The LCOE Evolution and Grid Parity Analysis of Centralized Solar Photovoltaic: A Case Study of Ningxia, China

Lingling Mu, Yidan Gu, Yafeng Guo, Ping LiuFrontiers in Energy Research 2021 · DOI

Abstract

Achieving grid parity in 2021 is the goal of China’s photovoltaic development, which is not only on the user side but also on the generation side. Relevant studies indicated that distributed PV has realized grid parity basically in China, while centralized PV, which belongs to the generation side, still has some difficulties in achieving grid parity. Therefore, this paper takes Ningxia Province, which is abundant in solar resources, as the research object and compares LCOE with the traditional coal-fired price to analyze the situation of grid parity of the Pingluo project. It is found that this project cannot reach the goal of grid parity. Then, the future evolution of the local LCOE is analyzed, so as to determine the time of grid parity of Ningxia’s centralized PV power stations. In the calculation of LCOE, the presence and absence of environmental benefits and the general and optimistic forecast of cumulative installed capacity are combined into four scenarios. The results show that the centralized PV in Ningxia cannot achieve grid parity in 2021 under the four scenarios. However, in addition to the scenario that there are no environmental benefits and the cumulative installed capacity is generally forecasted and will reach grid parity of the generation side in 2023, the other three situations can achieve the goal in 2022. Moreover, the LCOE value is the lowest under the scenario of considering environmental benefits and the optimistic forecast of future installed capacity.

Introduction

China has set ambitious targets for solar photovoltaic (PV) energy to reach grid parity—the point where the cost of solar-generated electricity equals that of traditional coal-fired power—by 2021. While distributed PV systems (smaller, user-side installations) have largely met this milestone, centralized PV (large-scale utility plants) faces significant economic hurdles. These utility-scale plants must compete directly with the wholesale generation price of coal, often without the benefit of the retail price offsets available to distributed systems. As government subsidies phase out, understanding the financial trajectory of these projects is critical for future energy planning.

This study focuses on Ningxia Province, a region characterized by abundant solar resources. By analyzing the Levelized Cost of Electricity (LCOE) for centralized PV projects, specifically the Datang Pingluo Gaoren 55 MW project, this paper evaluates the feasibility of achieving generation-side grid parity and forecasts the timeline for this transition under various economic scenarios.

Methodology

The research utilizes a multi-stage modeling approach to forecast cost evolution:

  1. LCOE Modeling: A comprehensive formula was developed to calculate the LCOE, incorporating initial investment costs, operation and maintenance (O&M) expenses, technical degradation rates (0.7% annually), and a complex tax framework including VAT and income tax.
  2. Learning Curve Theory: To predict future cost reductions, the authors applied a single-factor learning curve. This model posits that as cumulative installed capacity doubles, the unit cost decreases by a fixed percentage—the "learning rate."
Cumulative installed PV capacity growth (2011-2019) providing the basis for learning curve calculations.
  1. Scenario Analysis: Four distinct scenarios were modeled by crossing two key variables: the inclusion of environmental benefits (revenue from China Certification Emission Reduction (CCER) carbon trading) and the capacity forecast (utilizing "General" versus "Optimistic" growth projections).

Data and Assumptions

The study draws on historical data and technical benchmarks:

  • Historical Context: Cumulative installation data for Ningxia from 2011 to 2019 was used to establish the local learning rate.
  • Economic Benchmarks: The local coal-fired electricity benchmark in Ningxia is set at 0.2595 CNY/kWh, while the average carbon market transaction price is 29.19 CNY/ton.
  • Technical Parameters: The model assumes a 25-year project lifetime and an 80% performance ratio.

Results and Discussion

The analysis reveals a calculated learning rate of 22% for Ningxia’s PV industry. This high rate suggests that for every doubling of cumulative capacity, investment costs drop significantly. However, despite these gains, the study found that the 2021 grid parity goal was not achievable for centralized PV in Ningxia. The LCOE for the pilot project remained at approximately 0.41 CNY/kWh, well above the 0.26 CNY/kWh coal benchmark.

Historical evolution of PV electricity prices in China (2011-2020), highlighting the gap between centralized resource areas and distributed prosumers.

The transition to grid parity is expected to occur shortly after the 2021 target:

  • Conservative Outlook: Under the scenario of general growth without carbon trading benefits, grid parity is projected for 2023.
  • Accelerated Outlook: In the other three scenarios (incorporating optimistic growth and/or carbon revenue), parity is achieved by 2022.

The inclusion of environmental benefits through carbon trading acts as a catalyst for the transition, potentially pulling the parity date forward by an entire year. Furthermore, as prices decline to meet coal benchmarks, the associated tax burden (VAT) also decreases, creating a positive feedback loop that further lowers the LCOE.

Conclusion

While centralized PV in Ningxia missed the 2021 grid parity deadline, it is on the cusp of economic self-sufficiency. By 2030, the LCOE is projected to plummet to as low as 0.10 CNY/kWh, making solar significantly cheaper than coal. Future success will depend on the maturity of the carbon market (CCER) and the management of "soft costs" like land use and grid connection fees, which may not follow the same hardware-driven learning curves. Better policy coordination between electricity and carbon markets remains essential as the industry moves beyond the subsidy era.

Summary updated

Abstract

Achieving grid parity in 2021 is the goal of China’s photovoltaic development, which is not only on the user side but also on the generation side. Relevant studies indicated that distributed PV has realized grid parity basically in China, while centralized PV, which belongs to the generation side, still has some difficulties in achieving grid parity. Therefore, this paper takes Ningxia Province, which is abundant in solar resources, as the research object and compares LCOE with the traditional coal-fired price to analyze the situation of grid parity of the Pingluo project. It is found that this project cannot reach the goal of grid parity. Then, the future evolution of the local LCOE is analyzed, so as to determine the time of grid parity of Ningxia’s centralized PV power stations. In the calculation of LCOE, the presence and absence of environmental benefits and the general and optimistic forecast of cumulative installed capacity are combined into four scenarios. The results show that the centralized PV in Ningxia cannot achieve grid parity in 2021 under the four scenarios. However, in addition to the scenario that there are no environmental benefits and the cumulative installed capacity is generally forecasted and will reach grid parity of the generation side in 2023, the other three situations can achieve the goal in 2022. Moreover, the LCOE value is the lowest under the scenario of considering environmental benefits and the optimistic forecast of future installed capacity.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{mu2021lcoe,
  author = {Lingling Mu and Yidan Gu and Yafeng Guo and Ping Liu},
  title = {{The LCOE Evolution and Grid Parity Analysis of Centralized Solar Photovoltaic: A Case Study of Ningxia, China}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Energy Research},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3389/fenrg.2021.711864},
}
Figure