomas G. Brink and Sanyum Channa and Michael C. Cooper and Maren Cosens and Edward Donohue and Sean P. Fillingham and D. González–Buitrago and Goni Halevi and Andrew Halle and Carol E. Hood and K. Horne and J. Chuck Horst and Maxime de Kouchkovsky and Benjamin Kuhn and Sahana Kumar and Douglas C. Leonard and Donald Loveland and Christina Manzano-King and I. M. McHardy and R. Michel and Melanie Kae B. Olaes and Daeseong Park and Songyoun Park and Liuyi Pei and Timothy W. Ross and Jordan N. Runco and Javier Sánchez and Bryan R. Scott and Remington O. Sexton and Jaejin Shin and I. Shivvers and Chance L. Spencer and Benjamin E. Stahl and Samantha Stegman and Isak Stomberg and S. Valenti and Jonelle L. Walsh and Heechan Yuk and WeiKang Zheng},
  title = {{The Lick AGN Monitoring Project 2016: Dynamical Modeling of Velocity-resolved Hβ Lags in Luminous Seyfert Galaxies}},
  journal = {The Astrophysical Journal},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3847/1538-4357/ac6171},
}
Figure